Take-Up of Agricultural Insurance in India
How to cite
Patel, Dev; Breza, Emily; Chandrasekhar, Arun. 2024. "Take-Up of Agricultural Insurance in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014158. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14158-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We examine the flagship crop insurance scheme offered by the Indian government: Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY). We embed experimental variation into efforts to enroll farmers in this program, allowing us to shed light on the consequences of this agricultural insurance, the diffusion of information about the program within villages, and the relationship between informal risk sharing and formal insurance take-up.
Intervention
In the flyer arm, we distribute flyers throughout the village providing farmers with information about PMFBY and guidance on how to enroll.
In the meeting arm, we distribute flyers and additionally host an information session in the village to inform people about the scheme and answer questions. We also offer transportation to the local government office where farmers can enroll.
In the diffusion arm, we seed a random subset of farmers within each village with information about the scheme. Among this group, we also randomly select a subset of farmers to whom we offer a small incentive to be distributed conditional on their successful application to the program.
For each of the three arms listed above, we compare outcomes against people in control villages where information on the scheme was not distributed.
In a final set of villages, we elicit farmers’ willingness-to-pay for transportation to the local government office where farmers can enroll. We randomize the nature of this offer. First, we randomize the identity of a partner for each respondent. In some cases, the partner is in the farmers’ risk-sharing network, and we randomize whether this person has a perceived high- or low-covariance of agricultural risk with the respondent. In other cases, the partner is another person in the village who is not in the respondents’ risk-sharing network. Within these partner types, we randomize two more dimensions. First, we randomize whether we tell the respondent that we have also offered the transportation to the partner. Second, we randomize whether we tell the respondent that the partner may be informed if the respondent takes up the transportation.
In a follow-up of the treatment in summer 2025, we returned to villages in the meetings arm and conducted a new set of meetings as well as also offering mobile reminders about sign-up.
In a separate set of villages in 2025, we offer people a series of choices about spreading information about PMFBY. We approach random households using a right-hand rule, explain PMFBY to them, and then elicit their decisions about six scenarios. The order of the scenarios is randomized. In half of the scenarios, people are choosing about distributing information about PMFBY, and in the other half, they are choosing about distributing information about the weather. Crossed with these arms about the content of the information, there are three additional variations. In one, the respondent themselves is being offered a prize to go and distribute the information. In two others, the enumerator team is distributing the information. In the first enumerator-distribution, the identity of the respondent is kept private. In the second, the identity of the respondent is told to the recipient of the information. In each scenario, the respondent makes multipe choices among pairs of people, some of whom are randomly selected from the respondent's risk sharing network and some of whom are random other people in the village. One of these six scenarios and one of the choices will be implemented with a random probability. Additionally, there are four hypothetical scenarios involving a third person who will always be told the information. The arms in the hypotheticals are similarly placebo weather information vs. PMFBY information and visibility of the respondent.
Experimental design
Sampling disproportionately from areas at risk of flooding, we randomly assign villages to pure control arms (where no information is distributed) and to flyer and meeting arms. For the diffusion arm, we randomly select villages to be seeded, and then within village, randomly seed households. For the willingness-to-pay arm, we randomly draw partners for the respondent from a list of names elicited in previous surveys. We follow the same procedure for the information diffusion choices experiment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.