Referring into opportunities III: Field experiment on reactive help
How to cite
Munoz, Manuel. 2024. "Referring into opportunities III: Field experiment on reactive help." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014136. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14136-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this study, I investigate the role of social networks and biases in access to opportunities at a university setting, where such opportunities require third-party referrals, such as nominations and recommendations. I focus on university students as candidates and faculty members as referrers. Through a field experiment, I explore how these networks influence the request and receipt of referrals, potentially perpetuating biases that disadvantage certain groups in reactive help settings.
In the experiments, I inform students that they are offered an opportunity based on both their demographics and academic merit, requiring them to seek support from a faculty member to access the opportunity. I experimentally vary the information students disclose when requesting help—either focusing solely on academic merit (control condition) or including demographics. This variation allows me to evaluate how the type of information affects students' likelihood of seeking help, their choice of faculty members, and the likelihood of receiving assistance.
I conduct the study in two waves, one with only high merit student. The other with only low merit students. In each wave I use the same treatment variations.
This study complements a previous study on proactive help conducted in 2022, where faculty members where invited to nominate students to the same combined opportunity, access to an international training program plus participating in the lottery for a valuable prize. Data from the previous experiment allows me to identify proactive helpers, those who chose to make a referral in the first study. This consistency enables me to examine the relationship between proactive and reactive help. Specifically, I investigate whether faculty members who initiate help in the proactive experiment are also those whom students seek out in the reactive experiments.
The findings from these experiments will provide insights into the presence and extent of biases in referral processes and the effectiveness of awareness interventions in mitigating these biases. I aim to inform strategies for enhancing access to opportunities for underrepresented groups by increasing awareness of potential biases.
Intervention
Students are invited to register to participate in a beneficial opportunity: an international training program and a lottery for a valuable prize. To register, students are required to get an endorsement from a faculty member. The intervention varies the information students receive about the selection criteria for the opportunity. All students can be informed that they are selected because of their academic merit (high or low). In addition some are also informed that they are selected because of their demographics (e.g., gender, social class, etc). Students seeking an endorsement are provided a pre-defined message they use to request the support of a faculty member. The message may only disclose that the student is selected because of her academic merit, or it may also disclose that selection is based on demographics.
Experimental design
I will conduct a randomized control trial (RCT) with 4831 students and six groups, randomized at the level of the individual participant.
2561 students have high GPA (high academic merit) and are assigned into treatments as follows: 864 students in the first treatment arm will receive an invitation to take-up the beneficial opportunity and seek the endorsement of a faculty member. These students are informed they are chosen both because of their academic merit and their demographics, and the endorsement message makes this explicit. 864 students in the second treatment arm will receive the same information as in the first treatment, but the endorsement message used to request the help from a faculty member only states that selection is based on academic merit (and does not disclose any information on identities). 833 students in the third treatment receive the same invitation, but neither the students nor the faculty members receive any information that selection is identity-based and are only informed that it is based on the student's high academic merit.
2270 students have low GPA (low academic merit) and are assigned into the same treatments as follows: 776 in the first treatment, 757 in the second treatment, and 737 in the third treatment.
The experimental design allows me to address the following research questions:
(1) What is the impact of the information that selection is identity-based on the likelihood of seeking help?
(2) What is the impact of the information that selection is identity-based on the selection of faculty members to request the endorsement from?
(3) What is the impact of the information that selection is identity-based on the likelihood of receiving an endorsement?
(4) What is the impact of the information that selection is identity-based on the quality of the candidate?
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.