Evaluating Bundles of Resources and Information on Productivity and Gender- Driven Differences in the Rwanda Supply-Chain
How to cite
Steenkamp, Iris; Macchiavello, Rocco; Singh, Ameek. 2024. "Evaluating Bundles of Resources and Information on Productivity and Gender- Driven Differences in the Rwanda Supply-Chain." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014118. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14118-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Smallholder farmers in developing countries face multiple constraints to improve productivity: poor access to credit, labor, information, and capabilities. In such settings, alleviating any one constraint may not be enough, bundled interventions may be more effective in improving agricultural outcomes. Furthermore, the severity of these constraints often varies significantly across gender. We partner with a multi-national coffee buyer to provide and evaluate a bundle of services (Farmer Upgrading ‘Program’) that simultaneously relaxes resource and knowledge constraints faced by coffee farmers in the buyer’s supply chain in Rwanda. We experimentally test the effectiveness of improving access to labor, finance, and knowledge, both as stand-alone and in combination of interventions relaxing resource constraints. We will generate evidence on bundles of services which are likely to increase agricultural productivity and foster convergence between male and female smallholder farmers in Sub-Saharan Africa.
Intervention
In partnership with a leading coffee exporter, we design, implement and evaluate the impact of cash and labor-based incentive schemes on tree stumping behaviour by farmers in the Rwanda coffee chain. In both schemes, farmers receive financial incentives for stumping based on the number of trees they stump. In treatment one, farmers receive only financial incentives for stumping. In treatment arm two, farmers receive financial incentives for stumping and in-kind labor support for stumping. Both incentive packages are worth the same amount.
First, we examine the take-up of different incentive packages (i.e., schemes). Second, we evaluate the effectiveness of the different schemes on the adoption of tree-stumping practices. Third, we evaluate frictions in take-up of pre-paid labor. Additionally, we cross-randomize a digital intervention and evaluate its effectiveness in improving take-up of schemes and adoption of tree rejuvenation.
We roll out this tree stumping intervention in seven coffee washing stations (CWS) in Rwanda. The intervention builds on an earlier pilot (AEARCTR-0011838) in which conducted a pilot experiment to measure the impact of only financial incentives on take-up of tree stumping by farmers in Rwanda.
We expect the final paper to analyse the RCT, the large pilot RCT conducted in 2023 (AEARCTR-0011838) and interpret their results thorough the lens of a structural model of farm upgrading.
Experimental design
This study partly builds on an earlier pilot (AEARCTR-0011838) in which we designed and evaluated the impact of cash-based incentives on take-up of tree stumping by farmers in Rwanda. In this study, we examine the impact both cash-based and labor-based incentives on take=up of tree stumping. Additionally, we cross-randomize digital support intervention (Tx).
Our empirical strategy focuses on the following elements: i) take-up of tree rejuvenation schemes, ii) the (differential) impact of tree rejuvenation incentive schemes on tree stumping, iii) the effect of a digital support intervention (Tx).
We stratify random assignment within CWS, gender, past stumping, farm size, SMS delivery status, village, and delivery traceability.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.