Women's occupational choice: Impact of family, peers, and role models

How to cite

Sharma, Anisha; Deshpande, Ashwini. 2024. "Women's occupational choice: Impact of family, peers, and role models." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014111. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14111-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anisha Sharma* , Ashwini Deshpande

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014111
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14111-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-01-03 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14111

Abstract

Female labour force participation in India is among the lowest in the world. Women are significantly less likely to enter paid employment than men, and when they do, they tend to enter low-return occupations that are considered appropriate for women. Constraints on occupational choice include the attitudes of family members and peers, as well a lack of role models in non-traditional occupations. In this project, we aim to test the impact of these different constraints on the enrolment of women in vocational training programmes, and their subsequent entry into paid employment, as well as occupational choice. In one intervention, we randomly provide women and their family members with exposure to role models, who are young women from a similar geographic and socioeconomic background who have successfully completed training and started careers in high-return occupations. In another intervention, we additionally create a social setting where women and their families can interact with others like them, which can encourage them to successfully take on perceived social norms against entering non-traditional occupations. We measure the impact of these interventions on take-up of training, entry into high-return occupations, entry into paid employment, whether women migrate for work, as well as gender attitudes and beliefs about support for women’s work.

Intervention

All women in the study were visited by mobilisers who gave them information about vocational training opportunities with our partner organisation, and opportunities for paid work across 5 different sectors: beauty, sewing, healthcare, hospitality and automotives.

In one treatment arm, women and their family members were additionally shown a video by the mobilisers that featured four "role models", who were women from the same area who had completed vocational training in either healthcare or hospitality, and had gone on to begin successful careers. This video was shown to them on smart phones while they were being visited by mobilisers at their houses. At least one family member in a decison-making role (i.e. father, older brother, mother, husband, father-in-law or mother-in-law) was required to watch the video along with the main respondent. This is the role model intervention.

In the second treatment arm, women also received an invitation to attend an "open day event" along with other families in their area. They could bring along two other people with them and were encouraged to bring family members in decision-making roles. At the open day event, they were shown the same role model video, and they also got a chance to interact with one another and discuss any concerns they had about vocational training and employment. The event was around 90 minutes long and ended with lunch. Women and their family members received a travel subsidy to travel to and from their homes to the event (of Rs 150 or U$1.8 per person). This is the open day intervention.

Experimental design

We first completed a listing exercise where we listed eligible households in 126 villages across 8 blocks. Eligible households were those with at least one woman between the ages of 18-25 years, who did not, at the time of listing, have any children. Eligible women also needed to have completed at least up until Grade 10 of schooling, as this was a necessary requirement to enrol in the vocational training programmes offered by our partner organisation. We dropped those villages which did not have at least 15 eligible households.

2100 eligible households were randomly selected from the remaining eligible households. In those houses with more than one eligible woman, one woman was selected as the primary respondent.

These 2100 households were randomly allocated into one of control (C), treatment 1 (T1) or treatment 2 (T2) arms.

All women in the study were visited by mobilisers who gave them information about vocational training opportunities with our partner organisation, and opportunities for paid work across 5 different sectors: beauty, sewing, healthcare, hospitality and automotives.

Women in the first treatment arm (T1), and their family members, received the role model intervention.

Women in the second treatment arm (T2), and up to two family members, received the open day intervention.

Design details

Randomization method
2100 households were randomised into one of the 3 study arms: control, treatment 1 and treatment 2. This was done on a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization unit is the household. One eligible woman per household is randomly selected for inclusion in the study.
Clusters
2100 households
Observations
2100 households with one woman as a primary respondent per household. Additionally, one family member per household is also surveyed.
Arms
700 households in each of the control group and two treatment arms.
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes include interest in vocational training, enrolment in vocational training, choice of sector of vocational training, entry into paid employment, employment status 6 and 12 months after intervention, and whether the respondent has migrated for employment.
Secondary outcomes
To identify the mechanisms through which the intervention may affect enrolment in vocational training, employment and occupational choice, we will study the following sets of outcomes: 1) Gender attitudes of female respondents and a family member; 2) Perceptions of social support for women's work and specific occupational choices; 3) Increase in social networks as a result of the intervention; 4) Salience of intervention materials (i.e. how well the respondent remembers details about specific role models about whom they have been given information).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords