ENBLOC – Enabling energy transition in postsocialist housing cooperatives

How to cite

Frankowski, Jan; Vácha, Tomáš; Sokolowski, Jakub; Bełch, Wojciech; Mazurkiewicz, Joanna; Stara, Soňa; Prusak, Aleksandra; Nesladek, Michal. 2024. "ENBLOC – Enabling energy transition in postsocialist housing cooperatives." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014097. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14097-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jan Frankowski* , Tomáš Vácha , Jakub Sokolowski , Wojciech Bełch , Joanna Mazurkiewicz , Soňa Stara , Aleksandra Prusak , Michal Nesladek

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014097
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14097-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-08-01 – 2024-10-31
Countries
Czechia (), Poland ()
JEL codes
J21, L71, Q43
Secondary IDs
2021/43/I/HS4/03185
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14097

Abstract

In a low-trust society, collective decision-making is not easy. Driven by the statement that Central European inhabitants can be even ready to bear the costs of disengagement, we assess the housing preferences of various multi-family building residents in Poland and Czechia using a discrete choice experiment. This method is widely used to study willingness to pay for specific goods or services. In this specific study, it will assess preferences regarding renovation investments by multi-family building residents. Our survey, which includes a vignette experiment, will primarily focus on social and institutional attributes, potentially important but less studied within the context of enabling green investments and energy transition. Specifically, we set the investments with various beneficiaries, personal engagement, democratic procedures as well as short- and long-term individual accounts. The same survey will be conducted both online (CAWI) and in the field (CAPI) in Poland and Czechia during the same time. The online survey (CAWI) will cover a sample of 6,000 residents of multi-family buildings in Poland and Czechia. The field survey (CAPI) will cover a sample of 1,050 residents from three purposefully selected multi-family units [housing cooperatives]: two in Poland and one in Czechia. The results of the study will contribute to understanding the conditions of success and failure of developing green investments in multi-family housing in various country, ownership, and community contexts.

Intervention

Discrete choice experiment - study participants (aged 18-64) living in multi-family buildings will choose between hypothetical solutions aimed at renovation investments. The choice tasks are random and differ in terms of attributes and their levels.

Experimental design

The survey will consist of three parts. The first part will include closed questions about property ownership, basic information about the building, housing conditions, housing and energy expenditures, and individual residents' attitudes.

The second part will present vignettes with hypothetical renovation possibilities. Each participant will be shown five screens sequentially. Respondents' task will be to choose the most advantageous solution from their perspective from two presented in a random layout.
The list of attributes includes:
(1) type of beneficiary (attribute levels: close neighbours / distant neighbours / local community)
(2) various type of personal engagement (attribute levels: vote through the internet / raising hand on the meeting / discussing the scope of investment)
(3) degree of democratic choice (attribute levels: independent decision of the building manager / unanimous decision of citizens/ decision of the majority of citizens)
(4) monthly housing costs after the investment (attribute levels: {-30%,-20%,-10%, 0, 10%, 20%,30%} )
(5) real estate price value of the property in 5 years (attribute levels: {-30%,-20%,-10%, 0, 10%, 20%, 30%} )

The assumptions of experimental design are as follows:
a) All attribute choices are random: the only condition is that among the two options presented to the respondent, they must differ by at least one attribute level (there cannot be two identical options).
b) The order of attribute display is random.
c) The levels of quantitative attributes (range -30% to 30%, in increments of 10%) are also displayed randomly (with equal probabilities); they may be verified after the quantitative pilot study.
d) we include an additional question about the level of certainty of choices (slider 1-100%) under each vignette.
e) in both surveys (CAPI and CAWI) a respondent will read the experiment instructions (on tablet/computer/mobile phone) and select choices.

The third part will contain closed questions about residents' community attitudes, criteria for investing in energy transition, and socio-demographic information about the respondent and their household.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer system used to prepare the experiment. Each respondent will see five sets of two vignettes with attributes with a randomly selected level (1-3, with equal probabilities). Additionally, in each vignette in a set of five, a random value of cost/benefit will be drawn from a set of {-30%,-20%,-10%, 0, 10%, 20%,30%} (with equal probabilities).
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Choices clustered at the level of 4,000 individuals in Poland and 2,000 individuals in Czechia (CAWI) as well as 800 individuals in Poland and 250 individuals in Czechia (CAPI with residents living in three purposefully-selected housing cooperatives)
Observations
4,800 in Poland and 2,250 in Czechia = 7,050 in total
Arms
There is no division into treatment and control group. At least 7,050 individuals recieve five choice tasks each. The tasks are random as well as the attribute levels.
Primary outcomes
Willingness to pay for particular type of renovation activity considering: (1) type of beneficiary (close neighbours / distant neighbours / local community). (2) various type of personal engagement (vote through the internet / raising hand on the meeting / discussing the scope of investment). (3) degree of democratic choice (independent decision of the building manager unanimous decision of citizens/ decision of the majority of citizens). (4) monthly housing costs after the investment. (5) real estate price value of the property in 5 years.
Secondary outcomes
Heterogeneity of outcomes in terms of gender, education level, building ownership, income, housing conditions, heating preferences, housing/energy expenditures, beliefs about climate change, ecological attitudes, political and economic beliefs, innovation drive, pro individual/cooperative attitudes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords