The Impact of Price Incentives and Behavioral Nudges on Plant-Based Food Consumption: Evidence from a Nationwide Randomized Field Experiment

How to cite

SASAKI, Hiroki; Kyoi, Shinsuke. 2024. "The Impact of Price Incentives and Behavioral Nudges on Plant-Based Food Consumption: Evidence from a Nationwide Randomized Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014064. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14064-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hiroki SASAKI* , Shinsuke Kyoi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0014064
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14064-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-08-13 – 2025-01-31
Countries
Japan ()
JEL codes
Q18, D9, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/14064

Abstract

This study aims to investigate the effectiveness of "behavioral insights" and "monetary incentives" in promoting consumers' selection of plant-based foods (PBF), which are expected to address food issues such as the protein crisis and serve as a countermeasure against global warming. The research will be conducted through a randomized field experiment using purchase data collected via a smartphone household account book application. The data collected in this study is characterized by its ability to track individuals across stores, business formats, and product categories, allowing for a high-resolution capture of daily purchasing behavior. Moreover, this experiment is a "Natural Field Experiment" (NFE) where participants are unaware of their involvement, which is particularly advantageous in naturally observing consumers' daily food choices. This research aims to elucidate the following two points: (1) Using high-resolution data, we will rigorously determine the impact of consumer appeals utilizing behavioral insights, such as nudges, on PBF selection, including long-term effects. (2) Based on previous studies suggesting that information provision alone is insufficient to induce behavioral changes in food selection and that a combination with monetary incentives is crucial, we will examine the effect of monetary incentives (specifically, point cashback) on PBF selection, as well as the combined effect of nudges and monetary incentives. This study will contribute to our understanding of effective strategies to promote plant-based food consumption, addressing both environmental and nutritional challenges.

Intervention

The study targets receipt-buying and shopping app users and divides them into one control group and seven intervention groups. Among the vast amount of purchasing data, the primary interest of the researchers lies in the purchasing data related to plant-based food (especially plant-based meat). The interventions are implemented as follows:
The control group collects natural purchasing data.

Treatment groups 1 to 3 receive information provision:
- Treatment Group 1 receives information on the environmental impact of PBF (Plant-Based Food)
- Treatment Group 2 receives information on the health impacts of PBF
- Treatment Group 3 receives feedback on their purchase history based on the past six months of PBF purchase data before the intervention

Treatment groups 4 to 7 receive financial incentives for purchasing PBF. In these groups, users who purchase PBF and upload their receipts will be awarded points. Points, equivalent to about 10% of the product price, will be awarded and can be used as cash:
- Treatment Group 4 receives only financial incentives
- Treatment Group 5 receives environmental information plus financial incentives
- Treatment Group 6 receives health information plus financial incentives
- Treatment Group 7 receives feedback on purchase history plus financial incentives

Experimental design

This study analyzes the impact of nudges, price incentives, and the combination of both on the purchasing behavior of users of the largest receipt-buying and shopping app in Japan (6 million users). App users upload their purchase receipts daily, with any receipt being bought for 10 JPY. There are active and inactive users, but for this experiment, participants will be randomly selected from among the active users who upload receipts daily. Each group will consist of 400 app users, and since they are unaware of their participation, this experiment is a Natural Field Experiment. As explained above, they will be divided into a control group and seven treatment groups.

For Treatment Groups 1 to 3, a simple questionnaire introducing basic information about PBF (Plant-Based Food) and related nudges will be sent via the app on August 13, the start of the experiment. At this point, attribute information will also be collected. This is the method of information provision. Although it is difficult to determine whether users have viewed the information only through push notifications on the app, completion of the questionnaire will be considered confirmation that they have reviewed the provided information. Subsequently, purchasing data will be collected for approximately five months.

For the groups receiving financial incentives, an icon will be displayed in the app on August 13, indicating that users can earn additional points for purchasing plant-based meat. For users in Treatment groups 5 to 7, additional information on "environment," "health," and "purchase history" respectively is displayed on the app screen. Clicking this icon will be taken as recognition of the additional points offer for PBF purchases. Purchasing data will then be collected by the end of January. The campaign offering additional points for purchasing PBF (Plant-Based Food) will end approximately one month after its introduction. The purpose of this is to observe whether the purchasing habits formed before the incentive period continue after the financial incentives are removed.

In addition, a questionnaire will be administered to both the control and treatment groups approximately one month after the intervention, asking about their thoughts on plant-based meat and their purchasing intentions.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done by the shopping app developper
Randomization unit
individual revel
Clusters
N/A
Observations
3,200 individuals
Arms
We will set up a control group of 400 people and treatment groups 1 through 7 with 400 people each. Therefore, we will collect purchase data from a total of 3,200 individuals.
Primary outcomes
Extract the purchase history (amount, quantity, and average unit price) related to the following product data from all purchase records. Data collection items: ・Plant-Based Foods (PBF) (Soy Meat) ・Fresh Vegetables and Fruits ・Meat: Beef, Pork, Chicken, Processed Meat ・Seafood ・The Other Food Expenditure
Secondary outcomes
One month after the intervention, a survey will be conducted to ask about the consumption status of PBF and meat, impressions in terms of price, health, nutrition, and environmental impact, and attitudes towards switching from meat to PBF. These responses will constitute the secondary outcomes.
Sponsors
Name: JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number 23K05420 Location: Tokyo, JAPAN Url: https://www.jsps.go.jp/english/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords