Childcare expansion, Maternal employment and Child outcomes
How to cite
Lee, Jiyeong; Kang, Changhui; Koh, Kanghyock. 2024. "Childcare expansion, Maternal employment and Child outcomes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0014015. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.14015-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Government support for childcare has been provided through financial subsidies and after-school care programs. Over the recent decades, numerous researchers have studied the effects of childcare policies on maternal labor supply, child development, and family well-being, given the substantial rise in maternal labor force participation rates. Several countries, including Canada, Sweden, Denmark and Germany, offer universal childcare. Expanding childcare service has several benefits: It can increase maternal labor supply. Additionally, public childcare expansion can replace private childcare, which may not change maternal employment but can reduce household spending on childcare. On the other hand, expanding childcare services requires significant public funding, leading to higher taxes and potentially reduced economic efficiency.
We investigate the impact of Korea’s public childcare system expansion on maternal employment, child development, and the use of private tutoring services. In 2023, Korea recorded the lowest fertility rate globally, partly due to a working environment unfavorable to family life. Moreover, around 70% of parents send their children to private tutoring academies for better education and childcare, which has caused significant financial burdens. To address this, the Ministry of Education of Korea (MOE) recently expanded public childcare for children in primary schools, known as Neulbom schools. The government has integrated pre-existing after-school programs that separately offered learning opportunities and childcare services to students.
Neulbom schools have two notable features compared to the pre-existing programs. First, they offer the two programs free of charge from 1PM to 3PM, tailored to younger students’ developmental needs. Students can decide to join the entire program or only receive care services. Second, these programs are provided to any students who would like to participate without any prioritization. The pre-existing services prioritized children from dual-income families, low-income households, single-parent families, and those recommended by teachers. Initially, Neulbom schools target first-grade students in the first semester of 2024. The MOE plans to gradually extend the benefits to grades 2 to 6 by 2026. Thus, those from grades 2 to 6 attending Neulbom schools still remain under the same restrictions as current childcare services.
The introduction of Neulbom schools is exogenous to students and parents. The MOE released the list of participating schools two weeks before the semester begins, reducing the likelihood of parents transferring children due to the school's decision whether to participate in Neulbom schools. We exploit this quasi-experimental variations in the Neulbom schools to identify the causal effects of public childcare on maternal employment and child development, measured by children’s cognitive and non-cognitive abilities, life satisfaction and the use of private tutoring academies. We also examine the effects on workers hired by schools and the desired number of children, using detailed individual-level information collected through survey in the first half of this year.
We receive financial support from the MOE of the Republic of Korea.
Intervention
There are two interventions to first-grade students attending Neulbom schools in the first semester of 2024. The first intervention is two programs free of charge from 1PM to 3PM, tailored to the developmental needs of younger students. These programs include curriculum-based educational activities (such as Korean, reading and discussion, mathematics, science, English, and computers), and play-centered physical education, arts, and music, and other activities (such as Lego, linking cubes, board games, cross blocks, I-ringos, and wooden blocks). The first-grade students uniquely benefit from the programs of Neulbom schools in the first semester of 2024. Students can decide to join the entire program or receive care services only.
The second intervention is to remove priority restrictions for applying for the childcare services, unlike the pre-existing after-school programs and childcare services which give priority to children from dual-income families, low-income households, single-parent families, and those recommended by teachers.
Experimental design
1. Empirical Analysis
To evaluate the effects of the Neulbom school public childcare expansion in Korea on maternal employment, child development, the substitution of private care services, the number of workers hired by schools, and the desired number of children, we exploit the quasi-experimental variations in the introduction of Neulbom schools across grades and schools in the first semester of 2024.
We employ a difference-in-difference framework by estimating equation (1) for students in grade1-4:
Y_ijg=α_0+τ_g+λ_j+δ_y1 TS×TG+X_ijg^' β_0+ε_ijg (1)
where TS is a dummy variable indicating whether schools are Nuelbom schools (treated school) and TG is also a dummy variable indicating whether the grade is first grade in Nuelbom schools (treated grade). The subscript i,j,g refer to students, schools and grades, respectively. Y includes several outcomes as explained in prior subsection. X includes individual and household characteristics such as household income, sex of students and whether the household is a multicultural family.
The parameter of interest of is δ_y1 which captures the differences in the aforementioned outcome variables of interest between the first- and other-grade students in Neulbom schools compared to those of non-Neulbom schools. Even in Neulbom schools, students in first grade and their parents can choose to utilize the programs offered by Neulbom schools. According to the MOE data, 74.3% of first-grade students are attending Neulbom schools. Therefore, δ_y1 captures the ITT (intention-to-treat) effect.
We examine the effect of Neulbom schools on several outcomes for compliers-those who utilize the programs and childcare services provided by Neulbom schools-by estimating equation (2) and (3) using an instrumental variable and a difference-in-difference model. We predict the proportion of students utilizing the services offered by Neulbom schools with equation (2) and use it in equation (3) to estimate the parameter of interest, δ_IV, which captures the effect of Neulbom schools on compliers.
P_ijg=α_1+τ_g1+λ_j1+δ_P TS×TG+X_ijg^' β_1+η_ijg, (2)
Y_ijg=α_2+τ_g2+λ_j2+δ_IV (hat of P_ijg)+X_ijg^' β_2+ψ_ijg, (3)
where we follow the same notations as in equation (1). P is a dummy variable indicating whether students attend Neulbom schools or not. We predict the proportion of students utilizing the services offered by Neulbom schools with equation (2). Then, to estimate the parameter of interest, δ_IV, which captures the effect of Neulbom schools on compliers, we estimate equation (3) with the predicted value of P, P ̂.
We acknowledge that δ_y1 or δ_IV may capture the effects of other events occurring in 2024 other than the introduction of Neulbom school on private tutoring expenses and maternal employment. To enhance the robustness of our analysis, we estimate the false effects of the Neulbom schools by using data from 2023 and compare those with the effects during 2024, using a difference-in-difference-in-difference (DDD) framework. In particular, we estimate the below equation (4):
Y_ijg=α_3+β_31 TT+β_32 TS+β_33 TG+γ_31 TT×TS+γ_32 TT×TG+γ_33 TS×TG+δ_y2 TT×TS×TG+φ_ijg, (4)
where we follow the same notations as in equation (1). TT is a dummy variable indicating the timing of the introduction of Neulbom schools. δ_y2 captures the differences between the effect of Neulbom schools in 2024 and 2023.
2. Data Collection and Key Outcomes
We are collecting data through surveys for sampled students and parents to use detailed individual level information on education and employment in the first half of 2024 and 2023. Our research team, in collaboration with MOE, developed a survey instrument, and we summarize our main outcome variables above. These are categorized into five main areas: 1) employment, 2) education, 3) household finance, 4) life satisfaction, and 5) family. Note that we are collecting data for both 2023 and 2024 based on participants’ recollections, enabling us to conduct robustness analysis and verify that the behaviors are consistent across students within the same school.
(To present the experimental design decently, attached is pdf file in Material section.)
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.