Kinder to the environment: A game-theoretic approach to green trade-offs (Add-on Studies 1 and 2)

How to cite

Tay, Swee Kiat; Leong, Ching; Agarwal, Sumit. 2024. "Kinder to the environment: A game-theoretic approach to green trade-offs (Add-on Studies 1 and 2)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013995. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13995-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Swee Kiat Tay* , Ching Leong , Sumit Agarwal

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013995
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13995-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-08-01 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C90
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13995

Abstract

We conduct two coin-toss experiments (Add-on Studies 1 and 2) with a representative target sample of 5,000 participants each, using Dynata’s online panel. Each participant is randomly assigned to a pair of entities and instructed to toss a coin twice. Participants are asked to report the results of their coin tosses to determine the entity that will receive a USD 5 reward (they can choose to lie). Our main aims are to examine (1) whether people would act dishonestly for one entity instead of another in each trade-off context (e.g., Will people act dishonesty to benefit themselves at the expense of the environment?) (hypotheses about specific trade-off contexts), (2) whether people’s dishonesty to benefit a given entity depends on trade-off context (e.g., Will people act dishonestly to benefit themselves more if it is at the expense of a stranger than if it is at the expense of a random stranger?) (hypotheses across trade-off contexts), and (3) whether people would act less dishonestly when given the option to toss a coin either in private or on a platform where they may be monitored (Add-on Study 2) than when instructed to toss a coin in private (Add-on Study 1).

Experimental design

Both Add-on Study 1 and 2 have a 5 (entity pair) x 2 (probability split) design (for a total of 10 trade-off contexts).

Participants are randomly assigned to one of five entity pair conditions for which their responses determine which entity a USD 5 reward is allocated to: (1) self–environment, (2) environment–stranger, (3) self–charity, (4) charity–stranger, and (5) self–stranger. Each entity pair condition is further divided into two probability split conditions, one where the expected probability of winning the USD 5 is 25% for the first entity in the pair (and thus, 75% for the second entity), and another where the expected probability of winning is 25% for the second entity in the pair.

Add-on Study 1 instructs participants to toss the coin in private, while Add-on Study 2 gives participants the option to toss the coin either in private or on a platform where they may be monitored.

Participants in all studies and conditions are instructed to toss a coin twice and are told that a USD 5 reward will be given to one of two entities depending on the coin toss results. Participants are told that landing the coin on Heads (or Tails for half of the participants) on both coin tosses would result in one entity winning the reward (expected probability is 25%), while all other outcomes would result in the other entity winning the reward (expected probability is 75%).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation procedure is scripted by Dynata.
Randomization unit
For each of the 10 identified countries, randomisation into the 10 conditions is at the individual-level.
Clusters
5,000 individuals for each of Add-on Studies 1 and 2. Due to Dynata’s data collection method, 10-15% more participants may be collected.
Observations
5,000 individuals for each of Add-on Studies 1 and 2, 10-15% more participants may be collected.
Arms
For each of Add-on Studies 1 and 2, sample size is at least 50 for each of the 10 conditions.
Primary outcomes
Participants’ reported results of their coin tosses, and consequently, the allocation of USD 5 to either entity of their assigned pair (i.e., in the self–environment entity pair condition, the outcome variable is whether self or the environment won the USD 5).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords