Disentangling the Drivers of Taste Discrimination Using List Experiments.

How to cite

Listo, Ariel; Muñoz, Ercio; Sansone, Dario. 2024. "Disentangling the Drivers of Taste Discrimination Using List Experiments.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013989. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13989-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ariel Listo* , Ercio Muñoz , Dario Sansone

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013989
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13989-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-07-15 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13989

Abstract

This study seeks to advance our understanding of labor market discrimination by disentangling whether preferences by employers, co-workers, or customers may drive discrimination against sexual and gender minority individuals in the workplace. We partner with a local firm to recruit a large, nationally representative sample of individuals in Chile. We exploit an incentivized, double list experiment designed to elicit preferences free of social desirability bias. Additionally, the experiment is complemented with a real-stakes decision problem to address hypothetical bias. Specifically, participants can choose to donate their earnings from the study to a charitable organization with a mission to improve the welfare of sexual and/or gender minorities in Chile. Additionally, we compare findings from the list experiment with responses from direct questions to estimate the size of the social desirability bias. Lastly, we will conduct heterogeneity analyses by socio-economic variables, demographics, and employment status among other characteristics.

Experimental design

We use a double list experiment, a variant of the original list experiment pioneered by Miller (1984). In a regular list experiment, participants are either assigned to a control or a treatment group. In the control group, participants are given a list with a set of statements and asked to indicate how many of those statements are true for them. In the treatment group, participants are given the same list with the same set of statements plus one additional sensitive statement (e.g., a statement about attitudes towards LGBTQ+ individuals). The difference in means between the treatment and control group is the estimated share of the population with the key sensitive attribute.

In our case, we exploit the double list experiment technique to increase power, following Glynn (2013). For each sensitive statement, we will have two lists (i.e., Lists 1A and 1B), designed to be positively correlated. Some participants will be randomized into List 1A (control) and List 1B + Key Sensitive Statement (treatment). Other participants will be randomized into List 1A + Key Sensitive Statement (treatment) and List 1B (control). Some participants will get List 1A first, others will get List 1B first (order will be randomized). The differences-in means between control and treatment groups from both lists will be averaged and that will be the share of the population with that key sensitive attribute.

Design details

Randomization method
As mentioned above, to randomize which lists present the key sensitive statement and the order in which lists are presented, participants will be randomized into one of the following 6 paths: • Path 1: List 1A + Key, List 1B, List 2A + Key, List 2B, List 3A + Key, List 3B • Path 2: List 1B + Key, List 1A, List 2B + Key, List 2A, List 3B+ Key, List 3A • Path 3: List 2A + Key, List 2B, List 3A + Key, List 3B, List 1A + Key, List 1B • Path 4: List 2B + Key, List 2A, List 3B + Key, List 3A, List 1B + Key, List 1A • Path 5: List 3A + Key, List 3B, List 1A + Key, List 1B, List 2A + Key, List 2B • Path 6: List 3B + Key, List 3A, List 1B + Key, List 1A, List 2B + Key, List 2A Randomization will be done by a computer (Qualtrics).
Randomization unit
Individual level randomization
Clusters
Our goal is to run an initial pilot on online platform Prolific with approximately 800 participants. This is to check whether there are any issues with the instructions, code, or the software. Additionally, pilot participants on Prolific will be randomized into either the list experiment and the direct questions or only the direct questions. This is to check that direct question responses are not affected by the order in which they are presented with respect to the list experiments. After the pilot phase in Prolific, our local partner in Chile, DATAVOZ, will conduct a set of cognitive interviews with 10 participants. Subsequently, DATAVOZ will run a small pilot, a soft launch, and a main sample with a total of around 4,000 participants. Data from the initial Prolific pilot and from the cognitive interviews will not be combined with the main sample. On the other hand, if there are no issues after the small DATAVOZ pilot and soft launch, these data will be combined with the main sample.
Observations
Approximately 800 Chilean resident participants recruited via online platform Prolific. Approximately 4,000 DATAVOZ participants: 10 cognitive interview participants, 20 small pilot participants, 200 soft launch participants, and approximately 3,800-4,000 main sample participants.
Arms
We strive to have an equal number of participants randomized into the each of the six paths that vary which lists contain the sensitive statements and the order of the lists (i.e., Paths 1-6, as described above). We will use Qualtrics’s “Evenly Present Elements” feature when randomizing participants into each path. Local partner firm, DATAVOZ, will recruit participants in Chile based on sex, region, and age quotas with the goal of achieving a representative sample of the Chilean population along these three dimensions.
Primary outcomes
i) The average differences-in-means between control and treatment groups from all lists for all key sensitive statements (using the list experiment data). ii) The answers to the direct sensitive questions (using the survey data). iii) The differences between i) and ii). iv) The portion of an endowment that participants choose to donate to a charity versus keep for themselves and how it correlates with i) and ii).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords