Banking for Boomers – A Field Experiment on Internet Banking Adoption

How to cite

Hartinger, Katharina; Streich, David; Sarrazin, Erik. 2024. "Banking for Boomers – A Field Experiment on Internet Banking Adoption." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013985. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13985-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Katharina Hartinger* , David Streich , Erik Sarrazin

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013985
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13985-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-07-12 – 2025-08-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O33, G21, I21, J24, D12, D91, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13985

Abstract

Internet banking adoption is low among “Boomers” in Germany and other developed countries although they hold considerable wealth. We develop education concepts to foster internet banking adoption and evaluate them in a field experiment with elderly clients of a large German savings bank. Specifically, we use traditional knowledge-based approaches as well as approaches that focus on social connection and teach non-technical adoption skills – since fear of failure and technophobia are key obstacles to internet banking adoption. We assess the effectiveness of these approaches based on individual log-in and transaction data and use two surveys (pre-survey and post-survey) to identify key mechanisms.

Intervention

We conduct a field experiment with elderly customers of a large German savings bank to study the effect of different education approaches for technology adoption and lifelong learning on internet banking (IB) adoption at the extensive and at the intensive margin. We use traditional information-based approaches and approaches emphasizing non-technical adoption skills in a social learning context. Our target group consists of clients aged 50-85 who have not used internet banking in the recent past.
In total, there are four experimental groups: i) silent control group that we do not contact, ii) baseline treatment group (traditional, technical information-based approach), iii) non-technical treatment group I (coaching at home), iv) non-technical treatment group II (coaching in person). Note that participants never log into their own private internet banking as part of the training for data protection reasons. Instead, we use a demo tool.

Experimental design

Respondents to a call for participation sent out by the bank in July 2024 are randomly assigned (subject to some restrictions outlined in the experimental details below) to one of three treatment conditions (baseline, non-technical treatment I and non-technical treatment II) with a limited number of slots available in the non-technical treatments due to budget constraints.
Those in the baseline treatment group receive training material containing all technical information about the key functions of internet banking. Those in the non-technical groups receive additional material that addresses non-technical skills in addition and that is designed to be worked with at home (non-technical group I) or in an in-person course with peers (non-technical group II). All material is made available through a designated online platform, which also provides video summaries of the material.
We, thus, use a between-subject design. Survey capacities permitting, we plan to include some survey measures before and after the treatment to use within-subject variation in the analysis of mechanisms.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization. Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
We invite 23,500 clients who have not recently used internet banking (10,000 by letter, 13,500 by email) to participate. We expect a response rate of 2 percent. Update October 2024 (before final intervention data is available): We invited 25,982 customers who had not recently used IB (12,482 by letter, 13,500 by letter) to participate.
Observations
Update October 2024 (before final intervention data is available): We invited 25,982 customers who had not recently used IB (12,482 by letter, 13,500 by letter) to participate.
Arms
Silent control: 1,725 (725 from the group of clients we could have contacted via email) Main sample: Baseline treatment: 99 individuals Non-technical treatment I: 34 individuals Non-technical treatment II: 200 individuals Full sample: Baseline treatment: 252 individuals Non-technical treatment I: 49 individuals Non-technical treatment II: 250 individuals
Primary outcomes
Internet banking adoption (extensive and intensive margins); treatment take-up, attrition, effects of non-random assignment
Secondary outcomes
IB beliefs and perception, IB skills, technophobia, non-technical adoption skills (i.e., emotional regulation, coping strategies, ...) Heterogeneity analysis by gender (see large literature on financial dependence), age (exploratively, to shed more light on the understudied group of elderly in the context of lifelong learning), training completion, and baseline skills.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords