Competition, Cheating and Feedback

How to cite

Weidenholzer, Elke; Albertazzi, Andrea. 2024. "Competition, Cheating and Feedback." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013949. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13949-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elke Weidenholzer* , Andrea Albertazzi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013949
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13949-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-09-19 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91, D8, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13949

Abstract

We propose an online experiment to study the role of feedback on dishonesty in a competitive setting. The effects of competition and feedback on dishonest reporting behaviour have been widely studied in the literature. While some research suggests that competition can increase unethical conduct, others have found that competitive environments can also promote integrity and fairness. Similarly, the impact of performance feedback on dishonest behaviour is mixed, with studies showing either an increase or a decrease in cheating. The experiment aims to shed light on the interplay between competition and feedback, and their joint influence on individuals' propensity to misreport outcomes. In the experiment, subjects have an incentive to misreport a random outcome in their favour. We study how mis-reporting such an outcome is affected by the payment scheme (individual piece-rate vs winner takes all contest) and by the information about others' choices (no information vs past reports). Moreover, we study whether the effect of competition will carry over and affect individuals' misreporting in a subsequent round with a piece-rate payment scheme.

Intervention

There are two treatment dimensions:

* Incentive scheme: piece-rate vs winner-takes-all contest
* Available information about another participant/opponent: no information vs information about their past behaviour in the experiment

Experimental design

We propose an online experiment studying the role of competition and feedback on dishonesty. The experiment consists of three parts. In each part, participants can roll a virtual four-sided die 20 times and report each outcome. Each outcome is associated with a certain amount of points ranging from 0 to 3.

In Part 1, all subjects receive a piece rate payment corresponding to the total sum of points associated with their reported outcomes.

In Part 2, participants are assigned to one of the following treatments:

1) Ind No F: same as part 1

2) Ind F: same as part 1, but additionally, before rolling the die, the subjects receive information about the distribution of reports made by another random participant in part 1.

3) Comp No F: same as part 1, but subjects are competing in a winner-takes-all contest and will only be paid if they earn more points than another random participant they are matched with.

4) Comp F: same as (3), but additionally, before rolling the die, subjects receive information about the distribution of reports in part 1 made by the random participant they have been matched with in part 2.

Part 3 is identical to Part 1.

In Part 2, treatments (3) and (4), the amount of points associated with each die roll outcome is doubled in order to keep monetary incentives comparable across parts (assuming a 50% probability of winning).

At the end of the experiment, we elicit beliefs about others' behaviour, risk preferences, willingness to compete, and participants' sex at birth.

The experiment will be conducted online via Qualtrics and will involve real-time interaction thanks to SMARTRIQS software. We will recruit participants on Prolific and use a US subject pool. A typical session will last approximately 15 minutes, and participants will receive a fixed fee of £1.50 plus a performance-based bonus payment, resulting in an expected total compensation of around £18 per hour.

Additional treatments: upon funding availability, we will run a further experiment to elicit third-party beliefs on behaviour in our main experiment.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation is performed on the online platform. Participants will blindly self-select in one of the four experimental conditions without prior knowledge.
Randomization unit
The randomization is done on the individual participant. Each participant is independently assigned to one of the experimental conditions.
Clusters
600 human subjects
Observations
Participants, failing an attention test at the beginning of the experiment will be dropped. Because of the interactive nature of the experiment, some participants may drop out during the experiment due to time constraints. Thus, if a participant drops out, the person he is paired with must also drop out. This will make the observations of the whole pair unusable. For this reason, we plan to collect at least 200 "usable" participants per experimental condition. We will stop collecting data once we have reached this number for each treatment. This will give us a total of at least 600 subjects.
Arms
200 subjects per treatment. We will recruit participants on Prolific from the US sample with an approval rate of at least 99% and fluent in English.
Primary outcomes
Average points obtained in each part of the experiment.
Secondary outcomes
Binary variable equal to one if the average points obtained in one part are greater than 2. Beliefs about others' behaviour.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords