Elevating Positive Narratives: WhatsApp Campaign Effects on Migrant-Host Relations in Colombia
How to cite
Vasquez-Cortes, Mateo; Asimovic, Nejla. 2024. "Elevating Positive Narratives: WhatsApp Campaign Effects on Migrant-Host Relations in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013937. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13937-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In recent times, migration has surged globally, accompanied by an increase in negative narratives about migrants and xenophobia. This presents significant challenges for integrating migrants into new communities, even in countries with deep cultural, linguistic, and historical ties to the migrant community. Our study, set in Colombia, aims to examine the effects of a video campaign that counteracts negative stories by elevating positive interactions and experiences between Venezuelan migrants and Colombians, highlighting the migrants' contributions to the host community. To do so, we use WhatsApp for a communication campaign featuring videos of positive experiences between Colombians and Venezuelans, co-created with Innovations for Poverty Action and Barómetro de Xenofobia. This study evaluates the impact of receiving these videos – either directly or with an opportunity to comment on them in mixed groups of Venezuelans and Colombians, mimicking co-watching – on group relations, social norms, social integration, and attitudes toward migration policies. Recognizing the importance of both migrant and native attitudes for successful integration, our experimental design measures the campaign's impact on both groups.
Intervention
This experiment uses a between-subjects design to examine the impact of a communication campaign – created in collaboration with Innovations for Poverty Action and Barómetro de Xenofobia – targeting biases against Venezuelan migrants in Colombia. Against the backdrop of increased global migration and rising negative narratives about migrants, this study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of a WhatsApp-based intervention.
Participants assigned to the treatment group will receive two 3-minute videos simultaneously via WhatsApp. Each video features interviews with three different individuals: the first with Colombian interviewees and the second with Venezuelan interviewees, highlighting positive interactions and contributions of Venezuelan migrants to Colombian society. The order in which these videos are received will be randomized to minimize any sequence effects. In one treatment arm, participants will also have the opportunity to discuss the videos in mixed groups of Venezuelans and Colombians, creating an opportunity for them to exchange thoughts on the videos and connect with one another.
In contrast, the control group will receive a modified version of the video where the narratives in these videos will not explicitly focus on migration or integration, serving as a placebo condition to isolate the impact of the migration-focused content in the treatment videos. Additionally, a pure control group will receive no experimental treatment, providing a baseline against which the effects of the intervention can be measured.
The study will assess various outcomes, including group relations, social norms, social integration, and attitudes toward migration policies. We this design, we seeks to provide empirical insights into how elevating positive narratives can influence attitudes and perceptions between migrants and the host society.
Experimental design
This experiment employs a between-subjects design. Treated participants will receive a communication campaign consisting of two videos of approximately 3 minutes, each with 3 different interviewees (one video with 3 Colombian, other with 3 Venezuelan interviewees). Both videos will be sent at the same time in random order. Additionally, the control group will receive a different version of the video with some of the same interviewees but with narratives that are not explicit about migration and integration stories. There will also be a pure control that will receive no experimental treatment.
The comparisons between the arms will be conducted with the aim of allowing us to:
1) Understand the effects of exposure to narratives that emphasize positive experiences between Venezuelans and Colombians compared to no exposure to any narrative at all (T0) or exposure to Venezuelans and Colombians speaking on non-migration-related topics (T1); 2) Understand how exposure to such narratives in video form, coupled with an opportunity to discuss this topic with others, shapes the effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.