Menu Training and Vendor Linkages in school feeding programs to support Smallholder Farmers in Nigeria

How to cite

Andam, Kwaw; Amare, Mulubrhan; Gelli, Aulo; Abay, Kibrom; Kosec, Katrina; Bamiwuye, Temilolu; Edeh, Hyacinth; Adeyanju, Dolapo; Idowu-Ogundele, Ifetayo; Ekpo, Adaku; Udoh, Nsikak. 2024. "Menu Training and Vendor Linkages in school feeding programs to support Smallholder Farmers in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013936. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13936-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kwaw Andam* , Mulubrhan Amare , Aulo Gelli , Kibrom Abay , Katrina Kosec , Temilolu Bamiwuye , Hyacinth Edeh , Dolapo Adeyanju , Ifetayo Idowu-Ogundele , Adaku Ekpo , Nsikak Udoh

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013936
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13936-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-06-10 – 2024-10-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13936

Abstract

The project aims to pilot linking school feeding programs with smallholder farmers who can supply food to school feeding programs. We aim to achieve this through two types of interventions: (i) training of school vendors to improve and tailor school menus; and (ii) creating linkages between school vendors and smallholder farmers. Thus, the project targets both vendors/cooks involved in school feeding programs and potential smallholder farmers who can be linked with school feeding programs. We plan to conduct this pilot study in Osun State, located in the South-West region of Nigeria. Osun is recognized as one of the more successful states in implementing the Nigerian Homegrown School Feeding Program (NHGSFP) and is currently the only state where the program is active. Through this initiative, we aim to generate evidence that can improve program efficiency by analyzing menu plans and procurement procedures. Using this evidence, we intend to collaborate with the Government of Nigeria (GoN) and the World Food Programme (WFP) to extend successful interventions to other states across the country. The primary reference groups for this study are the cooks/vendors and smallholder farmers involved in sales to cooks supported by the school feeding program. We target all cooks involved in school feeding services and smallholder farmers in the targeted communities who are able to supply the food to the cooks, including produce oil-palm, sweet potatoes, yam, cocoyam and vegetables.

Intervention

The project aims to pilot linking school feeding programs with smallholder farmers who can supply food to school feeding programs. We aim to achieve this through two types of interventions: (i) training of school vendors to improve and tailor school menus; and (ii) creating linkages between school vendors and smallholder farmers. Thus, the project targets both vendors/cooks involved in school feeding programs and potential smallholder farmers who can be linked with school feeding programs. We plan to conduct this pilot study in Osun State, located in the South-West region of Nigeria. Osun is recognized as one of the more successful states in implementing the Nigerian Homegrown School Feeding Program (NHGSFP) and is currently the only state where the program is active. Through this initiative, we aim to generate evidence that can improve program efficiency by analyzing menu plans and procurement procedures. Using this evidence, we intend to collaborate with the Government of Nigeria (GoN) and the World Food Programme (WFP) to extend successful interventions to other states across the country. The primary reference groups for this study are the cooks/vendors and smallholder farmers involved in sales to cooks supported by the school feeding program. We target all cooks involved in school feeding services and smallholder farmers in the targeted communities who are able to supply the food to the cooks, including produce oil-palm, sweet potatoes, yam, cocoyam and vegetables.

2.1. Study objectives
This study aims to evaluate alternative mechanisms and interventions to support integration of local value chains into school feeding programs to benefit smallholder farmers in Nigeria. The impact evaluation includes a cluster randomized controlled trial aimed at evaluating the cost-efficiency and impact of adding training activities to an ongoing school feeding program to improve smallholder sales and revenues. The primary research questions we aim to address in this project include:
a) Can school feeding menu training improve the quality of school menus (including subjective evaluation of hygiene standards) and cooks’ welfare and empowerment outcomes (?
b) Can school feeding menu training and linking school feeding programs to smallholder farmers improve access and quality of school feeding menus
c) Can school feeding menu training and linking school feeding programs to smallholder farmers improve farmers’ sales and revenue?

Experimental design

The impact evaluation involves a cluster randomized controlled trial (c-RCT) design that will be implemented in about 300 schools supported by the school feeding program in Osun State, Nigeria. For this purpose, we closely work with school feeding program implementers during detailed planning stages. Schools and associated farmers will be randomly assigned to one of three treatment groups:
a) Standard of care (control) group: Schools with the standard school feeding for the duration of the trial.
b) Training (intervention) group (T1): the cooks in these schools will receive additional training focusing on menu planning, which will be implemented alongside the standard school feeding program.
c) Training + farmer linkages (training plus intervention) group (T2): the cooks in this group of schools receive similar training on school menu planning while farmers associated with these schools are linked with the cooks in neighbouring schools.

The random assignment into the three groups above will be conducted after the baseline line data collection. Smallholder farmers with some potential to serve and supply to nearby school feeding programs were identified in consultation with cooks, nutrition experts, and agriculture officers.

Cluster Randomization:
A c-RCT is a field experiment where clusters of schools are randomly assigned to intervention groups instead of individual cooks. Therefore, the unit of randomization (school) differs from the unit of analysis (cooks or farmers).

Design details

Randomization method
We randomize at the level of school using a complete listing from the school currently implementing school feeding program using a random number generator in Excel. This happens after the baseline data collection and after all inclusion and exclusion criteria are implemented.
Randomization unit
School
Clusters
100 schools
Observations
Planned number of observations: Cooks: 700 Farmers: 1500
Arms
T1 : 100 schools T2 : 100 schools
Primary outcomes
a) The proportion of smallholder farmers selling their agricultural products to schools as well as to traditional markets. b) Farmers' sales volume of locally grown agricultural outputs to both the market and schools (cooks). c) Farmers' sales revenue from locally produced agricultural outputs to both the market and cooks. d) Cost per unit of school meal to schools and cooks
Secondary outcomes
a) Menu quality and quantity assessment. b) Awareness of food safety and accessibility to fresh produce. c) Subjective evaluation of hygiene standards. d) Empowerment and well-being women cooks.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords