Not My Money to Touch: Experimental Evidence on Redistributive Preferences under Market Transition in China
How to cite
Mo, Zhexun; Belguise, Margot; Chen, Yuqian; Huang, Yuchen. 2024. "Not My Money to Touch: Experimental Evidence on Redistributive Preferences under Market Transition in China." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013928. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13928-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
China’s economic rise is arguably one of the most significant economic events of the past four decades. However, its opening up and liberalization have also created new inequalities. As China’s growth slows and inequality becomes more pronounced, redistributive policies have entered public discussion. A crucial question arises: how does the average Chinese person view those who have become wealthy over the past 40 years? Do they consider their wealth fair, or do they call for redistributive measures? This project builds on a pilot survey experiment we conducted in 2021, in which we found that priming–via vignettes–getting rich via relatively less meritocratic, yet representative ways under market transition in post-reform China - such as inheritance, housing arbitrage, or house demolition compensation - significantly reduces redistributive support, and in particular support for policies taking from the rich, while one may have a priori expected the opposite to happen. To verify the results of the pilot, we run a RCT on a representative sample of 2,000 Chinese respondents, replicating the priming treatment on a randomly-drawn subsample of 1,000 respondents. To better understand the results, we ask treated and control respondents what factors they think are the main sources of wealth in today’s society, as well as the sources of wealth of the individuals in the examples.
Intervention
Treated respondents will be presented with three vignettes. These vignettes capture stories of wealth acquisition through luck (that is to say not by personal effort) which were frequent during China’s economic transition. The first story involves an enterprise owner who became rich by joining a real estate hunting group, the second story involves a person who became rich by inheriting his family’s business, and the third story involves a family who became rich after being compensated for their house’s demolition.
Experimental design
The experiment will be conducted through a survey. After being asked if they consent to participate in the experiments, respondents will be asked to answer a series of demographic, socio-economic, and subjective well-being questions, as well as questions about their views on inequalities. Treated respondents will then be presented with the vignettes (described in “intervention"). Treated and control respondents will then be asked a series of questions on whether they agree or disagree (from “strongly agree" to “strongly disagree") with specific policies to reduce inequality (primary outcomes), and on what are, according to them, the main sources of wealth in today’s society (secondary outcomes). Treated and control respondents will then also be asked, for each of the vignettes, to what extent they attribute the wealth of the individuals in the vignette to individual ability and effort, pure luck, opportunities present in the specific period, or connection, privilege and inequality of opportunity.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.