Electoral Fraud, Voter Turnout, and Perceived Legitimacy
How to cite
Arbuzova, Anastasiia. 2024. "Electoral Fraud, Voter Turnout, and Perceived Legitimacy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013916. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13916-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The use of electoral fraud as a tool for securing victory in elections is well-documented. However, its use for purposes that go beyond winning an election remains relatively understudied. Particularly puzzling is its prevalence in the context of elections in non-democracies, where electoral results are often manipulated despite the incumbent's guaranteed success. Why do autocratic leaders engage in fraud when victory is assured? In this project, I study improving perceived legitimacy as one of the reasons for engaging in fraud. I examine the following mechanism: if turnout influences the population's perception of the autocrat's legitimacy, then he might want to employ fraud to achieve a desired turnout value. I will call this the legitimacy hypothesis. First, by leveraging data from the 2016-2021 Russian parliamentary elections, I confirm the presence of electoral fraud. I focus on manipulations of turnout values and perform several statistical tests to detect those, including last digit distribution and the excess integer values test. After gathering suggestive evidence of the use of fraud to influence turnout, I proceed with testing whether knowledge of turnout actually affects perceived legitimacy. To answer this question, I propose undertaking a survey with a representative sample of the Russian voter population. The key component of the survey will involve a randomized information intervention where treated respondents receive information about outcomes of a hypothetical election. Subsequently, their evaluation of legitimacy will be measured.
Intervention
Each respondent will be randomly assigned to one of five treatment arms: Control (C), Turnout Low (TL), Turnout High (TH), Turnout Low + Result (RL), and Turnout High + Result (RH). Respondents in the Control group (C) will not be provided with any information about elections. Respondents in the Turnout groups (TL, TH) will be provided with information about the turnout, either Low or High. Respondents in the Turnout + Result groups (RL, RH) will be provided with information about the turnout, either Low or High, and leading party vote share.
Experimental design
1,600 participants will be enrolled to ensure a representative sample of Russian voters. Participants must satisfy two inclusion criteria: (1) adults (over 18 years old); (2) Russian citizens with voting rights. In addition, quotas on federal district, city size, gender, and age cohort, will be implemented to insure that the sample is nationally representative.
The survey questionnaire consisted of three sections and should take approximately 10 minutes to complete. The first section will address socio-demographic characteristics. The second section will include questions on various forms of political participation, such as signing petitions and voting. At the end of this section, respondents will be asked about their participation in the 2021 Federal Duma elections and whether they recalled the results at both the national (proportional system) and constituency (majoritarian system) levels. To elicit actual political preferences, respondents will be presented with a scenario in which elections were scheduled to occur the following day and asked about their willingness to participate and, if yes, which party would they vote for. Subsequently, respondents will exposed to a hypothetical outcome of these election results and their perceptions of government elected with these results will be measured.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.