Selection, Sorting and Discrimination in Labor Supply Decisions
How to cite
Kumar, Chinmaya. 2024. "Selection, Sorting and Discrimination in Labor Supply Decisions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013882. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13882-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Minorities are underrepresented in enterprise ownership and leadership positions in big firms. Why? This paper empirically investigates the role of one potential reason for this: discrimination against minority employers by subordinate workers. I embed a field experiment in the recruitment of entry-level workers by a firm based in India. The field experiment aims to answer two main research questions: 1) Do minority employers face discrimination from below in labor markets? 2) What are the underlying motivations? I specifically test for two potential motives: attention discrimination and social image concerns.
Intervention
We run a Facebook advertisement to gauge the interest of candidates seeking positions as field surveyors, requiring them to complete an online form. We call up those who register using this application form and provide the name of the firm's director and request their educational certificates for credential verification. We randomize whether they are provided a minority-sounding name or non-minority sounding name. Additionally, we also randomize whether we tell the respondents that we will contact two of their listed contacts solicited in the initial form. There are four treatment arms: minority employer, non-minority employer, minority employer + reference check, and non-minority employer + reference check.
Experimental design
I run a Facebook advertisement to gauge the interest of candidates seeking positions as field surveyors, requiring them to complete an online form. This form solicits their contact details, educational qualifications, past experience, the names of two references, demographic details, questions testing their comprehension and mathematical skills, and the source through which they learned about the job. Candidates are informed that their references may be contacted if they are shortlisted.
We then conduct a basic screening based on educational qualifications. Candidates who pass this screening receive a phone call informing them that they have been shortlisted to participate in an interview for the job. During this call, we provide the name of the firm's director and request their educational certificates or transcripts for credential verification. The script for the interview-offer call varies in terms of the name of director and info on reference check. There are four experimental groups:
1. Minority Employer: Candidates will be informed that they are being considered by the survey firm whose director (minority-sounding name) has shortlisted them for an interview, and they should submit the required documents if interested in getting interviewed.
2. Non-Minority Employer: Candidates will be informed that they are being considered by the survey firm whose director (non-minority-sounding name) has shortlisted them for an interview, and they should submit the required documents if interested in getting interviewed.
3. Minority Employer + Reference Check: Candidates will be informed that they are being considered by the survey firm whose director (minority-sounding name) has shortlisted them for an interview, and they should submit the required documents if interested in getting interviewed. They will also receive this additional information during the call: the firm’s director will call up their references (names will be inserted using the data from sign up form) and inform them that you have applied to work for him/her and verify your prior work experience or education credentials.”
4. Non-Minority Employer + Reference Check: Candidates will be informed that they are being considered by the survey firm whose director(non-minority sounding name) has shortlisted them for an interview, and they should submit the required documents if interested in getting interviewed. They will also receive information about the reference check from the potential employer as before
Upon submission of their documents, candidates proceed to the interview stage, followed by an invitation to the office for training. Our analysis utilises the data collected at various stages of this experiment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.