Statistics and Stories: Shaping Memory
How to cite
Adam, Salamatu Nanna. 2024. "Statistics and Stories: Shaping Memory." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013880. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13880-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We propose to study how risk information about HIV should be presented in order to maximize its effect on beliefs about HIV for longer periods. In our baseline experiment, we will provide a random sample of participants with quantitative (statistical) risk information about the national new HIV infections and the attendance rates at a local clinic for HIV testing. For the remaining participants, we will complement this statistical information with a story, that is a qualitative narrative explaining how someone overcame the fear and anxiety to get tested after an ex-partner tested positive for HIV. The story also informs the reader about the testing experience at a local clinic. We will give all participants vouchers for HIV tests. This experimental design will allow us to estimate the effect of stories on the evolution of beliefs about HIV. Next, we will estimate the effect of stories on recall of the statistical information received two weeks after information is delivered. Lastly, We will estimate the effect of stories on voucher take-up intentions and actual HIV tests conducted at the clinic.
Experimental design
We propose to conduct a field experiment in Ghana with a student sample to study how the presentation of risk information about HIV affects long-term beliefs about the virus. The experiment will consist of two parts.
In the first part, we will provide a random sample of participants with quantitative (statistical) risk information about the number of new HIV infections recorded in Ghana and the attendance rates at a local clinic for HIV testing. For some participants, we will complement this statistical information with a qualitative narrative. This narrative will describe how someone overcame fear and anxiety to get tested after an ex-partner tested positive for HIV and will include details about the testing experience at the clinic. We will vary the narrator's test results (positive or negative) to examine which types of stories are most effective.
Before providing the information treatment, we will record participants' demographic data and elicit their prior beliefs about the number of new HIV infections in Ghana and the percentage of HIV tests conducted at the clinic. After the information treatment, we will measure their posterior beliefs about these metrics again. Additionally, we will offer HIV test vouchers and document participants' intentions to use them.
Two weeks after the first part of the experiment, we will implement the second part. In this phase, we will measure participants' posterior beliefs about the number of new HIV infections in Ghana and the percentage of HIV tests conducted at the clinic again. We will also conduct an incentivized guess and recall task based on the information provided in the first part of the survey. Finally, we will measure HIV test voucher take-up intentions again and distribute HIV test vouchers to all participants.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.