The Good Council: Deliberating inequality in a field experiment

How to cite

Lehner, Lukas; Disslbacher, Franziska; Haselmayer, Martin; Rapp, Severin; Windisch, Franziska. 2024. "The Good Council: Deliberating inequality in a field experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013874. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13874-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lukas Lehner* , Franziska Disslbacher , Martin Haselmayer , Severin Rapp , Franziska Windisch

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013874
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13874-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-01-15 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13874

Abstract

This document describes the research design and analysis strategy of our field experiment, designed around a citizens’ assembly to evaluate the impact of deliberative democracy on preferences for redistribution. The citizens’ assembly, Good Council (“Guter Rat”) takes place in 2024 in Austria. It consists of 50 residents of Austria who are selected to convene and develop ideas for addressing economic inequality, deciding on allocating an endowment of EUR 25 million to purposes conducive to this goal. The Good Council is an example of deliberative democracy, where participants “redistribute” a significant sum donated by a high-net-worth individual. We study whether participation in a citizens’ assembly affects (redistributive) policy preferences and related outcomes of participants. In particular, we are interested in preferences for redistribution and democracy using standard measures. Additionally, our rich questionnaire includes a battery of questions on people’s specific policy views and priorities.
The pre-analysis plan starts with an outline of the treatment and its timeline. We, then, provide a detailed discussion of our study design including data, sample selection, treatment assignment, variables used, and outcomes of interest. Finally, we conclude by specifying our statistical approach to inference.

Intervention

From March 2024 to December 2024, we conduct a field experiment designed in cooperation and implemented by the Good Council (“Guter Rat” in German). 50 people are randomly selected for the Good Council to reflect the population of Austria as accurately as possible. The 50 people selected meet over six weekends to deliberate and receive input from experts on the distribution of wealth in Austria and its impact on politics and society. The Good Council develops ideas for dealing with the distribution of wealth and eventually decides how the EUR 25 million endowment should be spent. The funding is provided by million heiress Marlene Engelhorn, who donates EUR 25 million.

Experimental design

To identify the causal effects of participation in deliberative democracy, we rely on random treatment assignment. The treatment group consists of 50 people from the pool of registered individuals who serve on the Good Council. Registered individuals are selected into the treatment group based on a random process that is specifically designed to ensure representativeness of the population when selecting members for citizens’ assemblies (Flanigan et al., 2021). The control group comprises a subgroup of other registered individuals. Since individuals opt in for our study’s data collection, the control group sample size is smaller than the complete set of registered individuals. The balance table (Table 2) details the means in the characteristics used for stratification between treatment and control groups. Since the treatment group is selected to correspond to the characteristics of the total population but the entire pool of those interested in participating does not, the control group differs by definition in some observable characteristics from the treatment group. Yet, the detailed stratification yields balanced groups for most covariates. Statistically significant imbalances emerge by age (for those 60 years and older 2), educational attainment (specifically, compulsory schooling, apprenticeship, and university degrees), employment type (dependent employment, retirement), household income (first income quartile), and views on wealth equality. The differences reflect the disproportionate self-selection of individuals with 30-44 years, higher educational attainment, dependent employment, with incomes in the upper half of the distribution, and more pessimistic views about the fairness of the perceived wealth distribution. Further, Table 3 compares the characteristics of participants with replacement group members, and Table 4 with control group members and replacement group members. There are no significant differences, though in part due to the small sample size of 14 individuals in the replacement group. In addition, Table 5 compares the characteristics of participants with those of the general population. The comparison confirms that the treatment group is highly representative of the general population.

We use three contrasts to adjust for imbalances between our treatment and control groups: First, we compare individuals in the treatment with the control group. The groups are balanced in most, but not all, characteristics. They should further be identical in unobserved characteristics conditional on the imbalanced observable characteristics. Second, we compare our treatment group with a random sample of the Austrian population that is freshly drawn in June 2024. Both groups should balanced in terms of observed characteristics since the treatment group is representative in observable characteristics. However, the treatment group may differ in unobserved characteristics as treatment is based on opting-in by registering for the Good Council citizens’ assembly. Third, we compare our control group with the random sample of the general population. By reweighting respondents in the control group to correspond to the general population in terms of observable characteristics, any differences in outcomes can be inferred to stem from unobservable differences due to self-selection. This serves as a test to quantify the magnitude of the potential selection bias from registering for the Good Council. It allows us to assess how clean or biased the comparison between the treatment group and the random sample of the Austrian population is.

Design details

Randomization method
The treatment is randomly assigned in the office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Person
Clusters
-
Observations
~1350
Arms
50 participants in the treatment group, 292 participants in the control group, and around 1000 individuals in the general population group
Primary outcomes
Political efficacy, Political participation, Knowledge of wealth distribution, Support for an egalitarian wealth distribution, Support for wealth taxation
Secondary outcomes
detailed in the pre-analysis plan.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords