Willingness to compensate for unequal circumstances

How to cite

Leites, Martin; Failache, Elisa; Salas, Gonzalo; Ramos, Xavier; Rodriguez, Mariana. 2024. "Willingness to compensate for unequal circumstances." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013863. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13863-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Martin Leites* , Elisa Failache , Gonzalo Salas , Xavier Ramos , Mariana Rodriguez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013863
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13863-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-06-24 – 2025-06-24
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D03, H23, H24, C93, D31, D72
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13863

Abstract

We conduct a survey to understand the valuation that individuals make when deciding how much to transfer to compensate for different circumstances. To do this we present hypothetical scenarios where the respondent has to allocate money to two potential beneficiaries. The beneficiaries are equal in all their characteristics but differ on one silent attribute associated with a circumstance. In addition, we randomly assign some individuals to receive information about the effort the potential beneficiaries put into searching for a job. The survey collects information surveying young people. On one hand, our results will provide evidence about how individuals value different circumstances. In addition, results will allow us to understand how individuals perceive the relationship between effort and circumstances.

Intervention

We use an experimental survey design, which is an adaptation of Almas, Cappelen y Tungodden (2020) to understand the role of circumstances in the willingness to compensate for income inequalities. The experiment will be carried on three samples. First, via an institutional email to students from Universidad de la República (the main university in Uruguay). Students from Economics, Business Administration, Accounting, Social Sciences, and Engineering will be invited. The email with the invitation to participate in the study and the link to the survey is sent to students enrolled in one of the mandatory courses in the first year of the university . In addition, we invite workers from the Universidad de la Republica (Teaching and non-teaching staff). The email with the invitation to participate in the study and the link to the survey is sent to workers using the email addresses available in the University’s administrative records. Additionally, the survey will be disseminated through the usual communication channels the University uses with its staff. In both cases, two reminders will be sent by email. A third sample of non-university-educated individuals aged 25-50 years from Uruguay will be invited through social networks.
Participation is voluntary but as an incentive for participating in the survey, participants will be entered into a drawing to win money to be used in a mall. The study is done with an online self-administered survey and the interventions (information regarding circumstances and effort of beneficiaries to look for a job) are embedded in the online survey.

Experimental design

We elaborate a questionnaire to understand the role of circumstances in the willingness to compensate for income inequalities. The questionnaire contains different vignettes where information related to circumstances faced by a potential beneficiary of a cash transfer program vary. We include 4 different circumstances, and all individuals are asked about how to distribute money depending on the circumstance. In addition, we randomly assign a group of participants to have extra information regarding the effort putted by the beneficiary.

We will collect data from six different modules. (1) Consent information; (2) Socioeconomic and demographic characteristics; (3) The compensation experiment (detailed below); (4) Questions on preferences for redistribution, attitudes, and political beliefs (5) Attention check questions and social desirability module; (6) Consent to merge the survey with other sources of information.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done through the software used for the online survey (Survey Solutions). Each individual has the same probability of being assigned to each group.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization are the respondents of the survey.
Clusters
We are not going to cluster the treatment.
Observations
We will send the invitation to participate in the experiment to 3500 university students from the Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y de Administración (Economic Sciences and Administration"), 950 from the Facultad de Ciencias Sociales (Faculty of Social Sciences) and 1000 from the Facultad de Ingenieria (Faculty of Engineering). We expect a response rate of 15%, therefore, we expect to have 700 observations from students. In addition, we will send the e- mail invitation to 15000 university workers. We expect a response rate of 7%, therefore, we expect to have 1000 observations from workers. Finally, we expect to reach 1000 participants through social networks. Considering all responses we expect to have 2700 participants.
Arms
The information treatment associated with circumstances will be answered by all participants, therefore we will have 2700 responses for each circumstance. Treatment associated with effort will be randomly assigned with equal probability of assignment to each group. We expect to have 1350 observations in the treatment group.
Primary outcomes
A measure of the willingness to compensate for unequal circumstances.
Secondary outcomes
As secondary outcomes we will measure: The probability of changing the allocation after a confirmation question. The primary outcomes mentioned before but when the beneficiaries face a different income gap (100 instead of 200 in the original scenario). The primary outcomes mentioned before but when they can also allocate money to other public programs. The acceptance to fund the transfer by a 5% income tax depending on the circumstance. The acceptance to fund the transfer by a 3% income tax depending on the circumstance. The primary outcomes mentioned before but when they can allocate 300. A measure of the willingness to compensate for “pure effort” Additionally, we will analyze heterogeneous effects according to: - Background characteristics of the respondent - Social desirability questions - Gender - Academic performance (available in academic registry)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords