How do unions solve their collective action problem?

How to cite

Naidu, Suresh; Pons, Vincent. 2016. "How do unions solve their collective action problem?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001386. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1386-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Suresh Naidu* , Vincent Pons

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001386
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1386-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2016-05-26 – 2016-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1386

Abstract

We are using large administrative data sets and randomized experiments to understand and improve outcomes in private sector unions. We randomize postcards sent to union members following a successful campaign. Treatment postcards invite them to participate in a membership meeting and contain information about past participation in union activities of their co-workers, co-union members, or themselves. We also randomize the fraction of coworkers of a particular shop that receive the treatment to estimate spillovers. We use administrative data from the union to measure participation in the membership meeting on June 22nd, participation in future events, contribution to the union political action fund, and eventual retention.

Intervention

We randomize postcards sent to union members following a successful campaign. Treatment postcards invite them to participate in a membership meeting and contain information about past participation in union activities of their co-workers, co-union members, and themselves.

Experimental design

Our design includes three experiments conducted on three different subpopulations (defined by prior participation of self and shop). In each experiment, any member can be allocated to one of three possible treatment conditions. Treatment postcards invite members to participate in a membership meeting and contain information about past participation in union activities of their co-workers, co-union members, or themselves. Randomization is conducted at two different levels. Treatment condition is randomly assigned at the individual level, but the fraction of coworkers that receive any particular treatment is determined at the shop level, to estimate within-firm spillovers.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by the researchers in office by a computer, with Stata.
Randomization unit
Individual and shop.
Clusters
Experiment A: 1,998 members Experiment B: 2,071 shops Experiment C: 4,288 shops
Observations
Experiment A: 1998 members; B: 37,663 members; C: 29,209 members. Total: 68,870 members
Arms
In Experiment A, randomization was done at the individual level: * 1/3 members (666 members) receive T0 * 1/3 members (666 members) receive T1 * 1/3 members (666 members) receive T2 In Experiment B, randomization was done at the shop level and then the individual level: * 1/6 shops (345 shops) in which all members (6,281 members) receive T0 * 1/2 shops (1,035 shops) in which 1/3 members receive T0 (6,240 members), 1/3 T1 (6,239 members), and 1/3 T2 (6,240 members) * 1/3 shops (691 shops) in which 1/2 members receive T1 (6,332 members) and 1/2 T2 (6,331 members) In Experiment C, randomization was done at the shop level and then the individual level: * 1/6 shops (714 shops) in which all members (4,951 members) receive T0 * 1/2 shops (2,145 shops) in which 1/3 members receive T0 (4,822 members), 1/3 T1 (4,821 members), and 1/3 T2 (4,822 members) * 1/3 shops (1,429 shops) in which 1/2 members receive T1 (4,897 members) and 1/2 T2 (4,896 members)
Primary outcomes
Participation in the membership meeting on June 22nd, participation in future events, contribution to the union political action fund, and eventual retention.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords