Insights into Action: A Mega Study to Promote Sustainable Behaviour Change
How to cite
Sussman, Kay-leigh; Percy, Pauline; Costa-Font, Joan; Lagarde, Mylene. 2024. "Insights into Action: A Mega Study to Promote Sustainable Behaviour Change." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013836. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13836-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Introduction:
Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) account for 74% of all deaths globally and physical inactivity is among the leading factors contributing to this global burden of disease (WHO, 2023; Ezzati et al 2006). In the UK, over 25% of adults fall below recommended activity levels, intensifying NCD prevalence and straining healthcare. Traditional approaches have focused on medical care delivery to people with an established disease. Instead, emerging research in the fields of behavioural economics is exploring new strategies to avoid the development of NCDs by encouraging individuals to adopt and maintain healthy lifestyles, including regular physical activity (PA). Various studies have shown that reminders, personalized goal-setting, and social reinforcement can boost PA, but it is hard to determine the relative effects of these interventions against each other.
Mega studies, which are randomised experiments testing multiple interventions offer the possibility to test simultaneously the impact of alternative interventions on the same outcomes in a defined population. This study introduces a mega study testing five interventions, aiming to foster regular PA among inactive individuals. Focused on a single population and outcome measure, our objective is actionable insights for evidence-based strategies to cultivate sustainable PA habits, significantly contributing to shaping public health initiatives.
Objectives:
Glean insights into nudging PA behaviour change within Vitality UK's member population, identifying effective strategies for lasting changes in PA behaviours and habits.
Methods:
A mega study involving 60,000 Vitality members compares five four-week digital programs encouraging exercise. Inclusion criteria encompass Vitality health insurance membership, opting into the rewards program, and prior engagement with a baseline incentive program. The study includes one control (simple reminder) and four treatment groups, testing distinct nudges (personalized reminder, loss aversion, authority, and resolution/fresh start). Utilizing a comprehensive dataset, including objective and biometrically verified data distinguishes it from traditional survey-based studies.
Results:
Ongoing analysis will include the effect of each nudge on PA levels compared to baseline. Subgroup analyses based on demographics and baseline PA levels will be undertaken.
Discussion:
Analysing the mega study's nuanced findings will assess intervention effectiveness, implications for intrinsic motivation, and behaviour change sustainability. Broader considerations for public health policies and interventions in combating the global burden of disease associated with physical inactivity will be explored.
Intervention
Intervention is delivered via the Vitality Mobile Application (Vitality App). Each day, individuals will be shown one of 5 cards, which serve as the intervention:
1. Control – simple reminder
2. Personalised forward looking goal reminder
3. Loss aversion
4. Authority nudge/ancillary benefit gain
5. Resolution/fresh start effect
Experimental design
Experimental Design
Study Title: Mega Study on Physical Activity Nudges among Vitality UK Members
Introduction: Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) account for 74% of all deaths globally, with physical inactivity being a significant factor. In the UK, over 25% of adults fall below recommended activity levels. This study investigates the effectiveness of different nudges in promoting physical activity (PA) among individuals, using a mega study framework to compare five interventions.
Objectives:
1. Evaluate the effectiveness of five different nudges on increasing PA levels.
2. Determine the sustainability of PA behavior changes.
3. Provide insights for public health strategies to combat physical inactivity.
Methodology:
Study Design:
This is a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 90,000 Vitality UK members, randomly assigned to one of five groups: one control group with a simple reminder and four treatment groups receiving different nudge interventions.
Population and Sample Size:
- Population: Vitality health insurance members who have opted into the rewards program and engaged with a baseline incentive program.
- Sample Size: 90,000 participants
Inclusion Criteria:
- Age 18 and above
- Current Vitality health insurance members
- Opted into the Vitality rewards program (VAR)
- Prior engagement with the Vitality program
Exclusion Criteria:
- Medical conditions prohibiting physical activity
- Not opted into Vitality and VAR or not syncing devices for PA tracking
Interventions:
Participants will be assigned to one of the following groups:
1. Control – simple reminder
2. Personalized forward-looking goal reminder
3. Loss aversion
4. Authority nudge/ancillary benefit gain
5. Resolution/fresh start effect
Data Collection:
- Baseline Data: Demographic information, baseline PA levels, and health metrics.
- Intervention Data: Engagement with nudges, changes in PA levels, and adherence to PA recommendations.
- Outcome Data: Objective and biometrically verified PA data, collected through wearable devices and Vitality's digital health platform.
Outcome Measures:
- Primary Outcome: Change in PA levels from baseline, measured in PA days and PA points.
- Secondary Outcomes: Sustained PA levels at follow-up intervals (3 months, 6 months), subgroup analyses based on demographics and baseline PA levels.
Data Analysis:
- Primary Analysis: Comparison of PA levels between control and treatment groups using statistical tests and regression analysis.
- Secondary Analysis: Subgroup analyses to explore variations in intervention effectiveness by demographics and baseline PA levels.
- Sensitivity Analysis: Assess robustness of findings by varying analytical assumptions and methods.
Results:
Ongoing analysis will focus on the comparative effectiveness of each nudge intervention. Initial findings will be reported after the six-week intervention period, with follow-up analyses at 3 and 6 months post-intervention.
Discussion:
The study will provide insights into behavior change mechanisms, sustainability of PA increases, and public health policy implications. Findings will help develop strategies to reduce the global burden of diseases associated with physical inactivity.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.