A Theory Based Analysis of Path Dependency (Part 2)
How to cite
Kazemi, Saeid; Camuffo, Arnaldo; Gambardella, Alfonso. 2024. "A Theory Based Analysis of Path Dependency (Part 2)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013819. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13819-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study proposes a theory-based perspective on path dependency, emphasizing the impact of both internal and external initial conditions on economic decision-making processes. Building on the framework established by David (2007), we argue that internal factors, particularly actors’ initial beliefs and priors, play a crucial role in shaping decision trajectories and influencing the likelihood of sub-optimal lock-ins. We identify four pathways through which decision makers form their priors: 1) Ignoring path dependency, thereby risking commitment to inferior paths with a single theory and an outside option; 2) Acknowledging path dependency but failing to consider unforeseen contingencies, which may lead to sub-optimal lock-ins; 3) Anticipating new information, events, and shocks, thereby adjusting their theory’s value to account for unforeseen developments; 4) Evaluating multiple theories of value, which can help avoid sub-optimal lock-ins. We hypothesize that economic actors who anticipate path dependency and unknown events and develop multiple theories of value are less likely to experience sub-optimal lock-ins. The QWERTY keyboard case is reinterpreted through these four lenses to underscore the importance of initial internal condition setting.
This RCT build on a previous RCT (AEARCTR-0013625), testing two additional hypotheses, using two additional treatment arms.
Intervention
This RCT build on a previous RCT (AEARCTR-0013625), testing two additional hypotheses, using two additional treatment arms.
Experiment Overview
This experiment builds on findings from a previous randomized controlled trial (AEARCTR-0013625) and is structured to investigate the likelihood of selecting the sub-optimal path in path-dependent decisions under the influence of either optimistic or pessimistic awareness of unknown future states. We will explore how these perspectives influence managerial decision-making without explicitly informing participants about path dependency. The participants, chosen from a pool of managers and balanced for gender, will be recruited via Prolific and the experiment will be conducted on the IMSL website (imsl.unibocconi.it). We aim to enroll 750 participants.
Procedure
Participants will begin with a welcome page, followed by a baseline survey to gather control variables such as age, gender, education level, field of education, industry, job function, total experience, and managerial experience. Based on their survey responses, participants will be randomly assigned to one of two groups, ensuring that the experiment starts with groups of 8 participants at a time and maintains an equal distribution of STEM and Non-STEM participants.
Experiment Flow
Introduction Video: A video will introduce the participants to a historical decision-making scenario involving a simplified version of Christopher Latham Sholes’ typewriter development. The video will present Sholes’ challenges without focusing on the path dependency aspects.
Scenario Presentation: After the video, participants will be asked to choose between two hypothetical keyboard layouts based on:
• Jamming Resistance (0 to 10): How well the layout prevents jamming.
• Typing Speed (0 to 10): How fast typists can type assuming no jamming occurs.
The two layouts will be:
• Layout A: High jamming resistance but low typing speed.
• Layout B: Low jamming resistance but high typing speed.
Group Treatments: Participants will be divided into two groups, each receiving different information after the video, before making their layout selection:
Pessimistic Unknown Group:
• Intervention: Participants in this group will be informed about Sholes' recognition of his limited knowledge of future events and his pessimistic outlook on unforeseen developments such as major competitors.
• Objective: To assess how a pessimistic view of future uncertainties impacts decision-making in a non-path-dependent context.
Optimistic Unknown Group:
• Intervention: Similar to the Pessimistic Unknown Group, but participants will be informed about Sholes’ optimistic expectations about future developments, highlighting the potential positive outcomes of unknown future states.
• Objective: To evaluate how an optimistic perspective on future uncertainties influences decision-making in a non-path-dependent context.
This experiment design allows us to examine the effects of different emotional outlooks on future uncertainties in decision-making and the propensity to make sub-optimal choices.
Experimental design
The engagement entails participation in an online experiment on the IMSL website (imsl.unibocconi.it/scenario) distributed through Prolific. Participants will be first introduced to the survey on the first page in two simple sentences, making them aware of the context of the experiment and the end goal which is “the optimal keyboard layout for his Type Writer machine”. They are then asked to fill in a short baseline survey with 8 questions on demographic information. The participants are then asked to watch a short video on the invention of the Type Writer Machine by Christopher Latham Sholes and are then asked to select a keyboard layout based on the available information.
There will be 2 arms in the experiment, differing on the information they receive at the end of the video, and before the layout selection, and a control group with observations that have already been collected in a previous RCT (AEARCTR-0013625)
The control group will receive the essential information needed to make a decision about the layout. This group and its observations have already been gathered in a previous RCT (AEARCTR-0013625)
The Optimistic Unknown group will be made aware of unforeseen contingencies and that Sholes is Optimistic about them, without an explicit awareness of path dependency.
The Pessimistic Unknown group will be made aware of unforeseen contingencies and that Sholes is Pessimistic about them, without an explicit awareness of path dependency.
Finally, they are thanked for their participation, explicitly debriefed on the experiment, and redirected back to Prolific. This activity is expected to last 5 minutes in total.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.