Is E-filing a Gateway Technology?
How to cite
Okunogbe, Oyebola; Pouliquen, Victor; Umargaliyev, Kairat. 2024. "Is E-filing a Gateway Technology?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013761. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13761-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates the determinants of internet adoption by small and medium firms and its effects on firm outcomes. We use an experiment conducted in Tajikistan in 2014 in which a randomly selected group of firms received help to register for electronic tax filing, leading to a higher likelihood of e-filing use. We use this variation to study the impact on internet adoption by firms as well as the short- and long-term impact of internet on firm outcomes using data from surveys conducted in 2016 and 2020, administrative data, and online checks conducted in 2023 to assess impacts on firms’ online activity and survival.
Intervention
The intervention was to train firms and provide them support in registering for e-filing.
There are three interventions:
1) Intensive treatment (Group A): firms received training and information about e-filing intended to increase awareness and trust in the system. In the training session, they learned about e-filing availability, its benefits, and registration procedures and participated in an interactive demonstration of the e-filing system. In addition, these firms received logistical support in registering for e-filing to mitigate the hindrances firms willing to use e-filing face in accessing the system: a representative of the implementing partner helped firms complete all the steps required for registration. Firms unwilling to register for e-filing had to explicitly “opt-out” of the program.
2) Training only (Group B): Firms assigned to this group received exactly the same training. However, they did not receive logistical assistance with registration procedures. Firms willing to register to e-filing had to “opt-in” and register by themselves.
3) Placebo training only (Group C): a general training on taxation not specific to e-filing.
To hold the delivery format of the treatments constant, all firms in the three groups received the same general training on taxation not specific to e-filing. The training included a review of different tax laws and procedures and a statement about the availability of e-filing on a slide listing the three modes of filing taxes: “by paper, by mail and electronically.”
Experimental design
1) Group A: Training session about the e-filing system and logistical support in registering for e-filing.
2) Group B: Training session about the e-filing system only.
3) Group C: firms did not receive e-filing training.
Experimental Design Details:
1) Group A: Training session about the e-filing system and logistical support in registering for e-filing.
Firms assigned to this group received training where they learned about the e-filing system: its availability, benefits and registration procedures. An interactive demonstration of the system was also offered to firms in this group. Moreover, firms received assistance from the implementing partner in completing all necessary registration steps.
2) Group B: Training session about the e-filing system only. Firms assigned to this group received exactly the same training. However, they did not receive logistical assistance with registration procedures.
3) Group C: firms did not receive e-filing training.
Firms in three groups were presented with a general training on taxation that did not specifically focus on e-filing.
Experimental Design Sampling protocol:
The evaluation draws from the universe of firms in Dushanbe which belong to the Tax Committee database. All legal entities and individual entrepreneurs which are (i) simplified tax regime payers (ii) have been active in the system for at least 2 years (i.e. not new enterprises or bankrupt ones) and (iii) are not currently e-filling were eligible for the study. There were 5,218 firms in the Tax Committee database that met these three criteria.
A list of 2,004 firms was randomly selected from this overall population with stratification on status of the firm (legal entities or individual enterprises) and “rayon” (administrative units dividing Dushanbe in four). This sample size of 2,000 firms was determined after discussions with Tax Committee and i-SYS (the implementing partner). This number corresponds to the expected number of firms that need to be contacted by i-SYS to obtain the attendance of 1500 firms at a training session. Since we expect the program to be more effective on legal entities which are usually bigger firms than individual enterprises, we oversampled legal entities to have 75 percent of legal entities and 25 percent of individual enterprises in the study population.
Key data sources:
Data from the original short-term study:
(1) The baseline survey conducted in 2014 prior to the program implementation. This self-administered survey was filed by each study participant at the beginning of the training sessions. It contains basic information on businesses, including questions on attitudes toward tax administration and perceived corruption.
(2) Administrative data on tax behaviors (including usage of e-filing)
(3) Data from the company in charge of implementing the program
(4) Data on program cost.
(5) Data from qualitative interviews with implementing agencies and program beneficiaries.
(6) Data from the first follow-up survey conducted in February 2016 one year after the end of the program. This survey was administered by enumerators in person to each firm in the sample (1263 firms) at the firm's premises.
We add the following additional data sources for the long-term study:
(7) Data from a second follow up survey, conducted in 2020 with a subsample of 174 firms from the overall study sample. 74 and 31 firms are in Group A and Group B respectively while 69 firms are in Group C.
(8) Online searches for firms’ online presence: two enumerators performed a systematic online search for all firms interviewed during the endline survey. Each enumerator independently assessed whether the firms had established any online presence, including websites, email addresses, social media handles, etc. Results on online search from both enumerators were combined into the single dataset after the verification of all discrepancies.
(9) Registration status (liquidated or active) of firms included in the endline survey was collected through a search on the website of the Tax Committee of the Republic of Tajikistan conducted between May and July 2023.
Hypotheses:
1) E-filing adoption has a short-term and long-term positive impact on firms' use of internet.
2) E-filing adoption (and internet adoption) has a positive impact on firm outcomes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.