Effectiveness and Efficiency of Government Health Insurance in India: Impacts of Strengthening Hospital Monitoring and Fraud Control
How to cite
Dupas, Pascaline; Jain, Radhika; Shang, Yinshan. 2024. "Effectiveness and Efficiency of Government Health Insurance in India: Impacts of Strengthening Hospital Monitoring and Fraud Control." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013744. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13744-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study seeks to identify government interventions that can improve the efficiency of public health insurance schemes without reducing their effectiveness. We conduct a statewide RCT that randomizes an intervention to increase the threat of crackdown on hospital fraud across private hospitals in one state of India. We leverage administrative data from the insurance program and augment it with patient surveys to measure impacts on hospital fraud, as well as patient out-of-pocket charges, care access, and care quality. The study will provide some of the first evidence on hospital fraud and monitoring within insurance in LMICs. It will also provide insights on the design and effectiveness of monitoring (auditing) systems given limited state resources that generalize to social insurance and assistance programs more broadly.
Intervention
Treatment hospitals receive a government letter, signed by the CEO of the health insurance scheme, warning them that the insurance authorities are increasing fraud controls and that their audit probability has increased. The letters are intended to abruptly increase hospitals’ perceived threat of fraud detection, which has been shown to deter fraud in other contexts.
A second intervention is potentially scheduled for later. In this second intervention, the insurance trust would conduct hospital audits at randomly selected hospitals in both treatment and control groups. We are not yet sure this will be possible as it depends on the insurance trust's capacity. We will file an update to the registry entry to update this part of the protocol when plans have been finalized.
Experimental design
Using historical data on claims, we identified private hospitals with relatively high claim volumes and values. Within these, hospitals were randomly selected for the "treatment" (letter intervention). We stratified the letter intervention randomization by what specialties the hospital offers (in particular whether or not the hospital offers the specialties targeted in the patient surveys), baseline average claims value, hospital share of district-level claims, and whether it is located outside AP state.
Public hospitals are not included in the RCT, but we will be able to use their claiming patterns over time as a useful benchmark since their incentives to manipulate claims are minimal.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.