Can Access to Smartphones Improve Adoption of Digital Agricultural Technologies?
How to cite
Abdelaziz, Fatma; Bulte, Erwin Hendricus; Abay, Kibrom. 2024. "Can Access to Smartphones Improve Adoption of Digital Agricultural Technologies?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013736. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13736-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The landscape of digital innovations in Africa is characterized by significant “digital divide”: less than 40 percent of smallholder households have access to the internet (Mehrabi et al., 2021). Marginalized farmers and households have even less access to the internet and mobile phones, this differential access to digital innovations and associated complementary infrastructures may generate further inequality.
Taking Egypt as a case study, smallholder farmers can easily get excluded from the agricultural digital revolution, as the existing rural farming communities in less developed or remote regions in Egypt usually lack the infrastructure required and internet connectivity to navigate these tools (OBG, 2022; AGBI, 2023). The high cost of smartphones and internet services may be one reason why urban households are more digital than rural households.
Consistent with literature and evidence from experimental learning (e.g., Carter et al, 2014; Fischer et al., 2019), short run subsidies that allow users experience a technology may help potential users revise their expectations, and eventually adjust their beliefs on the relative costs and benefits of these technologies. In this study, we utilize the Egyptian context and aim to investigate how access to a shared smartphone, which allows smallholder farmers to operate and use agricultural digital tools free of charge over the internet for a short period of time would: (i) impact farmers’ use and adoption of digital agricultural tools, (ii) affect farmer’s willingness-to-pay (WTP), following a 6-month experimental learning period, to keep and invest in these smartphone devices for future adoption.
Intervention
In this intervention we seek to promote the use of digital mobile apps to smallholder farmers who do not own smartphones and are likely excluded from the agriculture digital revolution. Accordingly, we provide 100 smartphones, with a pre-charged internet bundle to approximately 500 farmers in Minya and Benisuef. Farmers will be asked to form groups of 4-5s depending on their proximity to one another, and will be asked to share a smartphone together, whereby each member gets to keep the device for a week and then passes it on to the next. This intervention is meant to encourage and enable smallholders who do not own smartphones to access and use agricultural digital mobile applications for free for a 6-month experimental learning period. The objective is to evaluate the impact of access to smartphones on farmers’ adoption and investment in digital tools for agriculture using rigorous impact evaluation methods.
Experimental design
• Control Group: no intervention.
• Treatment Group: Farmers will be asked to self-select and formulate their own groups. The formulated groups will be provided with a shared smartphone device and will be assigned a trainer from their designated farmer organization to pass by every week to offer a refresher training when needed to farmers and to ensure that the farmers are complying to the smartphone sharing activity.
On each smartphone:
o The network operator (Vodafone) will provide 100 Internet SIM cards that can only function over specific agricultural digital tools/ apps (blocking unrelated services or apps that may consume internet or defuse the purpose of our intervention)
o The sim cards will be charged on monthly basis that grants internet for up to 10 GB
o After 6 months, farmers in the control and treatment arms will be invited to join one of two designed BDM auction bidding exercises, to measure their willingness to pay (WTP) to keep and invest in these smartphone devices for future agriculture digital tools adoption.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.