Assessing the impact of a healthcare-inclusive graduation program on health and livelihoods in Bangladesh

How to cite

Islam, Muhammed Nazmul; Anik, Asibul Islam; Saha, Jyotirmoy; Amin, Sajeda; Makino, Momoe. 2025. "Assessing the impact of a healthcare-inclusive graduation program on health and livelihoods in Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013735. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13735-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Muhammed Nazmul Islam* , Asibul Islam Anik , Jyotirmoy Saha , Sajeda Amin , Momoe Makino

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013735
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13735-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-05-24 – 2025-12-30
Countries
Bangladesh (Chandpur, Jhenaidah, Kushtia, Pabna, Shirajganj, and Shariatpur)
JEL codes
C93, I14, I32, I38, O12, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13735

Abstract

Despite notable economic progress, poverty remains a significant challenge in Bangladesh, with 14.3% of the population living in extreme poverty and 51% living below the lower-middle-income poverty line of USD 3.20 per day. Poor health, closely linked to poverty, restricts income-generating activities, while high out-of-pocket (OOP) health expenditures, without an effective risk pooling mechanism, expose households to financial catastrophes. This multifaceted nature of poverty requires a comprehensive approach that integrates livelihood and health interventions. To address the dual challenges of poverty and health shocks, SAJIDA Foundation launched a graduation program in 2022 named "UTTARAN". UTTARAN was implemented in 26 sub-districts across six districts in Bangladesh, targeting 11,000 poor households.
The program provides women living in vulnerable communities with productive assets, financial literacy training, and connections to social safety networks. It offers free door-to-door healthcare services, telemedicine support, and referrals to formal health facilities for their entire family. It also covers healthcare costs to significantly reduce their out-of-pocket expenditures. Through these targeted interventions, the program aims to enhance economic resilience, improve health outcomes, and empower women, ultimately contributing to sustainable poverty alleviation in Bangladesh.
This study employs a three-arm cluster randomized controlled trial to examine the transformative impact of including health interventions in the basic graduation model on health and livelihoods. Ninety villages/clusters were randomly assigned to one of three groups: a control group (no intervention), a group receiving only livelihood support, and a group receiving both livelihood and health support. Baseline data collection was collected from 3292 households during May-June 2023. The same households will be surveyed again in May-June 2025 for the endline data.

Intervention

The UTTARAN program is distinguished by its unique focus on promoting women's empowerment within marginalized communities. This is achieved through two intervention streams: (1) the livelihood intervention stream, which transfers productive assets, provides financial literacy training, link beneficiaries to different social safety networks, and matches savings; (2) the health intervention stream, which provides door-to-door healthcare services with telemedicine support and a strong referral linkage with formal health facilities, and funds healthcare.

Experimental design

We adopted a three-arm Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial (CRCT) to comprehensively assess both the combined and marginal impacts of UTTARAN’s healthcare and livelihood interventions. The villages were treated as clusters, and we randomly assigned them into one of the three intervention arms.

We applied a two-stage sampling technique to recruit the study participants. At the first stage, we equally distributed 90 villages into the three arms using a simple random sampling technique. However, in the second stage, we applied a purposive sampling technique to select the households. In the sub-section, ‘Study sites’, we described how the program used PRA approach to identify locations of poor households in each village and conducted a survey to assess the PPI scores of the households residing in those locations. We used that list of potential beneficiaries as our sampling frame and purposively recruited the households that met our inclusion criteria. Instead of selecting them randomly, we prioritized the households with lowest PPI scores.

However, for 66 villages, the list fell short in providing 36 households from each village. Therefore, to recruit the remaining households, we replicated the PRA approach that the program applied to recruit their potential beneficiaries. First, using PRA approach, we identified additional locations in the village where comparatively poor household could be found. Then, we conducted the PPI survey in those locations and identified households meeting our inclusion criteria. We included them in the sampling frame along with the program-identified households. Finally, from each village-list, we selected 36 households that met our inclusion criteria.

The first arm was pure control. UTTARAN did not provide any intervention in these 30 villages during the study period. The villages in the second arm received only the livelihood support. In the third-arm villages, the program provided both the healthcare and livelihood supports.

We have selected this study design for several compelling reasons. First, it will help us estimate both the combined and marginal impact of SAJIDA’s health and livelihood support packages among poor households. Second, randomizing the clusters will allow us to minimize the risks of contamination. Third, the intervention is expected to bring change at the community level, where our design will be useful in capturing different community-level dynamics and impacts. Finally, randomizing at the cluster-level helps balance potential confounding factors and establish socioeconomic and geographic comparability between the treatment and control arms. By employing this rigorous study design, we aim to provide robust evidence to understand UTTARAN’s effectiveness in uplifting the poor and contribute valuable insights to evidence-based policies aimed at poverty reduction in vulnerable rural communities.

Design details

Randomization method
Villages/clusters were randomized in the office using Stata
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
90 villages
Observations
3240 households
Arms
The total sample size is 3240 households, where each arm requires a sample size of 1080 households. Therefore, we recruited 36 households from each of the 90 villages/clusters.
Primary outcomes
To estimate the impact of UTTARAN on livelihood and health of the targeted population, we identified a set of indicators as primary outcomes, including- poverty status; income; consumption; and healthcare-seeking behavior.
Secondary outcomes
Food security; wealth and assets; financial inclusion, formal savings and access to social protection; women's empowerment; reduced morbidity and sickness-related absenteeism; knowledge on non-communicable diseases (NCDs), and out-of-pocket health expenditure

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords