Barriers in accessing sports: A field experiment at the intersection of sexual orientation and ethnicity

How to cite

Gonzalez, Carlos Gomez; Nesseler, Cornel; Dietl, Helmut. 2024. "Barriers in accessing sports: A field experiment at the intersection of sexual orientation and ethnicity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013711. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13711-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Carlos Gomez Gonzalez* , Cornel Nesseler , Helmut Dietl

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013711
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13711-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-05-15 – 2024-09-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, J15, Z29
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13711

Abstract

Discrimination based on race, ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation is highly persistent in multiple settings. Much research is needed to understand the mechanism behind differential treatment (Bertrand & Duflo, 2017). One of the research areas that require attention is how individuals are affected at the intersection of these traits. In this project, we are interested in the intersection of LGBTQ support and sexual orientation with ethnicity.

We perform a large-scale field experiment in Germany based on a correspondence study. Fictitious applicants contact coaches via email asking to join a trial training with a native- or a foreign-sounding name. The emails are identical, and the response rate to the different groups can provide evidence of discrimination. The experimental design is very similar to previous field experiments we performed in several European countries (Gomez-Gonzalez et al., 2021) and has a twofold aim.

First, we aim to examine if showing support for the LGBTQ movement negatively influences an individual's chance to obtain a response when contacting a sport club. Additionally, we examine if foreign background plays a role in this relationship. Our treatment showing support for the LGBTQ movement is a subtle signal in the signature of the email during pride month.

Second, we aim to examine if signaling homosexuality negatively influences an individual's chance to obtain a response when contacting a sport club. Additionally, we examine if foreign background plays a role in this relationship. Our treatment signals homosexuality by mentioning that the applicant has just moved to the area with a female/male partner.

In total, we contact 6023 amateur sports clubs.

Intervention

Randomly send information about the LGBTQ support of the applicant.
Randomly send information about the sexual orientation of the applicant.

See the Experimental Design for details.

Experimental design

We want to compare the response rate for individuals who contact a sports club. We compare the response rate for individuals with a typical German- and foreign-sounding name. All the clubs in the sample will receive one email only. The content of the email is identical for all clubs except for the names of the applicants and the treatments, which are randomly varied.

Names: The name is either female or male. We use the three names for each group for each nationality. Thus, six names for German-sounding names (three for males and three for females) and six names for each of the three largest foreign groups in Germany: Turkish-, Syrian-, and Ukrainian-sounding names.

Conditions: The English translation of the baseline message is as follows:

Subject: Club membership
Hello,
I recently moved here and would like to join your SPORTS club. I was in a club before I moved and would like to start again. Is it possible to come over?

Thank you
NAME

Treatment 1. We include one treatment with a signal of support for the LGBTQ movement in the signature of the email message. Find the English translation of the message below:

Subject: Club membership
Hello,
I recently moved here and would like to join your SPORTS club. I was in a club before I moved and would like to start again. Is it possible to come over?

Thank you
NAME
----
PrideMonth2024🏳️‍🌈

Treatment 2. We include one treatment with a signal of heterosexuality in the email message. Find the English translation of the message below:

Subject: Club membership
Hello,
I recently moved here with my girlfriend (boyfriend) and would like to join your SPORTS club. I was in a club before I moved and would like to start again. Is it possible to come over?

Thank you
Male name (Female name)

Treatment 3. We include one treatment with a signal of homosexuality in the email message. Find the English translation of the message below:

Subject: Club membership
Hello,
I recently moved here with my boyfriend (girlfriend) and would like to join your SPORTS club. I was in a club before I moved and would like to start again. Is it possible to come over?

Thank you
Male name (Female name)

Design details

Randomization method
We use block randomization by state and sport. This ensures that individual names are not overrepresented in sports or areas. We use Stata and the set seed command to make the randomization process reproducible.
Randomization unit
We randomize at the club and regional level.
Clusters
The dataset includes clubs from four different sports. We plan to have around 1500 observations per sport.
Observations
The dataset includes 6023 observations: 1504 football clubs, 1512 horse riding clubs, 1504 table tennis clubs, and 1503 tennis clubs.
Arms
For each sport, approximately 1/4 of clubs are assigned to local name, 1/4 of clubs to foreign group 1, 1/4 of clubs to foreign group 2, and 1/4 of clubs to foreign group 3. For each sport, approximately 1/4 are assigned to the baseline message, 1/4 of clubs to treatment 1, 1/4 of clubs to treatment 2, and 1/4 of clubs to treatment 3.
Primary outcomes
Positive response rate
Secondary outcomes
We perform a survey before the start of the experiment in which we ask participants to assess: if the names sound foreign, if the names are either female or male, if they associate a religion with the names, and what the average skin color of these names is.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords