The Value of Investor Data: An Experimental Approach using a Trading Simulation Platform

How to cite

Mihet, Roxana; Longin, Francois; Zhao, Ziwei. 2024. "The Value of Investor Data: An Experimental Approach using a Trading Simulation Platform." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013691. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13691-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Roxana Mihet* , Francois Longin , Ziwei Zhao

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013691
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13691-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-05-01 – 2024-12-14
Countries
Private
JEL codes
G0, G4, G5, O0, D0, D8
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13691

Abstract

Our project investigates personal data privacy and the monetization of personal data by digital finance platforms, particularly focusing on the value retail investors place on the privacy of their trading activity (i.e., their investor sophistication level, as well as the history of the orders they sent to the market and history of the orders that were executed). We collect this data using experiments on a realistic and sophisticated trading simulation platform we developed ourselves. We collect data on how much individual retail investors care about having their personal trading activity shared with other market players, by conducting a controlled experiment where we observe a privately informed individual’s trading behaviour when made aware (or not) about their personal trading history being shared with other market participants. We assess the implied monetary compensation for an individual’s data privacy by considering any changes in the timing of trades, the size, and the type of the orders (i.e., market or limit orders) between the different information regimes. We also look at the trading profits obtained by individual investors. In surveys that follow the completion of the experiment, we also collect standard demographics data (age, gender, education, etc.), data on attitudes towards risk and experience with stock market trading, as well as data on the subjective monetary value they would require as compensation for complete privacy on digital platforms. The data we collect is very rich and allows exploration of data valuations across demographic groups, market conditions, and availability of private information, contributing to the understanding of privacy's true value and the impact of different information treatments.

Intervention

In the digital landscape, the adage "if you’re not paying for a product, then you are the product" rings true. This is particularly evident in daily-use services like Google, YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, and others, which monetize by providing personal data to third parties. However, this practice is not limited to social networks. It extends to financial firms as well. For instance, trading platforms, such as Robinhood, offer zero brokerage fees by selling customer data to other financial institutions via 'payment for order flow' (PFOF). Despite concerns about potential issues such as front-running and back-running, this practice has been legally ongoing in the United States for years.

With the rising prominence of data privacy rights and the enforcement of consumer data regulations around the world (i.e., the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union in 2016, the California Consumer and Protection Act in the United States in 2020, and the Personal Information Protection Law of the People's Republic of China in 2021), there's a growing call to empower individuals with more control over their data usage and potentially compensate them for their data. Understanding how much individuals value their data becomes crucial to fairly compensate investors, especially as zero brokerage fees may underestimate the genuine worth of investor data. Balancing the advantages of information disclosure with privacy concerns necessitates quantifying both aspects using a unified metric for better decision-making in optimizing information sharing processes.

The scientific objectives of this research project revolve around investigating the value individuals place on their personal trading data in financial markets, particularly in the context of information sharing among market participants.

Experimental design

The first step involves developing a trading algorithm on a fully functioning trading simulation platform developed at ESSEC Business School, that provides direct access (“online”) trade execution and clearing services.

The algorithm will take into account three scenarios: (1) one in which retail investors are aware their trading data is shared with other market participants, (2) one in which they are aware the data is not shared and (one where nothing is mentioned regarding data-sharing, across three settings: (a) one in which participants receive good private information, (b) bad private information, or (c) no private information.

Thus, the experiment itself will have multiple versions: the control group will receive good or bad private information about the asset traded but will not be told anything about the functioning of their account. The treated group will receive good or bad private information and then be told that their account trading history will start being shared with other participants.

Demographic data collected will include the participants’ profile information (age, gender, experience with the stock market, etc.) and the experimental data will consist of participants’ trading activity during the trading simulations. More precisely, the trading activity consists of the orders (limit and market orders) sent by the participants during the simulation and the evolution of their position (cash and assets and profits) during the simulation.

The goal is to record how individuals react once they are made aware that their account trading data will be shared with others. This is virtually impossible to do in a non-experimental setting.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual subject.
Clusters
2 schools
Observations
450 individual subjects
Arms
2 schools, 450 individual subjects at least, 150 control group, 150 privately informed that trading history info shared, 150 privately informed that trading history info not shared
Primary outcomes
The project aims to achieve the following key objectives: 1. Quantifying Individual Concerns for Data Privacy: The research will measure the extent to which an individual investor cares about the sharing of their personal trading activity with other players in the financial market. This will be accomplished through a controlled experiment where a participant's trading behavior will be observed under scenarios where they are informed (or not) about the disclosure of their trading history to other market participants. 2. Evaluating Monetary Compensation for Data Privacy: The project will assess the implied monetary compensation associated with an individual's data privacy. We will analyze changes in trading behavior, such as alterations in trade timing, order size, and order type, between different information disclosure settings. Thus, we will infer the financial worth an individual investor places on maintaining their data privacy. 3. Analyzing Trading Profits of Individual Investors: The research will examine the trading profits obtained by individual investors within the context of different information-sharing regimes. Understanding how trading behaviors and profitability correlate with information disclosure can provide valuable insights into the potential impacts and implications of data sharing on investors' financial gains.
Secondary outcomes
The COVID-19 pandemic has witnessed a surge in female engagement with the stock market, attributed to job and savings insecurities during the pandemic, and increased usage of no-fee trading platforms facilitated by the time spent at home. For example, Robinhood saw a 369% increase in the number of women using its services during the pandemic and women now make up 30% of its customer base. Despite this, a substantial body of academic literature underscores the heightened vulnerability of women within the stock market due to a historical gender disparity in financial literacy and participation. Women typically exhibit lower financial education levels and reduced involvement in investment activities (Guiso and Zaccaria, 2021 ), often remaining underbanked (Demirgurc ̧-Kunt et al., 2017 ), and exhibiting lower stock market participation levels (Ke, 2021 ). Furthermore, women frequently express higher privacy concerns while exhibiting limited adoption of protective behaviors in comparison to men (Armantier et al., 2021 , Hoy and Milne, 2010 , Sheehan and Hoy, 2000 ). The prevailing digital landscape, characterized by the monetization of personal data by numerous online platforms, is notably relevant in the financial sector, whereby trading platforms such as Robinhood leverage customer data monetization as a means to offer commission-free services to individual investors. However, this data sharing practice raises concerns regarding investor vulnerability to welfare losses (Acquisti et al., 2015 ), especially concerning retail investors, including women, who may inadvertently consent to data sharing without a comprehensive understanding of its potential adverse impact on their trading outcomes. Consequently, this study emphasizes the necessity to investigate whether women modify their risk attitudes and trading approaches in response to the awareness of their trading data being shared. The aim is to provide insights that guide policy-makers in tailoring adaptive measures that protect privacy, considering gender dynamics.
Sponsors
Name: ESSEC Business School Location: France Url: https://www.essec.edu/en/ Name: HEC Lausanne Location: Switzerland Url: https://www.unil.ch/hec/home.html Name: Sandoz Foundation - Monique de Meuron Program Location: Switzerland Url: https://www.fpfs.ch/domaines-activite

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords