This study looks into the different factors that influence student decisions on university application and attendance.
Intervention
The intervention will involve providing secondary school students in the UK with information, mentorship, and subsidized in-person visits to universities, with the treatment arms varying the content and nature of each.
Experimental design
The experimental design consists of two cross-randomized treatments and a control group with randomization at the individual student level. All students will complete baseline, midline, and endline surveys before and after the intervention.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization will be conducted on a computer. We randomize students between arm C and the treatment arms when they complete the baseline survey using randomization in Qualtrics, stratifying by school. As noted above, for Queen Elizabeth’s Grammar School Faversham, randomization in the baseline survey only randomized between arm C and a treatment arm providing both mentors and visits without distinctions between demographically matched and unmatched mentors.
Randomization unit
Individual, stratified by school
Clusters
As the randomization is at the individual level, the number of clusters at the unit of randomization level is the same as the number of individuals. However, we will be sampling particular schools, and our central estimate is that we will recruit 20 schools.
Observations
Our central estimate is that we will have a sample size of 2000 individuals, but we may get fewer or more as we are still in the process of recruiting schools to the study and confirming participation.
Arms
Subject to budgetary and logistical constraints, we plan to assign 50% of participating students to the active control group, and evenly assign students to each of the four treatment arms, so that 12.5% of students are in each of arms T1a, T1b, T2a and T2b. Given our central estimate of 2000 participating students, this implies that we will have 250 students in each treatment arm and 1000 in the control arm. If we encounter constraints on our budget or the capacity of our mentors, we will reduce assignment to treatment evenly across the four treatment arms.
Students in the control group C will be notionally assigned (for the purpose of constructing placebo outcomes) to one of the four treatment groups in even proportions; under our main plan this will mean notionally assigning them to each of the four groups with 12.5% probability.
Primary outcomes
Short-run outcomes (collected at midline and endline surveys):
Beliefs about outcomes at universities where students are assigned videos, mentors, and visits
“How likely are you to make friends and fit in at [university]?”
“How likely are you to receive an offer from [university]”?
“How likely are you to graduate successfully from [university]?”
Stated preferences over universities and application intent
Long-run outcomes (collected by schools after university applications are submitted):
- Applications / attendance to universities where students are assigned videos*
- Applications / attendance to mentor's university
- Applications / attendance to university with subsidized visit
Note that we notionally assign each student in the control group in one of the treatment arms, and apply the same algorithm to assign them universities for videos, mentors and visits, but do not actually offer them these treatments. Having assigned universities for the control group allows the university- specific outcomes described above to be defined in the control group consistently, meaning that we can construct placebo versions of these outcomes in the control group for use in analysis. .
Secondary outcomes
We will look into heterogeneity of treatment effects on the primary outcomes by demographic similarity between participating students and mentors (where demographics include socioeconomic status, ethnicity, gender, and location). For instance, we will examine whether female students matched with female mentors were more likely to apply to their mentor's university compared to female students matched to male mentors.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.