How regional predictions of heat events in the coming summer and their forward-attribution to climate change affect support for adaptation and mitigation measures as well as attribution of guilt across generations.
How to cite
Longo, Enrico; Damania, Mrunali; Lange, Andreas; Perino, Grischa; Drupp, Moritz; Baehr, Johanna. 2024. "How regional predictions of heat events in the coming summer and their forward-attribution to climate change affect support for adaptation and mitigation measures as well as attribution of guilt across generations.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013668. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13668-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
How do regional predictions of the number of heat events (tropical nights) for the coming summer (June to August 2024) impact citizens’ willingness to engage in voluntary adaptation efforts, support for mitigation measures and the attribution of blame to the currently elder generation? How is this impact affected if the anthropogenic contribution in the predicted number of heat events is made transparent exa nte (´forward attribution´)? We study these fundamental questions with a large-scale survey experiment that involves 4,200 adult members from the general population in Germany.
There are three experimental conditions: Control, Prediction, and 'Prediction with Forward Attribution' ('Attribution' for short). All participants are informed about the health threats associated to heat events and tropic nights in particular. The Prediction and the Attribution groups receive regional (100km x 100km) predictions of the number of heat events (nights when temperature does not drop below 20°C, 75percentile from an ensemble of predictions with 30 members). The Attribution group on top of that learns the number of heat events (defined the same way as above) to be expected in a typical year (such as 1850) in a world without anthropogenic climate change. Predictions presented are conditioned on participants' postcodes.
Prior to treatment, we elicit core socio-demographic variables, post codes, attitudes to climate change, science and government as well as perceptions of the frequency of local summer heat events and holiday plans. Post treatment, we elicit emotional reactions to treatment, several core outcome variable (stated and revealed preference) on attribution of blame across generations, support for adaptation and mitigation measures. The survey concludes with further socio-demographic and attitutional questions.
In a second wave to be conducted in September 2024 we want to assess the impact that experienced weather has had on the same individuals in terms of support for adaptation and mitigation measures.
Intervention
Intervention 1: Prediction
We provide participants with a prediction for the number of heat events (75percentile of number of tropical nights, i.e. with temperatures always above 20°C, from an ensemble of predictions with 30 members) during the months June to August 2024. They are computed by research in our team (University of Hamburg) in cooperation with Germany's National Meteorological Service (Deutscher Wetterdienst). Predictions are region-specific (100km x 100km) and presented to participants based on the postcode of their home address elicited at the beginning of the survey.
Intervention 2: Prediction + Forward Attribution ('Attribution' for short)
Same as intervention 1 plus the prediction for the number of heat events (75percentile of number of tropical nights, i.e. with temperatures always above 20°C) during the months June to August in a typical summer without anthropogenic climate change (i.e. for the year 1850) as a reference point.
Experimental design
We run online surveys in Germany. We recruit participants through a professional survey company (Bilendi). To be eligible subjects must be adults (age 18+). The sample will use quotas for age brackets, gender and eduction (with and without a highschool diploma 'Abitur') to match the distribution in the general population. Moreover, we will exclude participants that complete the survey too quickly to have read the information provided and answers (<5min in total) or those showing clear signs of inattention (response times >60min in total).
All subjects answers questions about demographics and prior beliefs and attitudes towards climate change, climate policy and climate science.
Pre-treatment attitudes towards climate change.
Subjects then, in both the 'Prediction' and in the 'Attribution' treatments, receive a forecast on the number of heat events (days the temperature does not fall below 20°C, i.e. 'tropical nights') for the three summer months of June to August 2024.
All subjects also indicate how reliable they find the prediction, how they feel when they read it and they are asked to write down briefly how they would explain the prediction to a friend.
Only in the “Attribution” treatment, in addition to the prediction described above, participants also receive information on the number of heat events / tropical nights that would be expected in a typical summer without human-induced climate change.
Subjects in the “Attribution” treatment then indicate how reliable they find this second comparative information, how they feel when they read it and they are asked to write down briefly how they would explain it to a friend.
All subjects then answer questions about the key revealed and stated preference outcome variables on attribution of blame between generations, adaptation measures for oneself and for vulnerable groups, and a mitigation policy (details see above).
Finally, socio-demographic characteristics are collected, such as family composition, income and political attitudes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.