Much research has emphasized the disproportionate impact of the opioid crisis on White individuals in the United States, especially during the first wave. This project considers whether this framing has affected the response to the opioid crisis. In this experiment, we will randomize racial priming in a survey to understand whether it affects stated support for the policy response to the opioid epidemic. We will include a description of the opioid crisis in terms of overdose deaths. In one arm, we will not mention race. In the first treatment arm, we will highlight that most overdose deaths are among White individuals. In the second treatment arm, we will highlight the disproportionately high overdose death rates of Black and American Indian/Alaska Native individuals. We will compare whether this priming affects whether the respondent believes that we dedicate "too much" attention and policy spending on the opioid crisis. We will also include subsequent questions about willingness-to-pay for policies to decrease overdose deaths, whether opioid addiction is a choice, and other questions about possible policy options.
Intervention
We will randomize whether an introductory discussion of the opioid crisis includes a statistic about race. We will either not include any information by race, highlight that most overdose deaths are among White individuals, or emphasize the disproportionately high overdose deaths rates among Black and American Indian/Alaska Native individuals.
Experimental design
We will randomize respondents into one of the three arms with equal probability.
Design details
Randomization method
The code for the survey will perform the randomization in real-time.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2000 individuals
Observations
2000 individuals
Arms
We expect about 667 in each arm.
Primary outcomes
Share of respondents who report that the amount of public attention and spending on policies to decrease overdose deaths is “too much.”
We will calculate the share for each arm and compare each treatment arm to the control arm. Our full sample includes a “nationally-representative sample” and an “opioid-dependent sample.” We will use the full sample for the main analysis.
Secondary outcomes
We will also study the following outcomes:
1) Share of respondents who report that the amount of public attention and spending on policies to decrease overdose deaths is “too much” or “just right.”
2) Share of respondents who select that “opioid use is a choice and people should just not use opioids.” (This answer is only an option for respondents who previously answered that the amount of public attending and spending dedicated to decrease overdose deaths is “too much” or “just right.” Those not given this question will be assigned to not answering that “opioid use is a choice and people should just not use opioids.”)
3) Maximum willingness-to-pay for naloxone policy that would reduce overdose deaths by 1 / 100,000.
4) Share who agree or strongly agree that opioid addiction is a choice. (We will also study each option separately: strongly agree, agree, neither agree or disagree, disagree, strongly disagree)
5) Share who answer that those found misusing opioids should serve jail time.
6) Share who believe that prisons should provide MOUD to prisoners.
7) Share who believe that prisons should provide naloxone to prisoners upon release.
Our sample includes a “nationally-representative sample” and an “opioid-dependent sample.” We will conduct analyses of our primary and secondary outcomes for each sample separately as secondary analyses. When making this stratification, we will rely on our own questions about opioid dependence.
In addition, we will make the same comparisons for stratified samples: (1) people who know someone impacted by opioids in any of the following ways: (a) struggled with an opioid addiction, (b) needed medical attention because of an opioid addiction, (c) sought treatment for an opioid addiction, (d) Faced police contact, arrest, or incarceration due to an opioid addiction, or (e) are likely or very likely to overdose from opioid use; (2) people who are personally impacted by opioid use (same reasons as above) or report being likely or very likely to overdose from opioid use. In each stratification, we will show the comparable results for the sample not meeting the conditions.
(3) We will also stratify by race, gender, and political affiliation.
(4) Finally, we will stratify based on the 2022 overdose death rate of the state.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.