Perspectives and preferences of both refugees and hosts on refugee local integration in Uganda

How to cite

Kadigo, Mark Marvin. 2024. "Perspectives and preferences of both refugees and hosts on refugee local integration in Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013654. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13654-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mark Marvin Kadigo*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013654
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13654-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-07-10 – 2024-08-24
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93 Field Experiments, D91 Role and Effects of Psychological, Emotional, Social, and Cognitive Factors on Decision Making, F22 International Migration, J68 Public Policy
Secondary IDs
N/A
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13654

Abstract

Uganda currently hosts the highest number of refugees in Sub-Saharan Africa and is renowned for having one of the most progressive refugee policies globally. Despite extensive studies on Uganda's success in refugee management, the issue of local integration as a durable solution from the perspectives of both refugees and hosts has not been thoroughly examined. This study employs a mixed methods approach to analyze and compare the perspectives and preferences of refugees and local Ugandans on local integration. Additionally, it tests the importance of intergroup contact in shaping these perspectives and preferences. The quantitative part involves a fully randomized choice-based and rating-based conjoint analysis, where respondents will choose between pairs of communities, each with randomly assigned integration scenarios across six dimensions. These scenarios will vary in their level of perceived integration. The study will estimate the causal effect of each integration dimension and determine the relative importance of community characteristics. The qualitative part includes focus group discussions and key informant interviews to explore the meaning of local integration from the viewpoints of refugees and Ugandans, along with their experiences and preferences.

Intervention

The study aims to assess the perspectives and preferences of both refugees and host communities regarding refugee integration in Uganda. Specifically, the objectives are:
1. To determine the average preference of refugees and host community members (Ugandans) for a more integrated refugee-host community.
2. To analyze the relationship between reported intergroup contact and the integration preferences of both refugees and hosts across various integration dimensions.
3. To compare the average preferences for integration scenarios between refugee and host (Ugandan) respondents.

The study will take place in Kampala and Isingiro districts (particularly around Nakivale refugee settlement). Data will be collected from both refugees and host community members (Ugandan nationals) living near the refugees, in both rural settlement areas and urban towns. Participants will be randomly selected using preexisting sampling frames from the Uganda Bureau of Statistics (UBOS), employing a two-stage cluster sampling strategy with the Probability Proportionate to Size (PPS) approach (with replacement). The final sampling stage may utilize satellite imagery or a listing exercise, depending on field and budgetary constraints. Based on power calculations, the study aims to include 700 participants, evenly split between Ugandans and refugees or asylum seekers. Data collection is planned to start in July 2024 and conclude by the end of August 2024.

The study features a fully randomized choice- and rating-based conjoint experiment embedded within a household survey. Participants will complete a survey questionnaire and be randomly exposed to a conjoint experiment involving six integration dimensions and their corresponding pairs of integration scenarios/community characteristics. The dimensions are: location freedom, political expression freedom, labor market freedom, integrated services, cultural fluidity, and citizenship. Each dimension's community characteristics will be illustrated with carefully designed pictorial representations. In five rounds, respondents will be presented with randomly compiled pairs of communities and asked to choose their preferred community based on the selected characteristics from each integration dimension. The survey will be programmed to randomize the community characteristics within each dimension and the order of the dimensions between respondents to mitigate ordering effects, while keeping the order of dimensions constant across the five choice rounds for each participant to minimize survey fatigue.

Experimental design

The study involves two types of conjoint experiments and subsequent analyses: choice-based and rating-based conjoint experiments.

In the choice-based conjoint, respondents will be presented with pairs of communities containing randomly selected sets of integration scenarios across six dimensions. Each community option represents a more or less integrated refugee-host community based on the combination of characteristics within each dimension.

Respondents will make choices for five rounds, with characteristics randomized within each dimension to minimize survey fatigue. The order of integration dimensions remains constant across rounds for each respondent, but it is randomized between respondents to avoid bias. This randomization and ordering are automated within the survey system.

In the rating-based conjoint, respondents will rate each community option on a scale of 1 to 7, indicating their preference. This rating process occurs five times, following each choice round.

Each community characteristic will be described alongside a corresponding pictorial representation. Images for two community options will be presented side by side to aid respondent choice and rating in each round.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the Individual. I stratify by refugee status (refugee or Ugandan), and location (Kampala or Isingiro).
Clusters
The treatment is not clustered. The planned number of respondents is 700 individuals; 350 refugees and 350 Ugandans, approximately equally distributed between Kampala and Isingiro district.
Observations
Given the structure of the conjoint, the planned number of observations is 7000 observations in the dataset from a planned total sample of 700 respondents. In a conjoint experiment, the number of observations in the dataset is equivalent to the effective sample size. Since each respondent will view two (2) community profiles each round, for five (5) rounds in total, the effective sample size is (2*5)*700=7000. From each respondent, we shall have 10 observations, one for each community profile per choice round. Note that the planned total number of observations is above the minimum as determined by the power calculations. This is to account for possible failure to reach and/or non-response given the refugee-host context in Uganda.
Arms
Conjoint experiment. No treatment arms.
Primary outcomes
The primary measures of interest are; 1. A measure of the level of preference of both refugees and Ugandans for refugee local integration in Uganda 2. A measure of the importance of intergroup contact in shaping the preference for refugee local integration in Uganda
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes are; 1. The mechanisms through which their preferences are formulated. 2. The closeness of their preferences to their reality. 3. The influence of some demographic characteristics of preferences for refugee local integration.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords