Optimizing Cash Transfers with Social Empowerment Interventions to Reduce Child Marriage in Bangladesh

How to cite

Sulaiman, Munshi; Ahmed, Shaila; Rahman, Khandker Wahedur; Mahmood, Sakib; Islam, Md Johirul. 2024. "Optimizing Cash Transfers with Social Empowerment Interventions to Reduce Child Marriage in Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013652. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13652-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Munshi Sulaiman* , Shaila Ahmed , Khandker Wahedur Rahman , Sakib Mahmood , Md Johirul Islam

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013652
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13652-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-06-01 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Bangladesh ()
JEL codes
I25, I26, J12, J13, J16, J01
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13652

Abstract

Despite legal restrictions, child marriage remains prevalent in Bangladesh and in fact have gone up from 31% to 42% between 2020 and 2023. BRAC's Social Empowerment and Legal Protection (SELP) program is implementing an intervention that combines life-skills training and networking called "Shwapno Sharothi" (SS), and layering a conditional cash transfer component. This study employs a two-stage cluster Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) to evaluate the impact of the empowerment (i.e. SS) and the marginal impacts of providing monthly conditoinal cash transfers of two different values. The RCT operates across 5 districts in Bangladesh, targeting 450 clusters (primarily a village) with a total sample size of 11,250 adolescent girls aged 13–17. Clusters are randomly assigned to four groups:

1. SS only = 140
2. SS + High cash = 100
3. SS+ Low Cash = 100
4. Control = 110

The study will measure the impact of these interventions on child marriage prevalence and gender norms with a midline after the completion of the program and an endline one year after the completion of the program. Additionally, a cost-effectiveness analysis will be conducted to by comparing the costs associated with the interventions and potential improvement by applying different targeting approaches.

Intervention

BRAC's Social Empowerment and Legal Protection (SELP) program in Bangladesh has launched a two-year (2023-2025) multi-layered intervention targeting 2,400 villages in 240 sub-districts from 30 districts. We are conducting the study in 450 cluster/villages from 40 upazillas of 5 districts. This program aims to tackle child marriage by empowering adolescent girls (aged 13–17) and their families.

The intervention has two key components:
Shopno Sharothi (SS): Each cluster village has a team of 20-25 girls called "Shopno Sharothi (aka the Dreamer)". This girl-led initiative focuses on:
1. Developing life skills for the girls.
2. Fostering teamwork and problem-solving abilities.
3. Raising awareness about the negative consequences of child marriage and advocating for its prevention.

Conditional Cash Transfers: Families with girls aged 15-17 can receive conditional cash transfers for up to two years (or until the girl turns 18). The amount varies (low or high cash) and depends on the girl remaining unmarried. This financial incentive aims to discourage child marriage by providing economic support to families.
The reason for multiple cash transfer options is that it allows us to see if the size of the cash transfer affects the program's effectiveness. Even within the low cash transfer group, some teens receive the cash while others only get the program, allowing us to study spillover effects within the program group.
This program has used a multi-component approach to address child marriage. By combining social empowerment through life-skills training with conditional cash transfers, the program aims to be more effective than single-pronged interventions.

Experimental design

We did the randomization at two stages. In the first stage, we randomly selected 30 upazillas (subdistricts) out of 40 upazillas that are eligible to receive low cash and the rest 10 for high cash. In the 30 upazilas, there were 10 eligible villages identified for the interventions and in the second group of upazilas there were 15 villages. In the second stage, we randomly selected 4-5 cluster villages that have received "SS Only" (T1), 3-4 cluster villages that have received "SS + Low Cash" (T2), and 2 villages a control group (C1). For the other 10 upazilas, we selected 10 cluster villages from each for "SS + High Cash" intervention (T3) and 5 villages as control (C2). The reason for first-stage randomization is because of the programmatic constraints of addressing potential backlash by implementing two different sizes of cash transfers within the same upazila. So, we have a total number of villages in each of the arms as follows:

T1. SS only = 140 villages
T2. SS + High cash = 100
T3. SS+ Low Cash = 100 villages
C1. Control (from upazilas with low cash) = 60 villages
C2. Control (from upazilas with high cash) = 50 villages

This design with multiple arms and randomization helps control for external factors that might influence the outcomes and isolates the true impact of the SELP program on child marriage and gender norms. In each of the 450 cluster villages, on average 25 adolescents are selected (overall N=11250), and the targeted adolescent girls will be surveyed to measure the impact of this program. Our randomization was accomplished based on the BRAC’s listing (The listing was conducted on March 2023) data which consists of a sample of 11,250 girls. However, we randomly selected 6,730 girls for the baseline survey that was conducted from September to October 2023.
A midline survey will be conducted after the completion of the program and an endline survey will be undertaken one year after the completion of the program in all 450 cluster villages.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done in a computer using STATA software.
Randomization unit
Cluster randomization. Cluster unit is village level.
Clusters
450 clusters (villages/communities)
Observations
11250 adolescents
Arms
T1. SS only = 140 villages T2. SS + High cash = 100 T3. SS+ Low Cash = 100 villages C1. Control (from upazilas with low cash) = 60 villages C2. Control (from upazilas with high cash) = 50 villages
Primary outcomes
Child marriage and Education
Secondary outcomes
Parents' attitude towards child marriage, communication, trust, and mutual understanding of adolescents with parents, parents' perceived risks of elopement, incidence of elopement in the community, parents' perception of return to education.
Partners
Name: BRAC Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.brac.net/program/social-empowerment-and-legal-protection/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords