Gig Rules: The Political Economy of Labor Market Regulations
How to cite
Luo, Hong; Oberholzer-Gee, Felix. 2024. "Gig Rules: The Political Economy of Labor Market Regulations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013651. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13651-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In response to the emergence of online platforms that match workers with specific tasks such as ride-sharing, coding, or handy work, lawmakers, regulators, and sometimes even voters created new rules to govern these novel forms of work. The regulations often seek to strike a balance between the benefits of gig work, primarily flexibility and autonomy, and the advantages of traditional forms of employment. In this paper, we study the welfare effects of a wide range of hypothetical job designs, using ride-sharing as our example. We ask three questions: First, if current and prospective drivers were to choose freely between different job designs, which features would be particularly attractive to them? Second, what are the design elements of jobs that find broad political appeal among voters? And third, what are the welfare consequences of imposing politically popular job designs on current and prospective drivers? To answer these questions, we use conjoint survey experiments to solicit preferences for job designs from both likely voters and prospective drivers. In our analysis, we first estimate voters’ and drivers' preferences for each job attribute. Equipped with these estimates, we then predict the expected voter support for all possible job designs. Zooming in on designs that secure a majority of votes, we estimate drivers’ decisions to drive as well as their well-being under these working conditions. Our project aims to expand the horizon on what ridesharing could look like and the welfare consequences of having voters and their representatives decide labor market regulations.
Intervention
Our data are generated by two sets of conjoint survey experiments, in which we ask voters to vote between a random hypothetical job versus the status quo and drivers about their willingness to drive personally for a random hypothetical job. Please see the attached pre-analysis plan for the details.
Experimental design
For the voting survey, we draw a random sample that represents the general voting-age population. For the driving survey, we draw three different samples: individuals who worked for companies like Uber or Lyft in the past; current drivers for these types of companies, and a third group, which we call likely drivers. Likely drivers consist of people who might consider driving in the future, perhaps not under the current working conditions but under a broad range of possible ride-sharing job designs. In our analysis, we combine the current and past drivers due to their limited numbers.
We conceptualize jobs as bundles of attributes. A job design consists of ten attributes including compensation, work-related benefits (e.g., healthcare), and other elements such as work flexibility and the predictability of work schedules.
The design of the two conjoint survey experiments is similar. We ask each participant to complete eight tasks. In Task 1, the respondents evaluate a job profile that describes the working conditions that are typical of many of today’s ride-sharing jobs. In Tasks 2-7, the participants compare two job profiles: Job A represents the status quo, the profile that the participants saw in their first task. Job B is a hypothetical, randomly populated job profile that differs from the status quo along multiple dimensions. To facilitate the comparison, we highlight in boldface the attributes of Job B that differ from Job A. The first seven tasks are identical across voter and driver surveys. The only difference is that we ask respondents to evaluate the job designs as voters (“would you vote for or against…”) or drivers (“would you personally be willing to drive…”). The eighth task differs across the two surveys.
Please see the attached pre-analysis plan for the details of our study design.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.