‘Just transition’ policy strategies, public perceptions of climate change, and political participation in Italy.
How to cite
Lepidi, Pietro Michael. 2024. "‘Just transition’ policy strategies, public perceptions of climate change, and political participation in Italy.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013635. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13635-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Do policies combining long-term environmentalism with short-term compensation for lower-income households influence concern about climate change and climate action? Building on previous literature that looks at support for climate change policies (Maestre-Andrés et al., 2019), this research posits that the inequality and fairness perceptions of environmental policies influence the prioritisation of climate change amongst voters, as well as the willingness to act for climate through political participation. In other words, ‘just transition’ policy programmes combining environmentalism with economic compensation should promote climate change politics, making climate change action more likely. The research tests this argument by designing two hypothetical climate policy packages. People who are presented with information on how environmental policy can protect the incomes and jobs of lower-income households should be more supportive of political action in favour of climate change policy compared to people presented with generic long-term climate policies. When environmental policy is combined with short-term compensation, the likelihood of conflict between economic hardship/growth and climate change policy costs is potentially reduced. This should lead to a more optimistic view of climate change action. In the absence of climate economic compensation policies, perceptions about climate change and climate change action are influenced by the need for economic prosperity and fewer government economic regulations (Benegal and Scruggs, 2016). The research design involves an information-provision treatment in Italy to test whether job and income compensation measures affect the climate change preferences of Italian voters. The treatment manipulation provides some people with information on environmental policies and redistributive measures, while the control group is presented with an environmental policy package without any reference to the distribution of its costs. The research looks at how different information changes the prioritisation of climate change policy, as well as attitudes towards climate change protests, environmentalist associations, and political participation. Furthermore, the experiment tests whether the treatment effect varies depending on the respondents’ perception of economic status and their previous information about climate change science.
Intervention
The online survey experiment includes (a) a survey questionnaire, (b) a treatment and control video with information about two hypothetical climate change policies (a carbon tax and a publically subsidised green infrastructure plan) and (c) the collection of outcome variables. Each individual is only assigned to either the treatment or control video.
The control video has information on how a carbon tax and a green infrastructure plan would work. The treatment video contains the same information as the control video but also includes additional details on how environmental policies can be designed to protect the jobs and income of lower-income households. Specifically, the treatment carbon policy informs respondents that the revenues from the carbon tax can be redistributed based on income, benefiting lower-income households economically. The treatment green infrastructure plan highlights how, in Italy, more jobs would be created than lost in the fossil fuel industry and emphasizes the protection of lower-income families' jobs. The videos are similar in length (1:44 for the control and 2:50 for the treatment). Access to the treatment and control videos (in Italian) and a transcription and translation of the videos are available in the Analysis Plan.
Experimental design
Respondents are asked to watch either the control or the treatment video carefully. The videos explain two hypothetical climate policies using pictures and animations.
All permanent residents in Italy are eligible to participate in the survey experiment and can be randomly selected for the treatment group. Respondents who report that they did not view the video correctly will be excluded.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.