Financial Literacy and Aspirations: Experimental Evidence from Uganda

How to cite

Agasha, Ester; Bruce, Wydick; Hobbs, Andrew. 2024. "Financial Literacy and Aspirations: Experimental Evidence from Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013632. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13632-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ester Agasha* , Wydick Bruce , Andrew Hobbs

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013632
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13632-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-05-01 – 2024-05-15
Countries
Uganda (Eastern)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13632

Abstract

In Uganda, where financial challenges disproportionately affect women, our study aims to make a difference by enhancing financial literacy and entrepreneurial aspirations through innovative methods. We are conducting a randomized controlled trial to evaluate the impact of two specific interventions: a mobile game designed to improve financial knowledge and decision-making, and an inspirational documentary aimed at boosting the entrepreneurial drive among women participating in the FINCA community bank program. This study explores whether these interactive and engaging tools can help women become more financially independent and successful in their business ventures. By examining the effects of these interventions alone and together, we hope to understand better how learning and motivation can lead to economic empowerment. The findings from this research will contribute to the ongoing efforts by the Ugandan government and various stakeholders, including the Central Bank of Uganda and international organizations, to promote financial inclusion and empowerment among women.

Intervention

Our intervention consists of two main components designed to enhance financial literacy and elevate entrepreneurial aspirations among Ugandan microentrepreneurs, focusing particularly on women. The first component is a mobile phone-based financial literacy application called "Farm Finance," which utilizes gamification techniques to teach essential financial principles. This app aims to make learning about finance engaging and interactive, encouraging participants to apply what they learn in real-world scenarios effectively.

The second component is an aspirations documentary that showcases successful local women entrepreneurs. This documentary is intended to inspire and motivate participants by presenting relatable role models and success stories. The combination of these interventions is based on the theory that improved financial literacy, coupled with elevated aspirations, leads to better financial decision-making, increased business revenues, and empowerment.

Each intervention has been carefully designed with a deep understanding of the local context to ensure cultural sensitivity and relevance. We obtain prior consent from all participants, ensuring confidentiality and their right to withdraw at any stage. Additionally, we closely monitor the intervention's impact to address any unintended negative consequences, adhering to high ethical standards throughout the study​

Experimental design

Our study utilizes a randomized controlled trial (RCT) design to rigorously assess the impact of two distinct interventions aimed at improving financial literacy and elevating entrepreneurial aspirations among women in Uganda. The experimental design is structured to provide a clear, unbiased evaluation of the interventions’ effectiveness across several dimensions of women's empowerment.

Randomization:
Participants are randomly assigned to one of four groups to ensure that any differences in outcomes can be attributed to the interventions rather than pre-existing differences among participants:

Treatment Group 1: Receives the mobile-based "Farm Finance" financial literacy game.
Treatment Group 2: Watches an inspirational documentary designed to elevate entrepreneurial aspirations.
Treatment Group 3: Receives both the "Farm Finance" game and the aspirations documentary.
Control Group: Receives no intervention during the study period but is provided access to the interventions after the study's conclusion, ensuring ethical fairness.
Blinding:
While it is not feasible to blind participants to the type of intervention they receive (due to the nature of the interventions), data analysts and outcome assessors are blinded to the group assignments to prevent bias in data interpretation and outcome assessment.

Data Collection:
Data are collected at three critical points: baseline (prior to intervention), immediately post-intervention, and follow-up (six months after the intervention). This allows us to assess both the immediate and the longer-term impacts of the interventions. The data collection includes quantitative measures from surveys and qualitative data from focus groups and interviews.

Outcome Measurement:
Primary outcomes include improvements in financial literacy, changes in entrepreneurial aspirations, and overall economic empowerment, measured through a combination of direct testing, self-reported surveys, and behavioral observations. Secondary outcomes assess broader socio-economic impacts and participant satisfaction with the intervention.

Ethical Considerations:
The study adheres to high ethical standards, with all procedures approved by relevant institutional review boards. Participants are informed about the study's purpose, their rights as participants, and are free to withdraw at any time without any consequences.

This design ensures a rigorous evaluation of the interventions, providing credible, valuable insights into their effectiveness in enhancing financial literacy and aspirations among women in Uganda. The results are expected to inform future policies and programs aimed at women's economic empowerment in similar contexts.

Design details

Randomization method
In our study, randomization is conducted using a computer-generated sequence to assign participants to one of the four groups. This method ensures that the allocation process is both random and unbiased, crucial for maintaining the integrity of a randomized controlled trial (RCT). Details of the Randomization Process: Sequence Generation: A random number generator software is utilized to create the allocation sequence. This software is programmed to ensure equal probability of assignment across all intervention and control groups. Implementation: The randomization sequence is generated by a researcher who does not have direct contact with participants to minimize any potential bias. Once generated, the sequence is used to assign participants based on a unique identifier assigned to them at the time of their enrollment in the study. Blinding: To further ensure the objectivity of the trial, those involved in data collection and analysis are blinded to which group participants have been assigned. This blinding remains in place until the final analysis phase is complete. This computerized randomization process is chosen for its precision and ability to handle large datasets efficiently, making it ideal for our study's scope and scale. The method's transparency and reliability support the trial's goal to produce valid and generalizable findings.
Randomization unit
The randomization in our study is conducted at the individual level, ensuring that each participant has an equal chance of being assigned to any of the treatment or control groups. This approach is particularly suited to the interventions being tested, which are designed to measure the impact of financial literacy and aspirations enhancement tools on individual behavioral outcomes. Details of Randomization Units: Primary Unit: Each participant serves as an individual randomization unit. This method is chosen because the interventions – a digital financial literacy game and an inspirational documentary – are delivered and experienced on an individual basis, even when discussions or group activities follow the interventions. Secondary Considerations: While the primary randomization is at the individual level, we also consider the composition of groups in community sessions where discussions about the documentary take place. These groups are formed post-randomization and are structured to ensure diversity and a mix of different treatment exposures. However, these group formations do not constitute a separate level of randomization but are a part of the intervention's delivery mechanism designed to enrich the interaction and learning experience. This individual-level randomization ensures that the study can precisely attribute differences in outcomes to the interventions themselves, minimizing confounding variables that might arise from group dynamics or interactions. This method is rigorous in maintaining the scientific validity of the study's results.
Clusters
Our study does not utilize clustering in its experimental design. Each participant is individually randomized to one of the treatment groups or the control group, ensuring that the intervention's impact is assessed on a personal basis. Number of Clusters: 0 This means there are no aggregated units such as schools, villages, or other groups where treatments are administered collectively. All interventions are directed at individuals, and thus, each participant represents a single, separate unit in the analysis.
Observations
In our study, we plan to enroll a total of 700 participants, each serving as an individual observation unit. This number reflects the total number of women who will be individually randomized to one of the four groups (three intervention groups and one control group). Number of Observations: 700 participants This setup allows for a direct and precise analysis of the intervention effects on financial literacy and entrepreneurial aspirations, ensuring robust statistical power to detect meaningful differences between the treatment and control groups.
Arms
Total Number of Participants: 700 Distribution by Treatment Arms: Financial Literacy Game Group: 175 participants Aspirations Documentary Group: 175 participants Combined Intervention Group: 175 participants Control Group: 175 participants Each participant serves as an individual observation unit, and the equal distribution across the four groups ensures that each intervention and the control condition are robustly evaluated for effectiveness. This balanced allocation facilitates accurate comparative analysis of the interventions’ impacts on the primary outcomes of financial literacy improvement, entrepreneurial aspiration fulfillment, and economic empowerment.
Primary outcomes
Financial Literacy Improvement: Measurement: Overall enhancement in participants' financial literacy, assessed via comprehensive financial literacy tests conducted before and after the interventions. These tests gauge the ability to make informed financial decisions and apply key financial concepts in real-life situations. Specific Indicators: Progress is monitored through periodic quizzes during the intervention, assessing knowledge acquisition in areas such as budgeting, investing, and risk management. Entrepreneurial Aspirational Fulfillment: Measurement: Evaluation of the achievement of entrepreneurial goals set during the aspirations documentary phase and any subsequent adjustments in aspirations. Specific Indicators: Follow-up interviews and surveys are used to assess whether participants have realized their set goals and established new, higher aspirations. Economic Impact: Measurement: Examination of changes in borrowing capacity, enterprise revenues, and profitability attributable to enhanced financial literacy and elevated aspirations. Specific Indicators: Financial records review and participant self-reports at the end of the intervention period, with additional follow-ups at six and twelve months to gauge sustained economic impacts.
Sponsors
Name: University of San Francisco Location: 2130 Fulton St., San Francisco, CA, 94117 Url: https://www.usfca.edu/
Partners
Name: FINCA Uganda Partner_type: none Url: https://finca.org/locations/africa/uganda

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords