Impact of an intervention for senior high-schoolers aiming to facilitate access to information on higher education and student life, to enable them to make informed career choices in France

How to cite

Souali, Laïla; Huillery, Elise; Souidi, Youssef; Chevallier, Coralie. 2024. "Impact of an intervention for senior high-schoolers aiming to facilitate access to information on higher education and student life, to enable them to make informed career choices in France." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013613. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13613-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Laïla Souali* , Elise Huillery , Youssef Souidi , Coralie Chevallier

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013613
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13613-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-09-03 – 2030-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13613

Abstract

Despite the massification of higher education in France over recent decades, inequalities in access to higher education persist. Access rates to higher education vary widely according to parental income (Bonneau and Grobon, 2021). Moreover, when enrolled in higher education, students attend different types of courses depending on their social background (Bechichi et al., 2021). This raises questions of both efficiency and equity, as both the private and public benefits of higher education can be substantial (Fack and Huillery, 2021).

The first reason put forward to explain these inequalities in access is the difference in school results according to social origin. However, beyond this explanation, other factors have been put forward. In particular, socially disadvantaged students' lack of information and self-confidence can influence their aspirations (Guyon and Huillery, 2021; Terrier et al., 2023). The “Vers le Sup'” program, developed by the Article 1 NGO, aims to address these very factors.

The research protocol aims to observe the effects of the “Vers le Sup'” program on students' aspirations and self-confidence, as well as on their progress in higher education and professional integration.

Approved by the French Ministry of Education, the Article 1 NGO is rolling out “Vers le Sup'”, a program designed to help high-school students make the right career choices, accredited by the French Ministry of Higher Education and Research.

Article 1’s interventions include three modules:
- The inspire-orientation.org platform. This is an entirely free website for career guidance. It helps high school students plan their post-baccalaureate careers by providing information on study paths, in line with their results and interests. In addition, a network of student volunteers can be mobilised to answer students' more specific questions about the courses of study they are considering. Registration on this site takes place during the workshop.
- The “Se projeter vers le Sup'” workshop. This is a two-hour in-class workshop, led by student volunteers, to provide students with information on career guidance and to help them project themselves into higher education and student life.
- Mentorat Vers le Sup', a personalised support scheme, enabling general and technological high school seniors who wish to benefit from the support of a student mentor to help them in the transition between the end of high school (from January) and entry into higher education (until December).

There will be two types of interventions, I1 and I2:
I1: Year 12 students benefit from the “Se projeter vers le Sup'” workshop and have access to the inspire-orientation.org platform.
I2: Year 12 students benefit from the interventions proposed in I1. In addition, individual mentoring is offered to volunteer students.

The comparison between these two types of interventions will enable us to measure the additional benefit of offering mentoring to students, compared with the I1 intervention. Impacts will be measured by comparing the same indicators for all students (control, I1, I2). Our first aim is to establish the impact of the interventions on outcomes collected at the end of the senior high-school year (knowledge of higher education, self-confidence aspirations) and beyond (highest diploma, match between students’ initial aspirations and their diploma, number of years spent to obtain their diploma and professional integration).

Intervention

Article 1’s interventions include three modules:
The inspire-orientation.org platform. This is an entirely free website for career guidance. It helps high school students plan their post-baccalaureate careers by providing information on study paths, in line with their results and interests. In addition, a network of student volunteers can be mobilised to answer students' more specific questions about the courses of study they are considering. Registration on this site takes place during the workshop.
The “Se projeter vers le Sup'” workshop. This is a two-hour in-class workshop, led by student volunteers, to provide students with information on career guidance and to help them project themselves into higher education and student life.
Mentorat Vers le Sup', a personalised support scheme, enabling general and technological high school seniors who wish to benefit from the support of a student mentor to help them in the transition between the end of high school (from January) and entry into higher education (until December).

Experimental design

The evaluation protocol is based on a randomised controlled trial with 3 arms: I1, I2 and a control group in which no intervention is delivered. 58 high schools are included over three school years (2023-2024, 2024-2025, and 2025-2026). Randomization takes place at the cohort*high school level. In each high school, cohorts are randomised to one of three groups, as summarised in Table 1 :
In Group A, the 2023-2024 cohort of Year-12 students receives the I2 intervention, the 2024-2025 cohort receives no intervention and the 2025-2026 cohort receives the I1 intervention.
In Group B, the 2023-2024 cohort of Year-12 students receive the I1 intervention, the 2024-2025 cohort receives the I2 intervention and the 2025-2026 cohort receives no intervention.
In Group C, the 2023-2024 cohort of Year-12 students receives no intervention, the 2024-2025 cohort receives the I1 intervention and the 2025-2026 cohort receives the I2 intervention.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done by the research team using STATA.
Randomization unit
Randomization takes place at the cohort*high school level. We stratified on high school characteristics. We constructed strata with three schools with smallest distance in baseline characteristics and then we randomised within each stratum the three schools into the three experimental arms.
Clusters
The treatment is clustered at the cohort*school-level, so we have 174 clusters.
Observations
In each high school, one to four classes of year-12 students are included, with an average of 3 classes per high school. A total of 174 year-12 classes are included each year, which corresponds to a total of 522 classes over the 3-year study period. The final administrative sample will include approximately 13 050 students (25 per class). The final survey sample will include approximately 10 440 students, accounting for a 20% attrition due to absenteeism.
Arms
In each of the 58 high schools, one cohort out of the 3-year study period belongs to each treatment arms. Therefore there are 58 clusters in each treatment arm, which represents on average 174 classes.
Primary outcomes
Knowledge about careers and higher education Knowledge about financial aid Perceived self-efficacy (i.e., self-assessment of chances of success in higher education) Expected sense of belonging Degree of peers influence on higher education choices Degree of family influence on higher education choices Degree of certainty with respect to career choices Average prestige of students’ wishes in Parcoursup, prestige being measured by the average baccalauréat grade of students enrolled in a given track at the national level Average prestige of students’ top 3 wishes in Parcoursup Prestige of students’ final choice in higher education, i.e., the track students get enrolled in (prestige being measured by the average baccalauréat grade of students enrolled in a given track at the national level) Indicator of whether students passed the exams each year in higher education Indicator of whether students dropped out higher education Number of time students repeated a year in higher education Number of time students changed their track in higher education Prestige of students’ final educational attainment, prestige being measured by the average baccalauréat grade of students who attain this level of education at the national level. Time in employment during the first year after higher education Labour income during the first year after higher education International Socioeconomic Index (ISEI) of occupations during the first year after higher education Social transfers during the first year after higher education

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords