The persistent effect of narratives: additional mechanism and long-term effects
How to cite
Liu, Manwei; Zhang, Sili. 2024. "The persistent effect of narratives: additional mechanism and long-term effects." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013582. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13582-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study is a follow-up of the project “The persistent effect of biased narratives: Evidence from an online experiment”, preregistered in the AEA RCT registry (AEARCTR-0005595). The current study adds five new treatments (between subjects), plus one auxiliary treatment, to the original study to explore additional mechanisms for why narratives have persistent effects and whether the persistent effects of narratives are long-lasting.
Intervention
First, in Phase I, we vary whether subjects are exposed to one of the two narratives (pro-GMO or anti-GMO) first or both narratives (in random order). In Phase II, we vary whether subjects are immediately provided with the exact narratives from the other side that they did not see in Phase I, or they are provided with more arguments to counteract the influence of the Phase I narratives, which is scheduled two weeks after Phase I.
Experimental design
In the two mechanism treatments, Pro.Nrt and Anti.Nrt, subjects are randomly exposed to one of the two narratives (pro-GMO or anti-GMO) in Phase I. In a third treatment, Both.Nrt as a benchmark for this new set of treatments, subjects are exposed to both narratives (in random order). In Phase II, subjects in Pro.Nrt and Anti.Nrt are provided with the exact narrative from the other side that they did not see in Phase I.
Two additional treatments, Pro.Long, Anti.Long, are identical to the Exogenous treatments in the original study except that the two phases are two weeks apart. They are added to test whether the persistent effects of narratives are long-lasting. In Phase I (the first session), subjects are randomly exposed to one of the two narratives (pro-GMO or anti-GMO). Phase II (the second session), where subjects are provided with more information to counteract the influence of the Phase I narratives, is scheduled two weeks after the first session.
We implement one auxiliary treatment, Both.Long, in which subjects' average donation functions as the target of estimation of Pro.Long and Anti.Long.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.