Team-Up to Move-Up: Team Interactions and Social Mobility

How to cite

Zarate, Roman Andres; Caicedo, Santiago; Guerra, Jose-Alberto. 2024. "Team-Up to Move-Up: Team Interactions and Social Mobility." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013577. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13577-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Roman Andres Zarate* , Santiago Caicedo , Jose-Alberto Guerra

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013577
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13577-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-09-01 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Colombia ()
JEL codes
C92, C93, J71, J24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13577

Abstract

This project aims to understand how team interactions between individuals of different socioeconomic levels affect social mobility in Latin America. We will conduct a series of lab-in-the-field experiments to explore whether the opportunities for low-income individuals to move up the labor market ladder depend on their productivity and how they are perceived in environments populated by high-income individuals. Specifically, our project seeks to understand how the socioeconomic composition of a team affects team performance and whether revealing or concealing information about these characteristics impacts others’ perception of abilities, team interactions, and the recognition of leadership within a group. Our findings can provide insights into how team interactions can impede social mobility, thereby guiding public policies to enhance social mobility in the region.

Intervention

Participants will complete a series of individual and team tasks on Play Together, a platform designed to assess and enhance teamwork and leadership skills among secondary and tertiary education students through performance-based tasks. The platform was developed by one of the co-PIs. We will assess teamwork abilities and study team interactions with the platform with students at flagship university in Colombia.

The tasks on the platform were selected following the existing literature on teamwork in organizational studies (Woolley et al., 2010), psychology (Hall & Watson, 1970), and economics (Weidmann & Deming, 2021). Specific examples of the tasks include the Guilford test of alternative uses, where participants come up with ideas about how to use an object; reproducing art, where participants reproduce the pattern of a color grid; and Raven's Progressive Matrices, where participants identify the missing element that completes a pattern. Other tasks are specifically associated with the measurement of teamwork, including "Lost at Sea" and "Lost on the Moon", where participants first individually and then in teams need to rank fifteen objects in order of importance to survive. To ensure the reliability and validity of the measurement of teamwork and leadership skills, we will complement these tasks with academic tests compatible with the coursework of the participants in our project. These tests will cover various subjects, including microeconomics and macroeconomics. In general, while previous research has employed some of these tasks and tests to assess individual abilities, our methodology aligns with recent studies that employ them to investigate contributions within a team dynamic beyond individual abilities (Weidman & Deming, 2021).

The platform has two different stages for most of the tasks. First, participants solve the tasks individually, allowing us to measure individual abilities. At this stage, we also collect other measures of non-cognitive skills and social preferences (personality, trust, social perceptiveness). In the second stage, participants solve the tasks in teams. For most of the tasks, participants need to agree on their answers to proceed on the platform. For other tasks, such as “Reproducing Art”, participants need to coordinate their actions to make progress as a team. During the group stage, participants can communicate with their teammates via chat boxes. The use of chat boxes to assess collaborative problem-solving skills has been validated in other contexts—such as the PISA assessment of collaborative problem-solving abilities (OECD, 2017)—and mimics current workplace practices where chats are an important tool for coworkers to communicate.

The main interventions will take place at the team stage. There are two levels of randomization in the experimental design:

1. Team composition: Participants will be randomly assigned to either single-income-level teams or mixed-income-level teams, conditional on their socioeconomic status. For example, low-income individuals can be randomized either to an all-low-income team or a mixed-income team. In this case, there would be three types of groups: all-low-income teams, all-high-income teams, and income-mixed teams.
2. Information: The second randomization is the information about team members that is revealed or not to participants. Here, we will have three treatment arms:
a. Anonymous: all activities will be anonymous.
b. High school revealed: we will reveal the graduating high school as a signal of income in Latin America.
c. Names: we will reveal names that signal both income and other information about participants.

Experimental design

The experimental design has two levels of randomization:

1. Team composition: Depending on their income level, high or low, participants can be assigned to a single-income level or to a mixed-income level team.
2. Information: a team can be randomly assigned to three levels of information: (a) anonymous, (b) high school revealed, (c) names (identities) revealed.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the participant for the type of team and it is the team for the information treatment.
Clusters
1. 720 participants for the type of team randomization: 300 low-income and 300 high-income. This derives into the following types of teams: a. 60 high-income teams. b. 120 mixed-income teams. c. 60 low-income teams. 2. 300 teams for the information randomization stratifying by the type of team: a. Anonymous: 100 teams with 50 of each type of income level. a. High school: 100 teams with 50 of each type of income level. a. Names: 100 teams with 50 of each type of income level.
Observations
For outcomes at the individual level: 600 observations. For outcomes at the team level: 200 observations. For outcomes at the dyad level: 2160 observations. For outcomes at the task level: 1200 observations with each team completing 5 tasks.
Arms
1. 720 Participants, with 360 being low-income and 360 high-income: 180 participants of each group are assigned to a single-income level team, and 180 to a mixed-income team. 2. 240 teams for the information treatment: 80 teams are assigned to the anonymous treatment arm, 80 to the high school revealed arm, and 80 to the names revealed arm. This randomization is conducted by stratifying the type of team, and we expect 20 segregated teams of each income type and 40 mixed-income teams to be assigned to each information treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
1. Leadership nominations 2. Performance metrics
Secondary outcomes
1. Preferences for teammates 2. Ratings of communication and teamwork 3. Disagreement within a team 4. Chat interactions

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords