Building an inclusive workforce: an intervention to empower women police in India

How to cite

Bernhardt, Arielle; Kruks-Wisner, Gabrielle; Mangla, Akshay; Sukhtankar, Sandip. 2024. "Building an inclusive workforce: an intervention to empower women police in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013555. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13555-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Arielle Bernhardt* , Gabrielle Kruks-Wisner , Akshay Mangla , Sandip Sukhtankar

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013555
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13555-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-09-01 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13555

Abstract

Women worldwide face hurdles integrating into male-dominated professions, be it finance, technology, economics, or politics. Difficult work environments might prevent women from advancing in such workplaces, or even drop out. These problems are exacerbated in India, where women’s labor force participation rates are abysmally low to begin with (~20%), and even lower in professions like the police (~10%). Though the police constable position is considered to be an attractive job, many women drop out at various stages of the recruitment process, as well as after starting their first posting. Yet women’s role in the police is critical, as shown in multiple studies. In partnership with the Madhya Pradesh state police, we evaluate interventions designed to mitigate female constables’ social and professional isolation in a male-dominated work environment, and ideally improve retention and advancement. Using a mixed-methods approach – combining qualitative fieldwork, surveys, and randomized evaluation – we study the impacts of providing mentorship or peer support to new women recruits during their first posting.

Intervention

We evaluate two interventions designed to strengthen new women constables’ social and professional networks: (1) mentorship from a senior woman in the police force and (2) support via the presence of a same-gender peer.

The interventions are timed to coincide with the posting of new female and male constable recruits across police stations in Madhya Pradesh. New female recruits who are assigned to the mentorship program will be paired with a higher-rank woman officer at their police station with whom they will regularly meet for check-ins and to review the tasks and duties involved in constable work. Prior to commencement of the program, mentors receive training regarding activities to be conducted with their mentees and guidance on how to create a positive working and learning environment for their mentee. If no suitable female mentors are available, the new woman recruit is assigned a senior male mentor. New female recruits who are assigned to the peer intervention are posted at a police station alongside at least one additional new female recruit.

Experimental design

Our unit of randomization is the police station. We randomly assign 322 police stations across 17 districts (pop. ~33 million) due to receive new constables to one of four arms: (1) Base - these police stations receive one new woman constable, and follow business-as-usual procedures for the integration of new recruits; (2) Female mentor - these police stations receive one new woman constable, and she is offered participation in a mentorship program run by a senior female mentor; (3) Female peer - these police stations receive at least two new women constables; (4) Pure control - these police stations receive no new women constables. Across all groups, the total new recruits assigned (male + female) is meant to be kept constant.

Within each of the 17 study districts, we stratified police stations by the first principal component of a vector of police station characteristics (total number of existing officers; share female officers; number of senior female officers). We randomized our treatment and control arms within these strata, with 77 stations in the first treatment arm (base; one new female constable), 74 stations in the second treatment arm (female mentor; one new female constable); 73 stations in the third treatment arm (two new female constables); and, 98 stations in the control arm.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer using Stata
Randomization unit
Police station
Clusters
322 police stations
Observations
Approximately 900 new constables (300 female and 600 male) and 2,500 existing officers at sample police stations
Arms
Seventy-seven police stations are assigned to treatment arm 1 (base); 74 stations are assigned to treatment arm 2 (female mentor); 73 stations are assigned to treatment arm 3 (female peer); 98 stations are assigned to treatment arm 4 (control/ no female).
Primary outcomes
(1) New women constables’ working conditions; (2) aspirations of women constables and retention within the police force; (3) women constables’ support networks; (4) male constable attitudes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords