The higher you climb, the harder you fall: on career mothers and their identity

How to cite

Montinari, Natalia; Pisanelli, Elena; Vitellozzi, Sveva; Barigozzi, Francesca; Fort, Margherita; Monfardini, Chiara; Biroli, Pietro. 2024. "The higher you climb, the harder you fall: on career mothers and their identity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013509. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13509-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Natalia Montinari* , Elena Pisanelli , Sveva Vitellozzi , Francesca Barigozzi , Margherita Fort , Chiara Monfardini , Pietro Biroli

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013509
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13509-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-12-15 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D1, J16, J22, J13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13509

Abstract

Previous research (Kuziemko et al. 2018) indicates that women, particularly those with higher education, adopt more negative attitudes toward female employment post-parenthood and find the experience of motherhood more challenging than anticipated. Additionally, more-educated mothers across countries allocate more time for childcare (see Guryan et al. 2008). Our hypothesis posits that highly educated women, who have constructed their adult identities around their careers, experience amplified societal pressures to prioritize childcare, creating a tension with their earlier career-focused values. Utilizing a unique dataset comprising self-reported identities pre- and post-motherhood, along with time-use diaries from couples with young children, we analyze partners’ time allocation, and household arrangements, including chore distribution and satisfaction levels, by partners’ employment status, income, education, and personal backgrounds. Our investigation delves into the association between women's identities and both partners' perceptions of social norms, views on gender roles, time spent with children, relational dynamics, income, and educational levels.

Intervention

The study proposes a survey experiment in which participants are randomly assigned, with equal probabilities, to two conditions which vary the order of elicitation of i)perceived social norms and ii)personal values about the role of women as main caregiver within the family. The target population consists of cohabiting couples with at least one cohabiting child, and the oldest child is younger than 11. We aim to test for heterogeneity of the effect based on income, demographic characteristics, baseline gender norms and time use within the couple.

Experimental design

The study proposes a survey experiment in which participants are randomly assigned, with equal probabilities, to two conditions which vary the order of elicitation of i)perceived social norms and ii)personal values about the role of women as main caregiver within the family. The target population consists of cohabiting couples with at least one cohabiting child, and the oldest child is younger than 11. We aim to test for heterogeneity of the effect based on income, demographic characteristics, baseline gender norms and time use within the couple.

Design details

Randomization method
The platform where the survey is administered using a CAWI methodology, randomly assigns responends to one of the two conditions (i.e. ex-post we expect about 50% of respondents in each condition). The two conditions vary the order of elicitation of the (perceived) social norm and personal value.
Randomization unit
Individuals.
Clusters
The total number of individuals is 1,000.
Observations
The total number of individuals is 1,000.
Arms
500 in order 1: social norm - personal values 500 in order 2: personal values- social norm
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are the personal values and the perceived social norms of women as main caregivers within the family; the self-reported relative importance of different dimensions in life (e.g. family, career, friendship) before and after the birth of children.
Secondary outcomes
We control for education, income, socio economic background of both partners, general views about the role of women in the society views on gender roles, time spent with children, relational dynamics, income, and educational levels.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords