Effects of a Business Incubator Experiment in Nigeria

How to cite

Tang, Yulu; Kaul, Rupali; Nwokolo, Arinze. 2024. "Effects of a Business Incubator Experiment in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013435. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13435-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yulu Tang* , Rupali Kaul , Arinze Nwokolo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013435
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13435-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-04-15 – 2025-03-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13435

Abstract

Increasing the productivity of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) is a key challenge in emerging markets. While management training for SME owners might improve firm performance, existing research shows modest impacts. In this study, we further explore the impacts of management training, with a specific focus on peer interactions among entrepreneurs during accelerator and incubator programs. We aim to investigate two questions: (1) how do peer effects among startups affect future business growth and performance? (2) what are the mechanisms behind peer effects and heterogeneity on the basis of the gender of the entrepreneur and the stage of the business?
To answer these questions, we partner with Impact Hub Lagos to conduct a randomized controlled trial among firms participating in a business support program. These firms are either established startups participating in the acceleration program or non-established high-growth potential ventures at the idea stage participating in the incubation program. All firms will be assigned to chat groups within an online collaboration platform to stimulate peer interaction and feedback. Over two months, we will use an incentive scheme to encourage firms in the treatment group to ask and answer questions from each other regarding sales and financial management concepts covered during their programs. We will conduct two follow-up surveys at 2 months (short-term) and 12 months (long-term) after the baseline to collect data on firms' business outcomes. Furthermore, to test collaboration or competition between firms, we will run an award experiment offering a $500 prize at the end of the training. A random subset of entrepreneurs will be informed about this award. We will monitor award applications and survey responses to assess information transfer among entrepreneurs regarding the award, which helps gauge collaborative and competitive dynamics. We will also assess heterogeneity in award information sharing based on treatment status. Results from this study can provide policy-relevant guidance on supporting SMEs through peer-based business training models.

Intervention

Our intervention takes two steps. In the first step (Training intervention), firms will be divided into three groups: (1) full treatment group, (2) semi-treatment group, and (3) Control group. For all firms in the full treatment group, and for half of firms in the semi-treatment group, we will use an incentive scheme to encourage firms in the treatment group to ask and answer questions from each other regarding sales and financial management concepts covered during their programs.
In the second step (Information experiment), we will run an award experiment offering a $1000 prize at the end of the training. A random subset of entrepreneurs will be informed about this award, but all firms are eligible to apply for the award. We will monitor award applications and survey responses to assess information transfer among entrepreneurs regarding the award.

Experimental design

The main goal of this project is to conduct a randomized controlled trial to study the impact of peer effects on the performance of startup firms in business accelerator programs. These accelerator programs usually have two main components. First, they provide these young firms with training on running businesses. Second, they connect entrepreneurs with potential investors. Therefore, participants in the same programs can both collaborate and learn from each other’s skill sets and compete with each other for potential funding opportunities. We aim to analyze and untangle the impact of these two forces on firms’ performance.

We will conduct two experiments: (1) training intervention and (2) Information experiment.

In the training intervention, all firms will be divided into three groups: (1) 133 firms in the full treatment group, (2) 69 firms in the semi-treatment group, and (3) 173 firms in the Control group.
For all firms in the full treatment group and for half of the firms in the semi-treatment group, we will randomly form WhatsApp groups of 3 firms and use an incentive scheme to encourage firms in the treatment group to ask and answer questions from each other regarding sales and financial management concepts covered during their programs. We will then conduct surveys and collect all chat history from WhatsApp to understand what type of information these firms share with each other and how peer interactions affect business performances.

Design details

Randomization method
We will prerandomize in office using a random number generator in Stata.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Treatment is assigned at the individual level.
Observations
355 individuals
Arms
For the (1) training intervention: 133 individuals in the full treatment group, 69 individuals in the semi-treatment group: 69, and 173 in the control group For the (2) Information experiment: number of people to be informed of the award: 120. From full treatment group: 37. From semi-treatment group: 23. From control group: 60.
Primary outcomes
- firms' sales, the number of workers, the range of business activities, and ratings from experts - firms’ knowledge of other participants and the intensity of their interactions with each other - the list of firms that apply for the award
Secondary outcomes
- firms' interactions with other participants in the program

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords