Fighting gender stereotypes through narratives in gender roles and growth mindset- a RCT in Uruguay

How to cite

Brun, Martin; Gomez-Ruiz, Marcela; Marino, Maria; Ramos, Xavier. 2024. "Fighting gender stereotypes through narratives in gender roles and growth mindset- a RCT in Uruguay." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013425. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13425-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Martin Brun* , Marcela Gomez-Ruiz , Maria Marino , Xavier Ramos

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013425
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13425-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-04-23 – 2024-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I24, J16, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13425

Abstract

This research project investigates how the exposure to different role models impact children’s interest in STEM fields. We design a field experiment integrated within a Computational Thinking (CT) teaching proposal in Uruguay to explore two critical hurdles in children’s interest in STEM: gender and growth mindset beliefs. We will manipulate a teaching module called ‘Write your own adventure’ - provided in the initial level of CT - and randomly assigned classes to one of four different biographies of accomplished scientists. These biographies will manipulate (i) either the gender (male or female) scientist, or (ii) the extent of growth mindset (whether they succeeded or they had to overcome academic struggles since the young age). We will assess the impact on children’s interest in STEM across the 4 biographies and a control group exposed to another teaching module unrelated to the previous biographies. Finally, we will shed light on the underlying mechanisms by analyzing how children gender stereotypes and norms, and beliefs about growth mindset change when exposed to different role models. Our results will contribute to better understand how to foster an environment where all children can pursue and reach their full potential.

Intervention

Our intervention introduces four different treatments within the framework of the "Write Your Own Adventure" proposal to investigate the impact of gender stereotypes and growth mindset on students’ academic perceptions. To achieve this, we will manipulate the biographies used in the proposal and the narratives embedded in the biographies. Specifically, two treatments will present biographies of male scientists, while the remaining two will present biographies of female scientists. Within each gender category, one biography will provide a general narrative over the scientist’s life and achievements, while the other will provide a narrative of scientists with growth mind-set. The latter implies that the scientists are portrayed in terms of their academic struggles, detailing the challenges faced during their formative years, and illustrating how they overcame these obstacles through effort, perseverance, and daily diligence to ultimately attain success in the field of science. We choose an active control group compose by classes engaging in a completely unrelated proposal within the CT program called "Animociones".

The script related to the four manipulations of the "Write Your Own Adventure" will be collaboratively designed by the researchers and extensively discussed with the CT’s team. The inclusion of this content in the curricula needs mutual agreement between both parties. The script for the "Animociones" proposal in the control group was designed by Ceibal for this project.

For a successfully implementation of the intervention, teachers will be trained. Ceibal will provide materials to support teachers in effectively incorporating these treatments into their classroom practices and facilitating the translation of these concepts to students. For example, it is important for teachers to emphasize the notion that failures should not be interpreted as a deficiency in innate ability or intelligence, but rather as powerful stimulus that propels individuals toward the achievements of their goals. By conveying the message that perseverance, effort and regularity play a pivotal role in the learning process, teachers can empower students to embrace challenges, develop a growth mindset, and cultivate a resilient approach to achieving their objectives.

Experimental design

This study will exclusively target 5th and 6th-grade teachers and their students from urban, public schools in Uruguay (i.e children aged around 10 and 11 years). Participant teachers will be randomly assigned to 5 different arms, resulting in five distinct groups. Additionally, remote teachers will be randomly assigned to specific classrooms, allowing us to investigate potential variations in gender stereotypes associated with the gender of the remote teacher (male/female).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
School, clustered by socio-demographic characteristics
Clusters
60 schools, clustered by socio-demographic characteristics
Observations
2640 students
Arms
528 students per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
Interest in STEM jobs
Secondary outcomes
Confidence / Stereotypical thinking / Growth mindset / Maths preferences / Language Preferences / Maths performance

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords