Digital communication overload in the hybrid workplace. Can it be contained?

How to cite

Tojerow, Ilan. 2024. "Digital communication overload in the hybrid workplace. Can it be contained?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013406. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13406-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ilan Tojerow*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013406
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13406-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-04-18 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J28: Safety • Job Satisfaction • Related Public Polic, J81: Working Conditions, I31: General Welfare, Well-Being, M12: Personnel Management • Executives; Executive Compensation
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13406

Abstract

Since the pandemic, working a couple of days per week remotely from home has become the norm in many organizations. This transition, while granting newfound flexibility, also presents challenges. Employees may feel compelled to remain constantly connected to the workplace, particularly because digital communication tools enable virtual accessibility from anywhere. Research suggests a correlation between employee well-being and productivity regarding email and meeting practices. In this research, we conduct a randomized controlled trial (RCT) within a Belgian public administration to assess the impact of nudges (focusses) aimed at alleviating digital communication overload. The study seeks to assess how these nudges affect employee productivity and well-being.

The intervention involves proposing to managers and employees a specific set of “best” organisational practices (nudges) intended to improve operational efficiency. These nudges primarily address the utilization of digital communication tools, such as email, scheduling meetings, and techniques for disengaging from work. The objective is to provide strategies that minimize unnecessary communication and meetings while optimizing the effectiveness of these communication channels. Further details regarding the practical application and execution of the intervention will be elucidated below.

Intervention

In this research, we initiate a randomized controlled trial (RCT) in a Belgian public administration to assess the impact of nudges targeting and managing digital communication overload. Specifically, the intervention involves proposing a concrete set of “best” organisational practices to managers and employees, aimed at reducing/managing the volume of emails and meetings, as well as alleviating workplace connectivity pressure. The nudges align closely with the administration’s best practice guide. They focus on the use of (digital) communication tools such as emails, chats, and telephone, as well as the organization of meetings and methods for disconnecting from the workplace.

Between April and June, individuals will receive six brief well-being surveys to gauge general job satisfaction and wellbeing at work. Upon completing a survey, individuals will encounter one of six different nudges. Subsequently, a few days after the short well-being surveys, another email containing a permanent link to the nudges will be sent. Following the intervention, a longer well-being survey will be administered.

The information intervention is randomly assigned to teams of employees at the lowest hierarchical level within the organization, along with a subset of their direct managers. Managers who are simultaneously overseeing such a team and leading direct managers of other teams are excluded from this phase of the experiment to avoid information spillover from their subordinate managers, as some could potentially be assigned to the treatment group. Similarly, managers and teams directly managed by individuals informed about the experiment are also excluded. This leaves us with 216 teams comprising 1,200 employees and a subset of 130 direct managers of the 216 teams included in the experiment.

Experimental design

This research aims at measuring the collective impact of the intervention on the 1,200 employees and 130 direct managers participating in the experiment. Initially, individuals are stratified into four strata based on the inclusion status of the team manager in the experiment (see the description of the inclusion criteria in the experimental details) and by the gender of this manager. Within these strata, sub-strata have been established based on team size, resulting in 3 sub-strata within the first stratum and 3 within the subsequent ones. Within these sub-strata, individuals are then randomly assigned by team (“cluster”) to either the treatment or control condition.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done by a random number generator on a computer.
Randomization unit
The randomization is done at the team level.
Clusters
216 clusters: one for each team to which the employees belong
Observations
130 managers and 1,200 agents (employees): in total 1,330 individuals.
Arms
For the employees: 108 clusters are treated and 108 are not treated. 652 individuals are assigned to the control group and 548 individuals are assigned to the treatment group. For the managers: 65 in the treated group and 65 in the control group.
Primary outcomes
We measure the effects on primary outcomes separately for the employees and the managers included in the experiment up to one year after the experiment. We will consider three data sources: a) register data of the employees of the public administration, b) survey data and c) the experimental data (of the information intervention). A) Register data Productivity metrics linked to the use of emails and meetings - Average duration of meetings on MS Teams per week - Number of meetings per week on MS Teams - Email volume (sent, received and read) sent on average per day B) Survey data - General job satisfaction/well-being
Secondary outcomes
We evaluate the effects on primary outcomes independently for both the employees and the managers participating in the experiment for up to one year post-experiment. We will utilize three data sources: a) registry data from the public administration employees, b) survey data, and c) the experimental data from of the information intervention. A) Register data Absenteeism metric categorized by the following two reasons: 1) sickness and 2) holidays leave - A binary indicator equal to one if a person was absent for a reason for at least half a day due one of the above reasons within the first six months after the start of the experiment - The total time a person was absent due to one of the above reasons as a fraction of the contractual working time within the first six months after the start of the experiment Productivity metrics associated with the utilization of chats - Number of private chats (on Teams) recorded on average per working week B) Survey data In the longer well-being survey which will be administered after the intervention (in connection with an internal survey administered by the public administration) our aim is to evaluate the following constructs: - Perceptions of changes in the work environment related to emails and meetings - Dis-connection/detachment from work - General job satisfaction/ well-being - Work engagement - Self-perceived productivity C) Experimental Data Indicators of email opening/clicking behaviour (capturing treatment intensity): - An indicator that reveals whether the employee has responded to one or several of the short well-being survey, thereby indicating their engagement with the nudges - An indicator that reveals whether the employee has opened one or several emails with permanent links to the nudges - An indicator that the reveals whether the employee has clicked on one or several of the permanent links to the information within the different nudges List of moderators: - Gender  - The number of children   - The interaction between the number of children and the gender  - For employees assigned to the experiment, the treatment status of the direct manager: treated, not treated, or not participating in the experiment.  - The position in the firm - The team size

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords