Mentoring Small and Medium Micro-enterprises in Puebla, Mexico

How to cite

Karlan, Dean; Schoar, Antoinette; Bruhn, Miriam. 2016. "Mentoring Small and Medium Micro-enterprises in Puebla, Mexico." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001331. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1331-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Dean Karlan* , Antoinette Schoar , Miriam Bruhn

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001331
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1331-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2007-01-01 – 2015-04-03
Countries
Mexico (Latin America & Caribbean)
JEL codes
D21, D24, L20, M13, O12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1331

Abstract

Using a randomized evaluation with 432 Mexican small and medium enterprises, we show that access to
management consulting had positive effects on total factor productivity and return-on-assets (about 0.2
standard deviations, relative to the control group). Owners also had significant increase in
“entrepreneurial spirit” (an index that measures entrepreneurial confidence and goal setting). Using
Mexican social security data, we find a persistent large increase (about 50%) in the number of
employees and total wage bill even five years after the program. We document large heterogeneity in
the specific managerial practices that improved as a result of the consulting, but the three most
prominent areas are marketing, financial accounting, and long-term business planning.

Intervention

The intervention aims to expand the managerial skills by owner-managers of small and medium-sized enterprises in Puebla, Mexico by giving them access to subsidized consulting and mentoring services. Treated enterprises were matched with one of nine local consulting firms based on the specialized services they needed. Enterprises met with their consultants for four hours per week over a one year period. The enterprise owner and consulting firm decided jointly on the focus and scope of the consulting services based on a daylong diagnostic consultation between the enterprise and the consulting firm.

Experimental design

The aim of this study was to test whether alleviating the constraints on managerial capital has a first order effect on the performance and growth of small enterprises in emerging markets, and if so, which dimensions of managerial capital are particularly important for firm performance. A randomized control trial was set up in Puebla, Mexico, where 432 micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises applied to receive subsidized consulting services, and 150 out of the 432 were randomly chosen to receive the treatment. The remaining 282 enterprises served as a control group that did not receive any subsidized consulting services. The study measured the impact of the intervention on firms and owner-managers in two different ways: surveys were administered at baseline and a one-year follow-up, and confidential administrative data were obtained on employment levels and total wages for the firms in the treatment and control groups.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was stratified by sector (manufacturing, services, and commerce) and enterprise size (micro, small, and medium-sized)10 and was conducted through a Stata program that was run on the premises of IPPC in the presence of government officials and a public notary, who certified that the assignment to the treatment group was random, i.e., not re-run depending on any particular assignment.
Randomization unit
Individual sectors (manufacturing, services, or commerce) and individual enterprise size categories (micro, small, and medium-sized)
Clusters
Three sectors (manufacturing, services, or commerce) and three enterprise size categories (micro, small, and medium-sized)
Observations
432 enterprises
Arms
282 enterprises control 150 enterprises treatment (of which 80 decided to participate in the treatment)
Primary outcomes
Avg. sales Jul, Aug, and Sep 2007 (1000s USD) Sep 2007 costs (1000s USD) Profits (Sep 2007 sales minus costs, 1000s USD) Business assets (1000s USD) Full-time paid employees Average sales Dec 2008, Jan and Feb 2009 (1000s USD) Feb 2009 costs (1000s USD) Profits (Feb 2009 sales minus costs, 1000s USD) Productivity residual Return on assets (ROA) Number of employees Daily wage bill

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords