Behavioral Interventions to Advance Self Sufficiency – Next Generation (BIAS-NG), Wayne County Head Start Attendance
How to cite
Anzelone, Caitlin; Katz, Lawrence. 2024. "Behavioral Interventions to Advance Self Sufficiency – Next Generation (BIAS-NG), Wayne County Head Start Attendance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013272. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13272-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Behavioral Interventions to Advance Self-Sufficiency-Next Generation (BIAS-NG) project is supported by the Office of Planning, Research, and Evaluation in the Administration for Children and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. BIAS-NG aims to make human services programs work better for the people receiving services by reshaping program processes using lessons from behavioral science, an interdisciplinary field that incorporates psychology, economics, and other social sciences to provide insight into how people process information, make decisions, and take action. BIAS-NG partners with state and local agencies to identify a challenge to address, investigate its possible causes, design an intervention informed by behavioral science to address the causes, and test the efficacy and cost efficiency of the intervention relative to status-quo service delivery. For this study, BIAS-NG worked with two Early Head Start/ Head Start programs in Wayne County, Michigan, to use behavioral insights to design and test a proactive messaging strategy intended to improve daily child attendance.
Based on conversations with program staff and participating families and analyses of program administrative data, the BIAS-NG research team focused efforts on understanding challenges to consistent daily child attendance. The BIAS-NG team found that the vast majority of children in both programs were chronically absent—defined as missing 10% or more of school days—across three academic years. In the 2022-23 school year, average daily attendance was 76% in one program and was 65% in the other. Low attendances rates mean that Head Start participants may miss out on important opportunities and resources that can impact child and family outcomes. Beyond absences likely resulting in missed learning opportunities for children, absences also create administrative burden and instructional challenges for program staff.
The research team conducted interviews with program staff and participating families to identify potentially malleable behavioral barriers to consistent attendance, rather than focusing on tough to move structural barriers (e.g., transportation) or unavoidable causes of absences (e.g., illness). Identified behavioral barriers included families not receiving the right proactive information for attendance at the right time given programs’ focus on reactive attendance communications (once a child misses a substantial proportion of school) as opposed to proactive ones. Diagnosis activities also suggested that many families felt a limited sense of connection to program staff and other families in the program. Stronger bonds with staff and between families might encourage families to come to school to see people they have connections with and may also increase access to school (e.g., transportation vouchers) and non-school (e.g., a carpool) resources to support attendance.
In response to these behavioral barriers, the research team developed an intervention involving sending families positive, proactive messages via text and email aimed at improving child attendance. The messages are described further in the Intervention section. The positive, proactive attendance messaging intervention is intended to promote more consistent daily attendance by (a) underscoring the importance of attendance for child development, (b) helping families feel more connected to the program, and (c) highlighting supports available to help families get to the program. The messages are hypothesized to positively impact child attendance, as measured by number of days attended, average daily attendance, and chronic absenteeism rates.
To evaluate the impact of the messages, families in the two Head Start programs were randomized to either an intervention group receiving approximately three messages per week over 15 weeks or to a control group receiving no additional supports. Analyses after the intervention will consider whether randomization to the intervention group improved children’s attendance outcomes during the intervention and in the month following the conclusion of the intervention. Exploratory analyses will consider whether impacts vary by individual, classroom, or center characteristics. In addition to the impact study, BIAS-NG is conducting accompanying implementation and cost analyses to document how the intervention was delivered and at what cost.
Intervention
BIAS-NG’s positive, proactive attendance messaging intervention is intended to promote more consistent daily attendance in two center-based Early Head Start and Head Start (EHS/HS) programs by underscoring the importance of attendance for child development, helping families feel more connected to the program, and highlighting supports available to help families get to the program. The two EHS/HS programs offer full-day programming to children ages birth to five focused on promoting healthy development in a range of areas (e.g., cognitive, social-emotional, health). The intervention includes approximately three messages per week over 15 weeks that are sent via text and email to children’s primary caregivers. The messages employ behavioral strategies such as planning prompts that can support families in building routines that help them juggle multiple steps and competing priorities, messaging that encourage family-to-family connections designed to build social capital, and personalization from a designated staff member to build trust and connections with program staff. This approach builds on several studies showing the positive impacts of sending families regular text messages about the importance of attendance and about their specific child’s attendance behaviors.
Experimental design
The impact evaluation uses a randomized controlled trial design. Participating families have an equal (50/50) chance of being assigned to the intervention or control groups.
All families enrolled in center-based early education programs at either agency who (1) have a mobile phone number on record and (2) have opted in at the start of the school year to receive messaging from the program were randomized to either the intervention group or control groups. Randomization was at the family level rather than child level given that some families have multiple children enrolled in the programs, meaning that child level randomization could result in some caregivers being assigned to both the intervention and control groups.
Randomization was stratified by center to ensure an equal balance of intervention and control group members within each center. This method also ensured that each program has balanced randomization groups. The random assignment process followed these steps:
• Step 1: Obtain Administrative Data and Determine Eligible Sample Programs created a dataset of all families presently enrolled. This file included ChildPlus ID, ChildPlus Family ID, program name, center of enrollment, number of enrolled children in family, date of birth, phone number, and whether they’ve opted in/out to receive ChildPlus messages.
• Step 2: Randomize Families After receiving the data of enrolled participants, the research team randomized families using the MDRC random assignment web tool. New files, containing the original participant data (i.e., the administrative data generated and shared in step 1) and the newly generated random assignment group indicator, were shared back with programs.
• Step 3: Program Intervention Group into ChildPlus Research team staff worked with program staff to create a field in ChildPlus indicating if a family is in the intervention group.
• Step 4: Send Messages Using Random Assignment Families assigned to the intervention group receive the intervention messaging campaigns while those assigned to the control group receive status quo messaging.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.