Improving Skills Development and Employability through Traditional Apprenticeships: Evidence from Senegal

How to cite

Aubery, Frederic; Giles, John; Marazyan, Karine; Syll, Mame Mor Anta. 2024. "Improving Skills Development and Employability through Traditional Apprenticeships: Evidence from Senegal." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013252. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13252-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Frederic Aubery* , John Giles , Karine Marazyan , Mame Mor Anta Syll

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013252
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13252-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-12-11 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12, J24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13252

Abstract

In Senegal, a significant share of adolescents who leave formal education before completing middle school seek to learn skills through informal apprenticeships, and young adults who have completed informal apprenticeships have more stable employment than similarly skilled youths who have not chosen this path. Despite its attractiveness among less educated youth, informal apprenticeship training in Senegal is characterized by low quality, long duration (five years on average) and a lack of certification. Neither the sectors involved, nor the apprenticeships are regulated, and so the content of the training depends only on a workshop’s activity, which varies considerably within trades. To improve skills transfers through the traditional apprenticeship system, the PEJA program (“Improving Youth Employability through Informal Apprenticeships”), implemented by the Ministry of Employment, Vocational Training, Apprenticeship and Integration (MFPAI), aims to standardize training, improve the breadth and depth of skills training, introduce certification processes for both apprentices and masters, and strengthen the capacity of crafts person professional associations.

The PEJA project seeks to facilitate skills transfer to apprentices by providing equipment grants to master craftspersons, along with providing additional training (technical skills, business skills and socio-emotional skills) to craftspersons and apprentices alike, and then introducing additional incentives for apprentices to complete formal certification of their skills. The main beneficiaries are young informal apprentices, aged 15 to 25, and their masters. It is worth noting that the program does not place youth in workshops: beneficiaries are apprentices who have selected themselves into apprenticeships before the beginning of the program. The project targets urban areas, where traditional apprenticeships are more prevalent: it is implemented in the four departments of the Dakar region and in 15 regional capitals or economic hubs.

This experiment is conducted on the first wave of the implementation of the PEJA. Of the eight trades targeted by the first wave, our experiment focuses on five (Tailoring, woodwork, metalwork, auto mechanics, and hairdressing). It relies on two surveys (baseline and endline) and the random assignment to a treatment group.

Intervention

The PEJA project (“Improving Youth Employability through Informal Apprenticeships”) seeks to facilitate skills transfer to apprentices by providing equipment grants to master craftspersons, along with providing additional training (technical skills, business skills and socio-emotional skills) to craftspersons and apprentices alike, and then introducing additional incentives for apprentices to complete formal certification of their skills. The main beneficiaries are young informal apprentices, aged 15 to 25, and their masters. It is worth noting that the program does not place youth in workshops: beneficiaries are apprentices who have selected themselves into apprenticeships before the beginning of the program. The project targets urban areas, where traditional apprenticeships are more prevalent: it is implemented in the four departments of the Dakar region and in 15 regional capitals or economic hubs (Diourbel, Fatick, Kaffrine, Kaolack, Kedougou, Kolda, Louga, Matam, Mbacke, Mbour, Saint-Louis, Sedhiou, Tambacounda, Thies, and Ziguinchor). In its first wave the program targeted workshops from 8 trades (tailoring, metalwork, woodwork, auto-mechanics, hairdressing, market gardening, refrigeration/air conditioning, processing of fruits and vegetables).

At the level of the apprentice, the PEJA consists of the following interventions:
- Literacy training for illiterate apprentices. Apprentices were assigned to this treatment based on their level of formal education.
- Business skills training. Business skills training was provided in class. It followed the Start and Improve your Business curricula (with a focus on “Generate your business idea” and “Start your business”) adapted for the apprentice population.
- Socio-emotional skills training. The training was provided in class and covered self-esteem, self-affirmation, sense of initiative, compliance with commitment, risk-taking, communication, problem solving, perseverance, and networking.
- Two one-time cash transfers to enable youth to embark on a path of self-employment. First, an economic inclusion cash transfer (US$200, with a 50 percent premium for women) provided to young apprentices, conditional on participation in the business training. Second, a performance-based cash transfer (US$216 with a 100 percent premium for women) provided to apprentices who have obtained validation of their skills.

At the master craftsperson level, the PEJA interventions aimed at benefiting apprentices indirectly through an improvement of their learning environment. This includes the following components:
- Technical training for masters. Once the masters’ needs have been identified, the project supported a technical training (5 days in class). This activity was expected to expand the scope of technical skills transferred and to improve the quality of apprenticeship training.
- Business skills training. Business skills training was provided in class. It followed the Start and Improve your Business curricula (with a focus on “Improve your business”).
- Socio-emotional skills training. The training was provided in class and covered self-esteem, self-affirmation, sense of initiative, compliance with commitment, risk-taking, communication, problem solving, stress management, teamwork, conflict resolution and leadership.
- Pedagogical skills training. This training aimed at improving the transmission of technical skills to apprentices.
- Capital grant to upgrade the technology used in the workshop. Equipment (worth US$2,000 on average) was provided to masters after an assessment of their needs during the business skills training.

Experimental design

This study follows a cohort 6129 apprentices and 2144 master-craftpersons over time, with a baseline survey (December 2020-January 2021) and a endline survey (September 2023 – March 2024). The identification strategy for the impact of the PEJA relies on the random assignment of masters and apprentices, eligible to the PEJA, to one of the two treatment groups or to the control group. The unit of selection is the workshop: when a workshop is selected a master and his/her apprentices are all assigned to the same group. The two treatment arms are (1) a full package and (2) an alternative package that includes all the components of the full package but the socio-emotional training for masters and apprentices.

At both rounds the survey covered a whole range of apprentices and masters characteristics, including mathematics and reading skills (for apprentices only), socio-emotional skills, business skills, technical skills (for apprentices only), and attitude regarding disciplining measures.

We will estimate the effect of the PEJA by comparing learning and employment outcomes between apprentices assigned to the to the full package treatment group and the control group. The specific impact of socio-emotional training will be obtained by comparing apprentices and masters of the two treatment groups.

Additionally, to estimate the effects of any spillovers and/or displacement effects, we will compare outcomes of apprentices in control neighborhoods to those from control workshops within treatment neighborhoods. Indeed, for tailors only, the assignment to treatment was done through a two-step sampling process, with selection clusters first randomly assigned to treatment and control and then treated workshops randomly selected in treatment selection clusters only.

Design details

Randomization method
Assignment to the two treatment groups was donein February 2021 using Stata and QGIS. The selection protocol differs for tailors and the other four trades. The selection was performed at the workshop level. When a workshop is selected, the master and his/her apprentices are all beneficiaries of the same treatment arm. In the few cases where two sampled masters were in the same workshop, the two of them (and their respective apprentices) are allocated to the same group. For woodworkers, metalworkers, auto-mechanics and hairdressers, the selection was stratified by trade and localities (19 localities). For tailors, the selection followed a more complex protocol to assure variation in the distance to the nearest treated workshop: 1. First, we identified proximity clusters using workshop GPS locations. Two workshops within 300 meters of each other (240 meters in secondary cities) are considered part of the same cluster. 2. The 284 identified clusters were classified into three categories depending on their size: 157 clusters with only one workshop, 115 middle size clusters and 12 large clusters. 3. For each category, a sixth of the clusters were randomly selected to be pure controls, meaning that all workshops were allocated to the control group. 4. In the remaining clusters, in each locality, workshops were randomly assigned to the two treatment groups.
Randomization unit
The selection was done at the workshop level. When a workshop is selected, the master and his/her apprentices are all beneficiaries of the same treatment arm. In the few cases where two sampled masters were in the same workshop, the two of them (and their respective apprentices) are allocated to the same group.
Clusters
2124 workshops. 1 to 4 apprentices were interviewed per workshop.
Observations
At baseline: 6129 apprentices, under the supervision of 2144 master craftspersons, in 2124 workshops.
Arms
- 2166 apprentices and 754 masters (in 745 workshops) in the full package treatment - 1990 apprentices and 696 masters (in 690 workshops) in the alternative treatment group - 1973 apprentices and 694 masters (in 689 workshops) in the control group
Primary outcomes
At the apprentice level, the main outcomes of interest will be: - Test scores: Mathematics and reading test scores, Socio-Emotional Skills scores. (decision making, personal initiative, perseverance, self-control, expressiveness, collaboration, negotiation. and listening), technical skills. business skills. - Status with regard to apprenticeships training: Apprentice still in training as of endline survey, Total training duration as of endline survey, Successful completion of the apprenticeships training, Apprentice was certified since baseline. - Employment and income: Employment status as of endline survey, work intensity, type of employment (self-employment, employee, family worker), sector of employment, income from main and secondary occupation, Entrepreneurship (apprentice has created his/her own business as of endline survey). - Exposure to physical discipline. At the master/ workshop level - Tests scores: Business skills scores, Socio-emotional skills. - Status in the profession: Master artisan is still operating his business as of the endline survey, Number of apprentices in charge as of endline survey, Master artisans got certified since baseline. - Attitudes toward disciplinary measures - Business performance: Business failure as of endline survey, Logarithm of sales, profit and master’s income. - Business structure / vertical integration: Business size, Business workforce composition, Retention of apprentices, Human capital of new apprentices.
Secondary outcomes
At the apprentice level, we will measure the following secondary outcomes: - Marital status - Motherhood and fatherhood - Migration out of Senegal at the time of the survey.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords