Mobility Opportunity Vouchers to Eliminate Disparities Study

How to cite

Pollack, Craig; Deitch, Rachel. 2024. "Mobility Opportunity Vouchers to Eliminate Disparities Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013232. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13232-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Craig Pollack* , Rachel Deitch

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013232
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13232-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-04-12 – 2028-10-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13232

Abstract

The Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2019 (Pub. L. 116-6) and the Further Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2020 (Pub. L. 116-94) authorized HUD to implement and evaluate the Community Choice Demonstration. As described in the Federal Register Notice Docket Number FR-6191-N-01, HUD is implementing a multi-site randomized controlled trial (RCT) to test and evaluate the effectiveness of the Demonstration. The primary purposes of the Demonstration are to provide voucher assistance and mobility-related services to families with children to encourage such families to move to lower-poverty areas, to expand their access to opportunity areas, and to evaluate the effectiveness of the strategies pursued under the Demonstration (AEARCTR-0009805).

The Mobility Opportunity Vouchers to Eliminate Disparities (MOVED) Study builds on the Demonstration and will investigate how and for whom neighborhoods shape obesity and diabetes risk by sampling 900 adults and children enrolled in the Community Choice Demonstration across 3 sites (Pittsburgh, PA; Cuyahoga, OH; and Nashville, TN). Researchers will collect baseline and 2-year follow-up data for one adult and one child in each household in the comprehensive mobility services group and the control group, will assess obesity and diabetes risk among adults (measured BMI and HbA1c) and obesity among children (measured BMI z-score) and will examine mechanisms by which housing mobility may impact health outcomes, including behavioral (adult-diet, physical activity, sleep), psychosocial (adult-mental health, social support), contextual (food outlets, walkability, health care access), and structural (family-racial discrimination, exposure to violence, neighborhood segregation, collective efficacy, utilization of social services) factors using surveys, accelerometry, and geospatial analyses. Specifically, the proposed research aims to:

Aim 1. Investigate (a) the extent to which adults who receive comprehensive mobility services (“treatment group”) exhibit changes in obesity and diabetes risk (BMI and HbA1c) after 2 years compared to a control group (no mobility services), and (b) the extent to which children in the treatment group exhibit changes in obesity (BMI z-score) after 2 years compared to a control group. We will explore whether these relationships vary by baseline characteristics.

Aim 2. Examine whether adults and families in the treatment group exhibit changes in behavioral, psychosocial, contextual, and structural factors after 2 years relative to the control group. We will explore to what extent these factors mediate changes in adult obesity and diabetes risk and changes in child obesity risk.

Intervention

MOVED is an observational study that recruits families participating in the Community Choice Demonstration. The Community Choice Demonstration is a multi-site randomized controlled trial that will study the effects of two interventions. The first intervention, Comprehensive Mobility-Related Services (CMRS), will provide a comprehensive set of services that aims to address all of the principal obstacles that housing choice voucher participants experience accessing lower-poverty areas, including financial barriers, knowledge and skill gaps, hesitancy on the part of families to move to opportunity areas, hesitancy on the part of property owners in opportunity areas to participate in the housing choice voucher program, and challenges that affect families’ ability to stay in opportunity areas once there. The second intervention, Selected Mobility-Related Services (SMRS), will test up to three bundles of services selected from the broader CMRS to determine whether they can effectively assist families in accessing opportunity areas at a lower cost. The MOVED study will recruit families who are randomized to receive CMRS and to the control groups. Participants from the SMRS study intervention will not be recruited.

Experimental design

To minimize selection bias, we will use an intent-to-treat design, where individuals are analyzed according to the study group to which they were randomized, regardless of whether they moved to a lower-poverty neighborhood.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
900 households
Observations
900 adults, approximately 837 children
Arms
450 adults in each treatment arm, 418 children
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes for adults 1) Body Mass Index 2) Hemoglobin A1c Primary outcomes for children 1) Body Mass Index z-score
Secondary outcomes
1) Waist circumference (adults and children), continuous and categorical, measured in-person at the umbilicus using a measuring tape 2) Categorized BMI (adults) based on clinically meaningful cutpoints for obesity 3) Categorized BMI percentiles (children) based on clinically meaningful cutpoints for obesity 4) Categorized Hemoglobin A1c (adult) based on clinically meaningful cutpoints for prediabetes and diabetes. 5) Systolic and diastolic blood pressure, continuous and categorical cut-points based on clinical def-inition 6) Accelerometry measured physical activity, sedentary time, and sleep (adults and children) 7) Eating habits: a. NCI Dietary Screener converted to predicted daily intake of fruits and vegetables (cup equivalents), added sugars (teaspoons), whole grains (ounce equivalent), fiber (grams), and frequency of red and processed meat consumption using publicly available formulas from the National Cancer Institute b. Number of meals per week consumed away from home; meals consumed per week from fast food or pizza locations c. Perception of nutritional environment regarding fruit and vegetables in neighborhood d. Food shopping habits (i.e., typical stores for shopping, transportation and distance to stores) e. Frequency of dieting in past year; binge eating behaviors in past year; medication use to lose weight or manage diabetes in past year f. Eating to Cope using 5 item scale from the Emotional Eating Scale; weight stigma; satis-faction with body weight and shape g. Home food environment based on 4 items concerning space to prepare meals, store food, have meals as a family, and cook 8) Food security based on the USDA 6-item short form food security survey module; receipt of food assistance (SNAP, WIC, school meals) 9) Physical activity defined as meeting minimal physical activity recommendations using IPAQ; MET minutes per week 10) Perceived walking environment; types of places participants go for physical activity 11) Sleep duration and quality based on 3 items from the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index 12) Mental health including screening for depression based on Patient Health Questionnaire-8 and anxiety based on Generalized Anxiety Disorder-2; perceived stress based on the Perceived Stress Scale-4 13) Experiences of discrimination based on Everyday Discrimination Scale 14) Perceived safety of streets during day and night; concerns about gun violence in neighborhood; policing based on 3 items 15) Current tobacco use 16) Frequency of binge drinking 17) Collective efficacy based on the 10 item Collective Efficacy Short Form 18) Bonding social capital (i.e., having friends from different educational and racial or ethnic back-grounds) 19) Perceived social support based on adapted 10 item survey of informal social support 20) Perceived constraints measured using 5 items from the sense of control perceived constraints subscale 21) Predictability based on single item 22) Self-rated happiness 23) Healthcare use and access based on type of insurance coverage; having a usual source of care, time since last check up and time since last dental visit; and overnight hospitalizations in the past 12 months; delays in care 24) Self-rated health 25) Diagnosed conditions including mental health, asthma, diabetes, and hypertension 26) Health-related quality of life measured using the EuroQOL 5-D 27) Transportation, including vehicle access, public transportation, and transportation to food store 28) Housing and neighborhood conditions measured by interviewer observation 29) Geospatial measures such as access to retail food, street connectivity, greenspace 30) Child-focused measures a. Sugar-sweetened beverage and water intake, assessed using an adapted 9-item Bever-age Intake Questionnaire (BEVQ); frequency of eating breakfast and eating lunch at school; frequency of eating meals as a family b. Physical activity assessed using single item from CDC Youth Risk Behavior Survey; sports team participation c. Perceptions of neighborhood substance use d. Criminal justice involvement using two items from the Family Options Study e. Sleep quality, assessed using 3 items from the Family Options Study f. Tobacco use g. Average screen time and social media use h. Mental health including depressive symptoms using the 2 item Patient Health Question-naire and anxiety based on 5 item Child Anxiety Related Emotional Disorders (SCARED) i. Life satisfaction measured using four items from the NIDA Monitoring the Future Study j. Experiences of bullying k. Asthma diagnosis and exacerbations l. Usual source of care; time since last check-up; emergency room use m. Educational aspirations n. Social connectedness o. Perceived safety p. Weight and body shape satisfaction; diet behavior; binge eating q. Educational aspirations based on likelihood of graduating high school, vocational school, 2-year and 4-year college r. Household chaos (i.e., environment interference/noise) measured using 6 items adapted from the Confusion, Hubbub, and Order Scale (CHAOS) s. Perceived home quality measured using a single question from the HUD Rent Reform Demonstration t. Perception of the home food environment u. School-related measures including time spent at school; perception of school; number of schools attended; types of schooling/childcare received; disruptions to schooling (e.g., repeated grades; expulsion, changing schools mid-year, and missing days of school); and transportation and travel time to school

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords