Financial Constraints to Exporting: Experimental Evidence from Rwanda

How to cite

Bergquist, Lauren; Bai, Jie; Lippitsch, Christian; Artinano, Ignacio Marra de; Nyarko, Stephen. 2024. "Financial Constraints to Exporting: Experimental Evidence from Rwanda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013231. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13231-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lauren Bergquist* , Jie Bai , Christian Lippitsch , Ignacio Marra de Artinano , Stephen Nyarko

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013231
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13231-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-11-11 – 2027-12-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O16, F13, L25, G21
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13231

Abstract

Export-led growth has long been seen as a key to unlocking structural transformation. In pursuit of this goal, low-income country governments often enact industrial policies to encourage firms to overcome barriers to exporting, such as subsidized or guaranteed credit designed to ease financial market failures. In this project, we propose a randomized controlled trials of one such policy. We partner with Rwanda’s Ministry of Trade and Industry, as well as the Development Bank of Rwanda (BRD), to evaluate Rwanda’s Export Credit Guarantee Fund (ECGF), which provides state-guaranteed loans to exporters (and potential exporters) and suppliers of exporters (and potential exporters). We generate exogenous variation in loan take-up by partnering with the BRD to conduct a door-to-door campaign with randomly selected firms, in which treated firms receive both promotional materials and application support. Randomization is stratified by firm location in the supply chain (downstream exporter vs. upstream supplier). Using a combination of unique administrative data access from the Rwandan Revenue Authority (RRA) and primary survey data collection, we measure the impact of the ECGF on firm performance, speak to optimal targeting along the value chain, and shed light on underlying mechanisms.

Intervention

The ECGF is an initiative conceived by Rwanda's Ministry of Trade and Industry (MINICOM), implemented by the Development Bank of Rwanda (BRD), and externally financed by the German Development Bank (KfW). The facility's primary objective is to provide loan guarantees for firms along export supply chains—including current exporters, potential exporters, and upstream firms supplying inputs to these exporters (and potential exporters). The ECGF aims to enhance these firms’ access to credit from private financial institutions by addressing collateral constraints.
1) We will use administrative data from the Rwandan Revenue Authority (RRA) including customs data, VAT tax data, corporate income tax data, and other datasets to estimate a model predicting likely adoption of the ECGF based on firm characteristics. This analysis will be accessed from an on-site secure RRA data facility. Given the focus of the ECGF, we included firms in tradable goods and services. Our final pool of firms will consist of ~5,000 that are i) current exporters, ii) potential exporters, iii) upstream firms that are selling to exporters or potential exporters.
2) We will then conduct a listing exercise with these ~5,000 firms. This exercise will be conducted mostly on the phone, with an in-person follow-up for a subset of those unreachable via phone. Firms will be given a short survey to collect additional contact information and gauge general interest in expanding access to credit and exporting. This will be used to screen out firms who (1) are hard to reach/unwilling to be surveyed; (2) do not express interest in increasing access to credit or (3) do not express interest in exporting in the future or supplying to exporters. Based on additional ECGF eligibility criteria (e.g. only domestic firms may participate) we expect this to result in a reduced target sample of ~2,000 firms.
3) We will randomize these ~2,000 firms into ~500 treatment and ~1,500 control. As detailed below in the Power Calculation section, we have chosen to have more controls than treated firms in this experiment due to the high cost of treatment relative to data collection, especially for outcomes available in the administrative data. In these cases, a greater number of controls is optimal for power given a fixed project budget (Duflo et al, 2006).

We will use the administrative data to stratify our randomization by value chain position, firm size and sector. Value chain position here is particularly important, as we intended to explore effects of treating upstream suppliers vs. downstream exporters along value chains, to speak to optimal targeting of industrial policies and propagation of effects through networks.

This administrative data from the pre-experiment period will be used to test for balance among treatment and control groups, as well as to serve as baseline controls in our analysis.

We will then conduct a door-to-door campaign in conjunction with the BRD for treatment firms. This campaign will be comprised of the following components:

(i) Pre-visit engagement: Firms will first be contacted via phone to confirm contact details, identify appropriate decision-makers, and schedule an in-person meeting. Follow-up calls will reconfirm the appointment, ensuring effective coordination.

(ii) In-person visits: Field officers will visit the firms, providing a detailed presentation on the ECGF program, including eligibility criteria, benefits, and application processes. Firms will receive informational handouts and contact details for further assistance. Officers will conduct a brief survey assessing the firms’ existing banking relationships, interest in ECGF financing, and readiness regarding required documentation. The officers will finally explain the available tailored assistance and schedule follow-up sessions.

(iii) Tailored application support: Interested firms will receive intensive, hands-on support to provide tailored assistance to interested firms, guiding them through each step of the loan application process to maximize the submission of high-quality, complete applications. This phase includes help with basic documentation and specialized assistance for sector-specific requirements. Support involves follow-ups to address technical or strategic challenges in coordination with private financial institutions (PFIs), continuing until application submission.

Once completed, the firms will submit their finalized applications through PFIs, with the BRD following the ECGF eligibly review and approval processes. This structured outreach and intensive assistance program serves as "randomized encouragement," enabling evaluation of ECGF's impact on firm outcomes.

Experimental design

Experimental Design (Public) *
1) We will use administrative data from the Rwandan Revenue Authority (RRA) including customs data, VAT tax data, corporate income tax data, and other datasets to estimate a model predicting likely adoption of the ECGF based on firm characteristics. This analysis will be accessed from an on-site secure RRA data facility. Given the focus of the ECGF, we included firms in tradable goods and services. Our final pool of firms will consist of ~5,000 that are i) current exporters, ii) potential exporters, iii) upstream firms that are selling to exporters or potential exporters.

2) We will then conduct a listing exercise with these ~5,000 firms. This exercise will be conducted mostly on the phone, with an in-person follow-up for a subset of those unreachable via phone. Firms will be given a short survey to collect additional contact information and gauge general interest in expanding access to credit and exporting. This will be used to screen out firms who (1) are hard to reach/unwilling to be surveyed; (2) do not express interest in increasing access to credit or (3) do not express interest in exporting in the future or supplying to exporters. Based on additional ECGF eligibility criteria (e.g. only domestic firms may participate) we expect this to result in a reduced target sample of ~2,000 firms.

3) We will randomize these ~2,000 firms into ~500 treatment and ~1,500 control. As detailed below in the Power Calculation section, we have chosen to have more controls than treated firms in this experiment due to the high cost of treatment relative to data collection, especially for outcomes available in the administrative data. In these cases, a greater number of controls is optimal for power given a fixed project budget (Duflo et al, 2006).

We will use the administrative data to stratify our randomization by value chain position, firm size and sector. Value chain position here is particularly important, as we intended to explore effects of treating upstream suppliers vs. downstream exporters along value chains, to speak to optimal targeting of industrial policies and propagation of effects through networks.

This administrative data from the pre-experiment period will be used to test for balance among treatment and control groups, as well as to serve as baseline controls in our analysis.

We will then conduct a door-to-door campaign in conjunction with the BRD for treatment firms. This campaign will be comprised of the following components:

(i) Pre-visit engagement: Firms will first be contacted via phone to confirm contact details, identify appropriate decision-makers, and schedule an in-person meeting. Follow-up calls will reconfirm the appointment, ensuring effective coordination.

(ii) In-person visits: Field officers will visit the firms, providing a detailed presentation on the ECGF program, including eligibility criteria, benefits, and application processes. Firms will receive informational handouts and contact details for further assistance. Officers will conduct a brief survey assessing the firms’ existing banking relationships, interest in ECGF financing, and readiness regarding required documentation. The officers will finally explain the available tailored assistance and schedule follow-up sessions.

(iii) Tailored application support: Interested firms will receive intensive, hands-on support to provide tailored assistance to interested firms, guiding them through each step of the loan application process to maximize the submission of high-quality, complete applications. This phase includes help with basic documentation and specialized assistance for sector-specific requirements. Support involves follow-ups to address technical or strategic challenges in coordination with private financial institutions (PFIs), continuing until application submission.

Once completed, the firms will submit their finalized applications through PFIs, with the BRD following the ECGF eligibly review and approval processes. This structured outreach and intensive assistance program serves as "randomized encouragement," enabling evaluation of ECGF's impact on firm outcomes.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done by the PIs.
Randomization unit
Firms will be randomized into treatment. We will stratify by value chain position, with three categories: (i) exporter, (ii) potential exporter and (iii) supplier of exporter or potential exporter, as we intended to explore effects of treating upstream suppliers vs. downstream exporters along value chains, to speak to optimal targeting of industrial policies and propagation of effects through networks. We will also stratify by aggregate sector: (i) agribusiness, (ii) manufacturing, (iii) services and (iv) wholesale and retail. Within each value chain position-sector stratum, we will rank firms by revenue and match by quadruplets—grouping every four consecutive firms into blocks. Within each quadruplet, one firm is randomly assigned to treatment (25% treatment rate), ensuring treatment and control firms are comparable in revenue within strata.
Clusters
NA
Observations
2143 Firms
Arms
1605 Firms Control, 538 Firms Treatment
Primary outcomes
Using a combination of administrative data (customs, VAT, corporate income tax, firm-level employee information from PAYE) and firm surveys we will measure the impact of the ECGF over several key outcomes: 1) Total firm credit access. 2) Firm revenue, employment and export performance 3) Spillover effects through forward and backward linkages
Secondary outcomes
1) Mechanisms affecting firms' performance outcomes: quality upgrading, certification, export promotion, capacity expansion, etc.
Sponsors
Name: International Growth Centre Location: United Kingdom Url: https://www.theigc.org/ Name: Structural Transformation and Economic Growth (STEG) - CEPR Location: United Kingdom Url: https://steg.cepr.org/ Name: Yale University Location: United States Url: https://www.yale.edu/ Name: PEDL Location: United Kingdom Url: https://pedl.cepr.org/
Partners
Name: Innovations for Poverty Actions Rwanda Partner_type: ngo Url: https://poverty-action.org/ Name: Development Bank of Rwanda (BRD) Partner_type: government Url: https://www.brd.rw/ Name: Rwanda Revenue Authority Partner_type: government Url: https://www.rra.gov.rw/en/home Name: Ministry of Trade and Industry of Rwanda (MINICOM) Partner_type: government Url: https://www.minicom.gov.rw/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords