Controversial Political Expression and Social Image Concern: Experimental Evidence from China
How to cite
Zheng, Tianyu. 2024. "Controversial Political Expression and Social Image Concern: Experimental Evidence from China." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013194. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13194-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project studies the motivations behind controversial political expression from the perspective of social image concern. On August 23, 2023, Japan initiated the discharge of treated radioactive wastewater from the Fukushima Nuclear Plant into the Pacific Ocean, a move that provoked significant backlash across Asian countries, particularly in China, where anti-Japan sentiment is deeply ingrained due to historical and geopolitical reasons. The study takes the unique context of the anti-Japan expression in China following Japan’s discharge to investigate the public expression towards this event. I hypothesize that public expressions are driven by two primary motivations: the anti-Japan ideology, which is controversial due to its association with extreme nationalism, and concerns about the environmental consequence, which constitute a non-controversial motivation. In a theoretical model, I show that increasing the perceived prevalence of non-controversial motivations among the public can encourage individuals to engage in controversial expressions by providing a "social cover". Conversely, increasing the perception of proportion of the public with a controversial motivation has theoretically ambiguous effect on individual decision. I then design two online experiments to test the model prediction.
Intervention
We will run two experiments. In both experiment, participants are asked to fill out an online survey. We will vary the information provided in the survey regarding second order beliefs about anti-Japan attitudes or environmental concern. Subsequently, participants are provided opportunity to sign a petition to oppose the release and boycott Japanese product. In experiment I, we additionally vary if the signature on the petition is observable or not.
Experimental design
Online Experiment I adopts a 2x3 factorial design to examine the effect of varied information on participants’ willingness to engage in public expressions of dissent. Participants are asked to fill out a survey related to environemtal issues. They are then segmented into three groups, each receiving different information:
• The first group receives information about the percentage of college students concerned about ocean pollution from our pilot survey.
• The second group receives information about the percentage holding negative views of Japan from our pilot survey.
• The control group receives no information.
Participants are then provided with opportunity to sign a petition opposing the wastewater discharge and boycotting Japanese products. At this stage, we manipulate the visibility of the petition signature: in one condition, signatures are public; in another, they remain anonymous.
Online Experiment II introduces information varying on the intensive margin. In this experiment, participants are divided into four treatment groups, with each group exposed to a different set of information regarding anti-Japan sentiment and environmental concerns: The first treatment group is provided with information indicating a high proportion of people holding anti-Japan view among a subset of survey participants. Conversely, the second group receives data showing a low proportion of such view. Similarly, the third group is informed about a high proportion of people concerning about ocean pollution, while the fourth group learns of a lower proportion, with each group’s information coming from different subsets of our data.
Following the introduction of this varied information, all participants are given the oppor- tunity to sign the same petition as in Experiment I, which opposes the wastewater discharge and supports boycotting Japanese products. To deepen our understanding of the mechanism, we also conduct a separate survey to elicit people’s belief about the motivations behind others’ decisions to sign the petition.
Recruitment for both experiments targets students from a specific local university in Beijing, using WeChat and email lists to reach prospective participants.
Hypothesis: Our theoretical model predicts that increasing the perceived prevalence of non-controversial motivations among the public can encourage individuals to engage in controversial expressions by providing a "social cover". Conversely, increasing the perception of proportion of the public with a controversial motivation has theoretically ambiguous effect on individual decision.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.